3 ms·
How so? The fact that the company is attempting to minimize legal liability doesn't mean that the contractor was truthful. Nor does it mean that people who est
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
How so? The fact that the company is attempting to minimize legal liability doesn't mean that the contractor was truthful.
Nor does it mean that people who estimated that P(story = true | writer sounds racist) < P(story = true) were incorrect.
- aristotelian 14y agoIt's not about who's right and who's wrong. It's about who has the power. The Kixeye CEO did exactly the right thing for his shareholders. He's also going to make a large payment to the OP, which will enable this obvious professional victim to live for years off his month of work. This is also the right thing to do - for the shareholders. The lesson for hiring managers is that you have to be very careful when hiring a member of a "protected class." You are effectively hiring them for a different position than your ordinary second-class citizens. It's not illegal to be an asshole to an ordinary second-class citizen. But a member of a protected class is effectively a noble, and a different set of legal norms apply to him. It is illegal to be an asshole to a member of this nobility. America is a nation of laws, and you have to follow the law. Kudos to the Kixeye CEO for realizing this. Why isn't it illegal for anyone to be an asshole to anyone else? A fascinating question. Worth thinking about. (And don't ask me how our country got to have "protected classes" at the same time as it got "equal protection under the law." Actually, the latter is legally derived from the former - believe it or not.)
- mikeash 14y agoIf the guy had been white and everybody had been racist toward him because of that, it would have been just as illegal.
- aristotelian 14y agoIt would have been. It wouldn't have been enforced, however. If you look at the history of civil rights jurisprudence, in the South before 1960 there were a lot of laws that looked race-neutral. Their actual intent was to keep black people from voting, however. It didn't fool the Supreme Court. Software patents are just as illegal. But what actually happens?
- mikeash 14y agoOh, sorry, when you started talking about "illegal" and all that, I thought you were actually talking about the, you know, laws.
- cynicalkane 14y agoMy God. Say what you will about affirmative action and discrimination law, but I assure you that minorities and women do not feel like "nobles" in America.
- aristotelian 14y agoOh, no, they sure don't! They feel like they're horribly oppressed. But when you look at the actual legal privileges that the actual legal and political system actually affords them - like the privilege not to be insulted, not to mention the 450 free points (blacks over Asians) on their SAT - what you see is almost exactly the kinds of privileges that medieval polities gave their nobilities. I guess there's no sumptuary laws or stuff like that.
- basseq 14y agoBTW, if anyone else was confused by the 450 SAT points comment, here's the detail: "To receive equal consideration by elite colleges, Asian Americans must outperform Whites by 140 points, Hispanics by 280 points, Blacks by 450 points in SAT (Total 1600)." From "No Longer Separate, Not Yet Equal: Race and Class in Elite College Admission and Campus Life" by Thomas J. Espenshade & Alexandria Walton Radford (2009) Source: http://80-20initiative.blogspot.com/2012/03/450-point-sat-gap-large-racial.html http://80-20initiative.blogspot.com/2012/03/450-point-sat-ga...
- taybin 14y agoYou're being ridiculous.
- mindslight 14y agoYour rant could be applicable if it were directed at an appropriate situation. This is not that situation. A major problem with racism is that it's a Schelling point for assholes. I presume the entire department isn't made up of racists, yet it takes just a few assholes to make it a hostile racist environment. OP's next gig may involve assholes as well, but those assholes (hopefully) won't be using the same insults, singling OP out, or abusing the same sore spots that OP sees throughout his life. Letting the common assholes devolve into racism makes it so OP would be unlikely to find somewhere free of being specifically picked on due to something he cannot change. (Hellbanning as a moderation system is unfortunate. If you are who I think you are, I suspect that the specter of inevitable banning is causing you to go for a shotgun comment approach rather than taking the time to compose something less emotional and more defensible)
- mikeash 14y agoPardon me for semi-hijacking the thread, but can you explain your comment about hellbanning being unfortunate? When I first read about the idea, I thought it was pretty ingenious. However, I haven't thought about it deeply, nor studied its true effects, so I'm interested in what makes you say that.
