3 ms·
If the main motivator here is price (ability to charge per hour vs per month), and EC2 is so much more expensive than a VPS provider, have you done the math to
by peterwwillis 14y ago
If the main motivator here is price (ability to charge per hour vs per month), and EC2 is so much more expensive than a VPS provider, have you done the math to see if buying a couple extra VPS's for the month would not break even or be cheaper overall? Linode is kind of pricey compared to other VPS providers.
The larger your site gets the less you're going to need to rely on "hourly" scaling (as your traffic models also become more predictable). There's also the question of uptime, which we've all seen is not a guarantee from just using Amazon.
- grey-area 14y agoFrom the link: As a hosted continuous deployment service releasing changes and scaling automatically is a necessity. I think the key here is that this blog is talking about a hosted service which responds on demand to their client's needs on an hourly basis. EC2 has a lot of infrastructure which does this for them (as long as they can automate it) and is specifically built for this, whereas they'd have to write it themselves by interfacing with a VPS API otherwise. So EC2 might be worth the money to them. VPS providers are mostly more focussed on giving you 1 or 2 boxes to use, and then you leave your site running with occasional adjustments in capacity etc, not on spinning up and down servers on demand, which is a bit more specialised, and might require tens or even hundreds of servers. For a normal site that's not going to be relevant, and a VPS is cheaper, for this site, it seems EC2 is a better fit...
- matlock 14y agoExactly. Price itself is not the main issue, but flexibility is. For example on Weekends we typically see 20%-30% the traffic that we see during the week, simply because people are not at work. Scaling up and down is an absolute necessity there.
- bluestix 14y agoDedicated servers billed monthly cost 15% of what Amazon instances cost. So you would still be better off with dedicated hardware.
- peterwwillis 14y agoI think you're making a lot of assumptions about how a service like their could work and does work. You don't need to write a lot of code to leverage VPS's or scale them, and you don't always need to scale up or down on an hourly basis. I'll bet you that if they took the historical metrics of their services and their load use and averaged it, buying one or two boxes would easily break even and at the same time not be dependent on a specialized provider or functionality like an auto-scaling VPS. But that's just a guess.
- matlock 14y agoWe actually went that route with historical data and it wasn't any good to be honest. Work patterns change daily, so we really need the auto scaling. Working with Historical data means you either totally oversubscribe certain days, or totally underdo it. It has to be automated due to the latest load.
- astrodust 14y ago> Linode is kind of pricey compared to other VPS providers. Can you qualify this? The cost is lower than Amazon and Rackspace Cloud. There are dime-store VPS providers out there that are technically less expensive, but they're usually not able to provide the same level of service. Linode always seems to provide exceptional customer support.
- peterwwillis 14y agoDo you know how many "dime-store VPS providers" there are, and how many of them have existed as long as Linode and longer? Linode provides a valuable, quality service, and has lots of extras that you may not need. Some VPS providers specialize and have a good history of both uptime and support, and provide it for less than the big-name competitors. I've found many to be exceptionally reliable with good support, and there are communities where you can find reviews and status on such providers to back up their claims. And in the end, realistically, if you're doing small scaling by the hour you probably don't need the biggest providers in the game. A small service provider for a small company is often a great fit. You can check out reviews on http://www.lowendbox.com/ http://www.lowendbox.com/ and http://www.webhostingtalk.com/ http://www.webhostingtalk.com/ and compare prices, services and reputation. In general, a standard small-sized VPS will be half the cost of Linode, meaning you can buy double the VPS's (on different providers, for example) and get double the capacity and redundancy for the same cost. If you spread them out by region you can implement cheap software GeoIP load-balancing and serve the content by servers closest to your users.
- ajitk 14y agoI too have found quite a few usable offers from lowendbox.com (LEB) and lowendtalk.com (LET). Searching the websites bring up quite a few attractive deals. However it may be tricky to pick a good host. It is usually a good idea to look for past experiences before signing up. The community is active and helps make that decision: http://www.lowendtalk.com/discussion/5136/best-leb-host-q3-2012 http://www.lowendtalk.com/discussion/5136/best-leb-host-q3-2...
- krobertson 14y ago