7 ms·
In India, engineering students outsource their academic projects
- bsg75 14y ago"After three years of engineering education, the final year student is struggling to make even a simple circuit work" If this leads to outsourcing of student projects, and thus a habit to outsource professional tasks, then that education system is a failure - and an indictment of outsourcing in general. As engineers are replaced with "business people", the world becomes less capable.
- kamaal 14y agoActually I posted this article not because I wanted to point out how bad Indian students are. Not all Indian students do this. And the Indian market is a usual mix of people of various kinds- Awesome, good, bad, horrible and even clueless people like this. What I wanted to point out was how things work out in the real world. The thumb rule for describing these sort of things in India is the saying 'No good deed goes unpunished'. You will see most of these students doing these will actually win over the actual hard working guys. The guy who did the real project would have probably failed, or wouldn't have enough polish on his project. Or due to his sheer intelligence, and little touch of arrogance gotten out of favor of his professors. Due to all this he probably would have scored less marks, missed out the interview opportunity and then left to wander for jobs. The guys who got the project done 'ready made', would have made their project look complete. Mugged up all the viva and etc questions. Got plenty of time to study interview books and questions asked in campus interviews. And due to all this would have easily cleared the already heavily gamed interview process. So the net story is, if you cheat you are likely to win than if you work hard the true way. When I joined the industry I noticed the process manifest in front of my own eyes. Every joe joining the company wanted to be a manager in 4 years, with a monthly take home of 1.5L, at least 3-4 foreign travel opportunities. Of course in highly political environments like large corporates, some played their old game and got through. But most who didn't had two options a) MBA b) MS in the United States. I saw the very people who did all this once again went to tutions, cleared their GRE/CAT were granted bank loans to go study in the US. Most of them I know are working today in the US and probably will end up being US citizens. The actual hard working technical guys(programmers, hackers or whatever you may call them) are treated like commodity, worst like a foot ball tossed around by 'business guys', because Indian IT religion creed says 'Being technical is not important, rather one must do smart work'. So in the name of smart work, technical career has no growth path, no long term rewards. In order to grow and get paid well you have to be a 'manager'. Or worst work at a start up, where you are likely fail, not get compensated enough, Or if you are too unlucky work for a stingy/unethical founder and burn your hands then get back to your old MegaCorp back again. When this is the routine cycle. What do you expect this students to do?
- registeraux 14y agoI find the tone of your comment condescending. It almost seems like you have some sort of a grudge against people who managed to go to the US. Your tone reflects this: "working today in the US and probably will end up being US citizens." So? And what kind of a generalization are making here anyways? You are meaning to say: "All people who did this cleared GRE/ GMAT and went to the USA". That's a gross overstatement based on no evidence. Not to mention the fact, assuming even if they did get their project made from somewhere else (I really doubt it that it happens a lot), they still had other academics to clear. And they had the GRE exam. And then they cleared the job interview. Means they were not as dull and stupid as you want them to and show them to be. Your tone and your attitude seems more of hate based than anything else.
- abc_lisper 14y agoLol. I think he is frustrated. First you get frustrated, then you accept it, and then you laugh at people who are frustrated .. LOLOL.. Just kidding. Kamaal, Do you get frustrated because you don't think you are paid as much as you should be? Or, that the business people shouldn't be paid as much as the technical guys? If it is the latter, there is no respite, and you should probably do what others do. First of all, you are in your own country, and you are welcome to leave the job anytime you want. ANYTIME. If you think you are overworked you don't have to put up with it, you just move on. There is no shortage of software jobs in India, and if you are as technical as you say you are, you shouldn't have any problem finding one. Secondly, are you an engineer because you like it, or you do it to satisfy your ego, or differentiate yourself, or because you worked so hard until now that you can't give up? If it is for any other reasons than the first one, take a good hard look at yourself. It probably is not worth being frustrated all your life for anything. Life is short, and you should not do disservice to yourself. Don't buy into the hype created by society for serving its own selfish reasons. Yeah, it is great if you invented an algorithm that solves a problem in half the time, but recognize that in itself it is meaningless to your life unless you enjoy it. Don't, please don't do it because everyone says so-and-so thing is great. Thirdly, I don't know how you would do it, but please don't let others recognition of you define your happiness. Do it by keeping away from people who cause all the negativity or learn to ignore them. You are your own person, and you should do everything to serve yourself better and keep yourself happy. PS: I am a desi living in the US from quite a while now. I felt the same frustration you feel now. It is quite a journey to get out of it, but you should not stay where you are PPS: You are not responsible for the world. The world is a unjust place and is what it is. Learn to live with it. It is not going to be "your" problem in a few short years anyways.
