5 ms·
Greeting Vocalizations in Domestic Cats Are More Frequent with Male Caregivers
- lawlessone 1y ago>it is therefore possible that male caregivers require more explicit vocalizations to notice and respond to the needs of their cats, which in turn reinforces cats' tendency to use more directed and frequent vocal behavior to attract their attention. This is very funny. Ig Noble prize stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ig_Nobel_Prize https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ig_Nobel_Prize
- x3n0ph3n3 1y agoDoes the study mention anything about how much male caregivers meow back?
- lawlessone 1y agoIt says females are more verbally interactive, possibly for cultural reasons , study was done in Turkey. Anecdotally i can see that being similar in europe though
- markhahn 1y agocats being cats, perhaps a little verbal reticence is what it takes to inspire them ;)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- abetusk 1y agoN=31 > We acknowledge that our sample size limits the generalizability of our findings on cat greeting behaviors.
- psunavy03 1y agoThat smacking sound you heard was stats professors facepalming across the world.
- moozilla 1y agoI also found this bit funny: > We also suspect that the geographical and cultural factors may have influenced interaction patterns, given that all our participants were residing in Türkiye.
- ddoolin 1y agoAnecdotally, my cats meow at me a lot. But they're my cats (others live in the house and help care for them). I also meow back more than anyone else. In fact, I might be the only one to do so. :)
- alexjplant 1y agoI used to meow back to my cat when he was younger for vocal modulation and pitch practice (lots of minor seconds and perfect fourths). This might have been a mistake as he's now very talkative, particularly when I'm on the phone.
- leoc 1y agoAlready, a solid 2026 Ig Nobel contender.
- gradus_ad 1y agoOr maybe they're more excited to see the male caregivers? Or maybe the male caregivers are louder themselves so they copy them? Or maybe...
- ASalazarMX 1y agoMaybe "Greeting Vocalizations in [These 31] Domestic Cats Are More Frequent with Male Caregivers"
- casey2 1y agoMaybe "" You couldn't write a book containing the context needed to qualify a factual statement about any of these cats. It seems even the article authors couldn't be bothered, writing only 5 pages after failing meet their nonsensical objective.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- siliconpotato 1y agoIf you read the paper, it suggests Turkish female caregivers are more vocal with their cats and understand their vocal cues more intuitively/don't need telling twice.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- SecondHandTofu 1y ago22 behavioral measures looking for one that is <0.05? Unless they pre-registered that prediction, isn't this just the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy?
- psunavy03 1y agop-hacking is a thing . . .
- EnPissant 1y agoYep! It's green jelly beans cause acne almost exactly.
- byronic 1y agowe asked seventy-four cats and you won't BELIEVE number eight
- canjobear 1y agoThey did a Bonferroni correction to the p values, which is supposed to compensate for this kind of thing.
- observationist 1y agoI can't wait for all the research papers from the "They Can Talk" talking buttons studies. Absolutely fascinating stuff coming out - pets apparently learn to understand not only simple words, but complex constructions and grammar, when sufficiently modeled by their people. They even chain together words in meaningful ways to augment their vocabulary and communicate complex ideas. Simple vocalizations are cool, but that's pretty limited communication, and if they're capable of so much more, it's pretty likely that they're using individual meows in much the same way a human would under the same constraints. Imagine only being able to say "HEY!" and having to use context and body language in every situation. TheyCanTalk have got n>10k animals so far, mostly cats and dogs, with a handful of pigs, rabbits, goats, and others. I've seen a few horses, cows, and others on social media, too, and they've got a lot more customers than study participants.
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 1y agoYeah it varies from individual to individual but the running theory I've seen is that cats can understand and interact with language at the level of a 3-4yo.
- phainopepla2 1y agoThis is an absolutely wild theory. 3-4 year-olds can speak in full sentences, and understand quite complicated language
- magixx 1y agoI would love to believe this but given my experience with my cat even single words are tough for them. For example my cat knows how to fetch her favorite toy but doesn't respond to the word "fetch" at all even with positive reinforcement (treats). The word "fetch" just doesn't mean anything for her even though I've paired it with the action of her fetch many times we play.
- jasonjmcghee 1y agoAnecdotally, the pitch/tone/voice you say something seems to matter more than the words themselves, to cats.
- blindriver 1y ago"n = 31" tells you how valuable this research paper is.
- jacquesm 1y agoWhat the cats really are saying is 'unshaved human alert, unshaved human alert'.
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoIn my house the occupants are divided into fur-faces, and bare-faces.
- jacquesm 1y agoThat could be the answer right there: kinship.
- fat_cantor 1y agoA lazy error [0] in the abstract suggests that the paper may have been written by a domestic cat (Felis catus). Given that male experimenters tend to stress out mice [1], it is plausible that the opposite effect occurs in cats. Mostly, it would be fun to know whether cat greetings reflect different motivational or emotional states, since reasonable people might believe that they don't. [0] "We also tested whether demographic factors such as the influenced the amount of greeting behavior expressed by household cats." [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2014.15106 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2014.15106
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46132439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46132439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46077728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46077728
- casey2 1y agoThey are not.
- tim333 1y agoThat was probably true with our cat. It was very 'talkative' when I came home. It also definitely distinguished between men and women, prefering to sit on the lap of women, preferably old ones.
- foxyv 1y agoThis makes me wonder if we could invent a constructed language that can be used by both cats and people. If people learned how to speak such a language, could they teach some of the basic vocabulary to cats too? I imagine it would be a pretty weird phonetic scheme. Cats have a ton of cool sounds they can make because they use them to lure in prey.
- telesilla 1y agoBecause our cat knows who the big softie is when asking for snacks (not me the woman of the house, who is more concerned that kittie will get too fat to fit through her cat door).
- stevenalowe 1y agoIs it because men don’t listen?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]