4 ms·
The problem with this essay is that, if its claims are true, Litepanels can't possibly prevail in court, so there's no reason to respond to a grass-roots fundin
by lutusp 14y ago
The problem with this essay is that, if its claims are true, Litepanels can't possibly prevail in court, so there's no reason to respond to a grass-roots funding appeal.
The essay tries to make Litepanels' legal maneuvers sound like a realistic legal threat to monopolize the LED lighting business. But it then explains that there's plenty of prior art and no basis for Litepanels' claiming patent rights over the manufacture and sale of LED products.
Only one of the above claims can be true.
Also there are some very big players in the LED field, with potentially billions of dollars at stake. This isn't exactly the scenario in which a grass-roots action committee is either the appropriate response, or likely to make any difference.
Also, the essay needs some fact checking:
> Furthermore patents are legally only given to those that create something new that someone skilled in the art would not think of.
Although once true, at present this is false -- very, highly, extremely false. In fact, things have gotten to the point where (at least in the US) patents are issued with little or no prior-art checking, on the assumption that the patent is nothing more than a license to sue, with the expectation that the courts will sort out the issues.
And worse (or better, depending on your tastes), just over the horizon is an explicit Patent Office rule change that will grant a patent to the first filer, regardless of whether or not that person has any connection to the creation of the idea being patented:
"USPTO Publishes Proposed Rules Governing First-Inventor-to-File":
http://www.uspto.gov/news/pr/2012/12-44.jsp http://www.uspto.gov/news/pr/2012/12-44.jsp
Finally, the headline is flat wrong: "Litepanels may ban all LED lights from the market"
The headline (which isn't from the linked article, but from the poster) wrong in these ways:
* Litepanels can't do any such thing -- that power rests with the courts.
* Litepanels seems to be claiming a proprietary interest in LEDs used on photography, not (as one example) TV sets.
* Finally, Litepanels doesn't want to ban LED sales -- they want to hold the business hostage.
I can't repeat this often enough: when you submit an article, do not write your own headline, because you will get it wrong. Copy the original headline.
- cube13 14y ago>And worse (or better, depending on your tastes), just over the horizon is an explicit Patent Office rule change that will grant a patent to the first filer, regardless of whether or not that person has any connection to the creation of the idea being patented: This is false. The burden of proof has not changed. The only thing that has changed is determining who would be awarded a patent if two almost identical patents are filed around the same time. In the previous system, the patent would be awarded to the party that could prove that they started working on the invention first, assuming that it passes the prior art check. You still have to prove that you actually created the invention in the first place. In the new system, the patent is awarded to the party that files first, also assuming that it passes the prior art test. Again, you still have to prove that you created the invention. The rules changes here actually increases the prior art field, counting any published patents, and also including internationally filed patents. The fact that the USPTO has had a bad track record with prior art checks has no bearing on this rule change. It's a separate issue.
- lutusp 14y ago>> And worse (or better, depending on your tastes), just over the horizon is an explicit Patent Office rule change that will grant a patent to the first filer, regardless of whether or not that person has any connection to the creation of the idea being patented: > This is false. Yes, it is false, and it's too late for me to reword my original post. I should have emphasized that first-to-file applies to two or more people, all of whom are working on inventions so close together as to be indistinguishable. A claimant might try to assert priority but not be actually involved in the work, or someone might purchase the right to pursue a claim but not be directly involved, but these are perversions of the intent of the change.
- tzs 14y ago> And worse (or better, depending on your tastes), just over the horizon is an explicit Patent Office rule change that will grant a patent to the first filer, regardless of whether or not that person has any connection to the creation of the idea being patented That's not correct. The difference between first to file vs. first to invent is how priority is determined when two or more parties are trying to patent the same thing. Under first to invent, you take all people who meet all the requirements for a patent (they invented the thing, it's new, useful, non-obvious, and so on), and then try to determine who among them invented first. This is often difficult to determine because the invention date is when you first conceived of the idea and started working diligently to reduce it to practice. If you stop working on it, and then resume, you invention date moves up to the date you resumed. Under first to file, you take all the people who meet all the requirements for a patent (they invented the thing, it's new, useful, non-obvious, and so on), and give the patent to the first one who filed.
- lutusp 14y ago> That's not correct. You're right, it is not correct, my wording is misleading, and it's too late for me to change the original. There will be times when the first to file has no right to do so, but if the system works, such claims will be cast out on their lack of merit.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoCame here to say something similar. Basically you don't need a 'call to action' to fight a bad patent, you just need to ask for it to be re-examined [1]. Now you may be more successful if you have a patent litigator doing the requesting and explaining it to the PTO but it doesn't require much more than patience and a postage stamp to kick the process off. [1] http://igdmlgd.blogspot.com/2005/11/amazon-one-click-reexamination-request.html http://igdmlgd.blogspot.com/2005/11/amazon-one-click-reexami...