- damian2000 14y agoThis is another way of paying for a qualification that you don't deserve, and in doing so it dilutes the standard of graduates. I've heard personally from an Indian friend that this is very common - and is the reason that he came to Australia to study.
- capex 14y agoThe situation in Australia is hardly any different. http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/uni-cheats-buy-work-in-cyberspace-20121002-26xhj.html http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/uni-cheats-...
- damian2000 14y agoNo doubt - there's cheats everywhere... but I don't think its near the scale of India.
- kamaal 14y agoScale of population in India magnifies this problem. Both good and bad things look bigger.
- registeraux 14y agoOk, may I know the source of this scale you are talking about? Statistics without proper references don't cut much ice.
- swatkat 14y ago@damian2000, [citation needed]
- intended 14y agoI can chime in here - I've studied in the India - then the states and then back in India. Copying is endemic. Amongst the final year students in my CS class of nearly 50 I think maybe 1 person did it on their own. The rest knew a guy who knew a guy who had a copy of the project. This is for your undergrad degree. For my 10th standard practical exams, which I did in one of the more strict institutions, the invigilator who came from another school left the room for a short time, and my physics professor came in and took a look at what we were doing. he didn't give us advice directly, but with enough stern looks and exasperated sighs he let people know what they were doing wrong, and why certain experiments were doomed to fail. Then again given the sorry state of some of the equipment like the calipers, I doubt we could have gotten too precise a measurement anyway. Similarly for the chem practicals and bio practicals. I also know that our professors would go to other schools and invigilate there, where they would return the favor. Onward to practical exams in undergrad - Comp sci was probably easier to copy and cheat. The engineering courses were similar though - you could find a talented student/graduate who would make your projects for you at a price. This is still nothing, because every year there is a scandal where the question papers are leaked for almost every exam. This is constant. People will find a bribe-able teacher or peon and get X or Y exam paper from them. Again constant and ongoing. This is often the option of the desperate, who also resort to interesting ways to cheat - such as having your text books hidden away in the toilets and so on, or on your phones, or scratched onto the desks or the walls. ------ I can't find it anymore, but there was a great article written by a professional paper writer in the US. He used to work for a firm that wrote papers and articles for college students who could afford them. He never looked down on his students - some of them were quite wealthy and he knew that they would go on to do something else once they graduated. So for him this was just an extension of them learning useful real world skills and he appreciated those clients who made no pretense and could give instructions on how he would like an article to be written and what emphasis to be given.
- pravinkenator 14y agoActually this is extremely common and infact, projects for undergraduates and post graduates are a thriving business in India. The colleges give a damn about this and they are seldom bothered. This kind of practice is extremely common in government aided universities in India. But, I must also say that there are some universities where the students perform exceptionally.
- gunn 14y agoI think deciding that learning and understanding is more important than pleasing markers and getting a qualification is one of the most important decisions you can make. One of my favourite movies ever is a bollywood film on this topic. 3 Idiots. Here's a snippet: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35sfBjmVWpU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35sfBjmVWpU
- varrunr 14y agoOK, maybe some students do outsource their projects. This does not mean that hard working students who can prove themselves otherwise are ignored. To companies like Infosys, CTS etc. who actually indulge in mass recruiting and have pathetic interview standards, of course, this might make a difference. But to good companies how want to recruit good Engineers, projects on the resume can only aid in interview calls. A lack of knowledge would be apparent in an interview. While you explain the problem, you never make an attempt at finding or listing a solution for the same. But instead, you end your post with a rhetorical statement. Analyzing this problem, I think it can be attributed to widespread plagiarism in engineering schools in India. In the US, plagiarism is dealt with severely and can even lead to expulsion. This forces Indian students who used to indulge in malpractices in their undergrad to put on their thinking hats for once and be creative, for the fear of expulsion(which would be a disaster after so much preparation). Thats when one realizes the consequences of ones action. Such a system should be enforced in colleges in India.
- gingerjoos 14y agoThe sorry state of education is a distraction, the real problem is something else. Most students in India are not given much of a choice when it comes to choosing their career path. Most of the students are forced to be doctors, engineers or civil servants. Very few end up being artists, singers, sports-person... anything which is not a "real" job. The result being that a host of colleges have sprung up to meet this demand. These colleges are setup with the sole aim of making money. Education is just a side effect. Students get no academic freedom and have no space to learn outside of a very narrowly defined "syllabus". The worse problem is that most students who end up in Engineering Colleges have absolutely no interest in becoming engineers. They do manage to somehow graduate and get an "IT job". They end up being mediocre engineers and at the earliest opportunity try to find a way out. These poor souls end up giving a bad name to Indian Engineers. What about those who want to be engineers because they like to build things and love to tinker around? The hacker types? Getting into an engineering college requires a lot of money. If and when they do get into an engineering college it's a poor quality one. They are forced to spend time only on mugging up equations and theorems. They get no space to build circuits of their own or blow up stuff for the heck of it. Assignments are a joke, they require no application of thought and all that's required is merely copying stuff from the text book onto paper. The poor dispirted hackers end up languishing in low paying jobs or find an escape route by moving out of the country where their talents are recognised. tl;dr : Quality suffers when quantity increases beyond limit.
