3 ms·
Is arbitration as evil as it's popularly made out to be? I will say, the thought of being able to settle a dispute via a neutral third party without invoking th
by Karunamon 14y ago
Is arbitration as evil as it's popularly made out to be? I will say, the thought of being able to settle a dispute via a neutral third party without invoking the morass that is the legal system sounds enticing, and i'm the consumer.
Are there any stats on how often they find for the corporation vs the consumer? Nothing jumped out at me when I did a search.
Another question I just thought of, how freely can courts ignore the contract of adhesion in which you "agreed" not to bring a class action?
- agpen 14y agoExcept it isn't a neutral third party when one party gets to pick the arbitrator and the other party has no say. It's why forced arbitration in employment contracts are so odious, it's the corporation + a corporate lawyer vs you, and you have no options if they for instance allow you to be brutally raped and then imprison you in a shipping container for days for reporting it.
- adrr 14y agoConsumer is going to lose almost 100% of the time when it goes to Arbitration. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Arbitration_Forum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Arbitration_Forum
- Karunamon 14y agoThat's a single, corrupt organization which hasn't handled a consumer case since July 2009. Over 3 years ago.
- genwin 14y ago> Are there any stats on how often they find for the corporation vs the consumer? The corporations choose the arbitration firms. The arbitration firms should know full well who's feeding them. So stats aren't really necessary. > ... how freely can courts ignore the contract of adhesion in which you "agreed" not to bring a class action? My understanding is, zero freedom for that.
- spindritf 14y ago> The arbitration firms should know full well who's feeding them. So stats aren't really necessary. Yes, the incentives are perverse but empirical evidence is always necessary.
- illuminate 14y agoAnd certainly not always available due to those same perverse incentives.
- genwin 14y agoI second what illuminate said. Plenty of society's systems hide info for potentially nefarious reasons, so that you have little choice but to draw your own conclusions. Just follow the money.
- mcherm 14y agoBeing able to settle a dispute via a neutral third party is enticing. And I'm a big fan of arbitration. But you're not thinking of arbitration, you're thinking of binding arbitration. That's where a 3rd party is picked (in these cases, picked by the corporation) and then both sides must do whatever that person says, regardless of whether they find it fair.