- mindslight 14y agoAs long as it's applied to those who you don't empathize with - spammers, one-liners, youtube style, etc - it's ingenious. When applied to people with well-spoken yet unpopular opinions, it's basically the worst dystopian censorship - invisible, unaccountable, and ostracizing. The saddest cases are the people who make a few trollish comments, don't know they're hellbanned, and keep on trying to contribute. Turn on showdead and you'll get an impression of how various cases play out. I just wish there were a way to un-dead comments/accounts through upvotes.
- rmc 14y agoConservatives often like to pretend that "the pendulum has gone too far" and that the poor white men are now the ones being discriminated against! "You can't say anything anymore!" they'll exclaim, usually they want to right to continue to call Latinos "Wetback". Appparently their inability to insult people is a terrible crime.
- tptacek 14y ago“While it’s clear that not everything in the blog post was accurate, I did discover examples of embarrassing behavior that I find inappropriate for Kixeye, or any other work environment." It is clear in context that "embarrassing behavior" refers to racially charged conduct, that being the through-line of the whole story in which the CEO is publicly commenting and disclosing employee terminations. If they wanted to minimize legal liability, saying nothing would have made more sense than publicly disclosing "embarrassing behavior" that lead to termination. I know this sounds like more tea-leaf reading and I am myself continually exasperated by the tea-leaf prognostications HN gives rise to in other stories, but the CEO of a large-ish company publicly stating, in the wake of notorious claim of racial prejudice at their firm, that the company fired people for their behavior... that's a Big Deal.
- aristotelian 14y agoUnfortunately, it's not a Big Deal for someone to get fired for mistaking a pendant for a calculator. That sort of thing happens all the time. You know, in the country we live in. It would certainly be a Big Deal if we lived in a country controlled by the Vast White Racist Conspiracy. Actually, San Francisco is especially notable for its deeply entrenched racism. The KKK has a huge office on Market Street, right next to Twitter - you can't miss it.
- tptacek 14y agoHuh? Who got fired for mistaking a pendant for a calculator? Did you simply make that up?
- aristotelian 14y agoI counted four "dumbwhites" and four people who got fired. Maybe I miscounted. I don't know. We obviously will receive no more information. Do you think it's implausible that the pendant woman got fired? Would you say, that kind of thing can't happen in America?
- 14y ago
- psykotic 14y ago> How so? The fact that the company is attempting to minimize legal liability doesn't mean that the contractor was truthful. Apparently the contractor was truthful enough to warrant firing four people. What's the likelihood of them throwing four employees under the bus if there were no bite to the charges? A purely propitiatory sacrifice like that would be hell on employee morale. Good on the CEO for taking action. But my applause is diminished by the weasel words in the CEO's posts on the matter. In the first one, he described the person with the allegations as "a former short-term contract employee". The employee's blog post unequivocally stated that he only worked there for the month of August, so the purpose of such a comment on the CEO's part can only be to cast aspersions on his credibility. Now, in these latest comments, the CEO implies that the claims apparently had enough validity to warrant firing a bunch of people while going on to say that not everything claimed was true. Was this just legal ass-covering? In any case, it makes his public apology feel conniving and insincere. It may have been the best legal maneuver (I wouldn't know) but it makes for bad PR.
- danielweber 14y agoWhile in some cases a company will settle a lawsuit even when claims are groundless, it's really hard for me to read that in here. 1. They don't seem to have settled with the developer in question (although I may have honestly missed that). 2. You settle by giving the quacking duck a bunch of money to shut up. You don't fire 4 people who didn't do anything wrong, or else you have just quintupled your potential legal exposure. I'm glad they did the right thing. I'm sad the bad thing happened in the first place. I am hopeful that this kind of workplace culture will die out. I am worried that it will continue.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoYou don't fire 4 people who didn't do anything wrong, or else you have just quintupled your potential legal exposure. You can fire people for anything you want (barring contractual clauses stating otherwise) except for membership in a protected class.