- Tsagadai 14y agoWith growth in the middle classes you will get a lot more people not working "real" jobs. This is a repeated pattern across the world. First everyone forces their children into the money-making professions. Then the second generation attempts to not repeat the choices their parents made for them that they resented. Eventually, it evens out and you get people who do what they want to do.
- sown 14y agoIt sounds like education could be even more disrupted there than here?
- 14y ago
- cmadan 14y agoFortunately, for these group of students the benefit is short lived and mainly on paper. They have better grades compared to their honest peers because of the complicity from professors (it is trivial to figure out whether someone has done the project or outsourced it, but they don't care). But when it comes around to getting a job, they are the ones who usually struggle. I've seen so many students with average grades ultimately be recruited for the best jobs available on the market because they preferred to spend their time on TopCoder instead of gaming the system. In some ways, I feel sorry for them. Most of them do it due to the herd mentality, everyone is outsourcing their projects so they must outsource their projects too. Clearly, this doesn't work out very in the long term and what they gain by taking the easy way out, they lose in terms of denying themselves the opportunity to gain some practical experience.
- kamaal 14y ago>>Fortunately, for these group of students the benefit is short lived and mainly on paper. Sorry these are precisely the kind of guys who end up being mid level managers in large corporates. >>But when it comes around to getting a job, they are the ones who usually struggle. Interview in India are a joke. Body shops pick up people for marks, and familiarity with objective questions roaming around on the internet.
- pjscott 14y ago> Sorry these are precisely the kind of guys who end up being mid level managers in large corporates. If it's any consolation, those large corporations get what they deserve: they end up with middle managers who cheated their way out of an education. There's some justice in this.
- gingerjoos 14y ago> because of the complicity from professors (it is trivial to figure out whether someone has done the project or outsourced it, but they don't care) "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." A lot of professors join teaching during the gap between graduating and getting a job. They are neither motivated or smart enough to figure these things out.
- trhtrsh 14y ago1. How much does "project making" pay compared to other available software jobs? 2. Are those projects more fun than other jobs? 3. Subvert the whole system: Create a project-making company. Keep good records. Refer your employees to employers, on the basis of their solid project portfolios. Basically, project-making companies thus displace the universities as the place where real learning happens and is proven. 4. Thank you to all the Indians posting here today. I feel like I am reading hackernews.in, and it's nice to get a vacation from Silicon Valley :-)
- gingerjoos 14y ago1. It doesn't pay much. The people it employs are engineers who did not get jobs in software companies. 2. No. More often than not, students end up doing projects "suggested" by these project-making companies. They already have a bunch of "Student Database Management System" and "Hospital Record Management System" projects lying around which they rehash. 3. This already happens to an extent. People who work in these low paying jobs end up getting some experience and move onto better paying jobs. But like I said in (2) above, what they get to do are hardly any fun stuff
- jezclaremurugan 14y ago1. 20 - 30 projects a year = 1 yr. inexperienced programmer salary. 2. Fun - yes, Interesting - yes => if you can convince students to choose projects on whatever you want to work on. 3. Project making companies are dime a dozen. 4. Most welcome :) PS - when I was a student I did 2-3 other projects for others... AND students studying MS in USA and UK also send their assignments/homeworks back home - did those too ;)
- kamaal 14y ago>>AND students studying MS in USA and UK also send their assignments/homeworks back home - did those too ;) Actually MS in USA and UK in many(Not all, so please don't frown on me) cases is really for. a. Foreign degree. b. USA return/citizen stamp. c. Helps to get dowry in many cases. How many people actually go there to study in the true sense?
- throwaway503 14y agoWell, I completely agree with kamaal's comments as well as the information presented in the article. In India, especially in engineering colleges, people are mostly interested and encouraged to somehow get HUGE GPAs and secure well paying jobs. The real calibre of these so called engineers are found when they go and work for non standard companies (read as not Wipro, TCS, Infosys, Tech Mahindra etc). I was educated by an interviewee that a IPv4 address is 256 bits by someone who claims to have 6 years of work experience as a Juniper Administrator. The first thing which is taught in the "so called companies" (refer above) is to follow the process. They don't give a fuck about the outcome. Just follow the bloody process. And this idea is incorporated right in college. No one bothers to ask questions. And if someone does, then they get into the bad books of the teachers. I was failed in "Computer Networks" because I used a Soekris board + OpenBSD PF for implementing a firewall which was my third year project while everyone else had compiled a Linux distro with IPchains (remember IPChains and NOT IPTABLES and this was in 2003). Now lets talk about employers. I had worked for 4 startups and 2 HUGE multinationals literally people are treated like slaves. They are expected to work 24/7. I am a Unix Administrator and I was expected to come to office 8 in the morning and leave at 1 in the night, that too after pleading with the manager to let me go. The reason I was made to work like a maniac was, I was the guy who understood the internals and others were merely sitting behind their desks. The result? I threw in the towel and have decided to go for a MS. I do not intend to work for anyone in India ever again.
