5 ms·
BMW to crowdsource the design of their megacity-centric future car
- justinjlynn 14y agoHonestly, I think it would be nice if we started designing cities to be single-occupant car unfriendly. There is a lot of wasted space that could be more efficiently used by both commercial and community owned and operated people moving technology that is currently used by parking structures, roads, alleys, and thoroughfares. At the very least, I think that point to point automated transit should be a highly preferable option for retrofit. But of course, this sells fewer cars to the general populace so we probably won't see anything like this from companies who's main revenue stream is from precisely that.
- EGreg 14y agoI completely agree. The auto manufacturers would sell less cars, but we'd have less cars parked on the road. With Google's self-driving cars, we would have driverless taxis that can take you somewhere, then go pick up someone else that called them with an app. Simple, convenient. The main reason to have your own car is for image and largesse. In a world of scarce resources, it might make more sense to share the cars. Might even have taxi carpooling.
- pchristensen 14y agotl;dr: Changing land use is the only way to make transit of any kind more effective than private cars. Technological improvements that made point-to-point transit as effective as private cars are completely infeasible due to social and societal constraints. Self driving cars will be a feature for users but will NOT change or accomodate existing cities. Point to point would be great, but it's really, really expensive and doesn't change the economics of land use. Look at what cars cost. Most US cities have ~1 car per adult, and to average expensive cars and paid off cars, let's assume ~$5000 in payments per car per year, plus about that much for gas, maintenance, insurance, etc. So ~$10,000/adult per year. Now assume with automated p2p 1 car can do the work of 10 private cars at the same vehicle cost. But barring some efficiency changes, operational costs would be the same as 10 cars, so each car would cost ~$55,000/yr. This means $5,500/adult, about half the cost of a private car - big savings! For a city of 1M, assume 50K cars, and you need almost $3B/yr just for the cars, the whole organization (gov or private) would probably cost another $1B. $4B/yr would be a big savings over private vehicles and free up all the space used by parking. Big caveats: 1) For reference, Nashville (~650K city, ~1.5M metro) had a mass transit budget of $60M, or about 1.5% of this back of the envelope budget. The entire municipal budget was $1.5B, or about 37% of this budget. This demonstrates that however beneficial such a system would be, it' would require a complete restructuring of government and society to shift that kind of spending into centralized transportation infrastructure. 2) These fairly affordable unit economics only work if everyone participates. But the system also only works if you continue to maintain the existing road network, which makes the switch from private cars that much more difficult to justify. 3) A p2p network is an attempt to get people who live in non-transit areas to use transit. But many (many many many) of those people live there specifically because they want privacy and seclusion from other people, so any kind of transit system is wrong on principle.
- thruflo 14y agoThose prizes are derisory.
- kmfrk 14y agoI assume they are subject to taxation, too.
- thejabus 14y agoFirst Sentence of the article: "What will the 2025 BMW be like? Know one knows for sure, which means your guess is more valid than you might thing." I know grammar isn't everything but two major typos before I even get into the article. How am I supposed to begin taking this seriously when I can barely read it.
- potatolicious 14y ago$5 says it ends up something like this: http://simpsons.wikia.com/wiki/The_Homer http://simpsons.wikia.com/wiki/The_Homer Seriously though, I'm not sure if the future megacities will really have many cars, at least not the personal vehicle variety. I'm sure BMW is looking for ideas, but IMO the solution is outside of the box they're willing to work within (i.e., private car ownership that is substantially similar to what we have today).
- danielweber 14y agoThis is 100% PR. They are not going to make any kind of car out of this.
- kmfrk 14y agoI think it is entirely possible that we will have cars as a method of public transportation instead of private. Perhaps a merging of taxis with what we today think of as public transportation.
- ctdonath 14y agoSelf-driving is obvious. The infrastructure will be in place to allow, if not require, highly automated traffic. Just get in the car and tell it where to go; leave navigation, congestion issues, etc. to the onboard computer linked to the city traffic network. Which obviously leads to an otherwise not obvious major design factor: round. Once the norm is for the occupying humans to not have much, if any, control in driving, the paramount drivetrain issue will be how to move the vehicle in any suitable direction on very short notice. Replace the "front wheels turn a few degrees" paradigm with zero-turn-radius or any-direction movement, and the vehicle's ideal shape is a circle. Seems obvious to me. What's not obvious to me is how crowdsourcing will come up with such a model. To wit: how does crowdsourcing overcome non-ingrained memetic patterns? ETA: BMW is partnering with crowdsourcing pros Local Motors of Phoenix to run the contest. Local Motors already has a crowdsourced, on-sale car to its credit, the Rally Fighter. Then the outcome of this contest will be amusing, as the Rally Fighter seems the utter opposite of the design pursued here.