- intel8085 14y agoNot every guy who did their project themselves ended up as an entrepreneur, but almost all entrepreneurs did their college projects themselves.
- arunprabu 14y agoI think u r right. not many are business owners. I did my academic projects myself and now an entrepreneur.
- pajju 14y agoFirst of all an undergrad in India is naive and needs good mentoring. That's missing and no one cares to solve this problem! I think we have to blame the Indian education system largely for this. The root cause is - The quality of the system is poor and is broken. But it should only get better over-time and its happening. Indian Schooling system is not ready to bring out Quality Engineers. It doesn't encourage Creative thinking and promote an intellectual environment. There are many IT companies that fill this void by giving 6months intensive training because they know the education system. Another social-cultural reason being - Indians are spoon feed-ed right from birth. They aren't independent much and depend on schooling more. This promotes a conservative mindset. But this norm will gradually change for the better, I'm already seeing today's young undergrads getting involved in Startup space by asking internships and are doing some really great work! In my startup, we have given internship projects to undergrads but we never value their paper degrees or schooling. We only value their github page, OSS work and appreciate self-taught programmers.
- paolord 14y agoThis also happens in the Philippines. Sometimes the reason why students outsource projects isn't exactly related to how good they are academically. Some students(both good and bad) finish projects themselves and some outsource because they'd rather focus on a more important subject or project. Some even have part time jobs and really doesn't have the time. Even the really smart students sometimes outsource, these students have already been training and specializing on one field and if their project happens to be on a different field they'd rather have someone else do it than have bad marks. And about the project making companies, they're more like "teams" here in the Philippines. Mostly undergrads or graduates that haven't found jobs or programmers that have jobs but wants some extra-income.
- amitagrawal 14y agoI study in one of the largest universities in India. It is also fairly reputed within the country as well as outside. During my 2nd year of engineering we had to complete a programming "mini project". If you're familiar with these you may know the quality of most projects. Year after year you can see the same projects reappear, some even to the point that the old student's details aren't changed in the source code to reflect the new owner's! So we had to complete this project by forming a group - minimum of 2 students and a maximum of 4. The guideline? It should have a UI (duh!) and a database. The clear instructions from the professor were to use only Visual Basic or Java. The syllabus booklet obviously mentioned that any suitable language could be used. I went to him to ask if it was OK to do a "web based", "database-enabled" & "User Interfacing" application. To say that he was agitated would be a euphemism. It was like I had insulted him. To placate him, I respectfully pointed out that it was perfectly okay for me to use a language that I was comfortable in and that a web-based project was in fact a norm. To avenge the dishonor I had brought him, he bullied another member of my group to leave my group just an hour before the demo to an external professor (a professor from some other college who is invited for the demo and viva voce). Meanwhile the demo went great, the external was very satisfied with the answers to his questions although I can be sure he was a little happily surprised that I had coded it myself completely. My professor sitting next to him was fuming with rage. I gladly left the hall being sure of making it satisfactorily. I was dumbfounded when I found it on my report card that I had failed getting only 10% of the total allotment for the project and the re-hashed project managed to score 90% and above. The sad thing is most of my colleagues didn't even try to code or come up with an idea. Even sadder is the fact that if you do, the professors make sure to take it personally and pull you down instead of motivating or giving a helping hand.
- kamaal 14y ago>>I study in one of the largest universities in India. It is also fairly reputed within the country as well as outside. Doesn't matter. Great colleges in India are about campus hiring, not education. >>During my 2nd year of engineering we had to complete a programming "mini project". If you're familiar with these you may know the quality of most projects... :) You made feel nostalgic. >>The clear instructions from the professor were to use only Visual Basic or Java. and then.. >>I went to him to ask if it was OK to do a "web based", "database-enabled" & "User Interfacing" application. To say that he was agitated would be a euphemism. It was like I had insulted him. To placate him, I respectfully pointed out that it was perfectly okay for me to use a language that I was comfortable in and that a web-based project was in fact a norm. Cardinal sin! Golden rule of such places. Just do as he says, because the idiot feels great power in his fingers and can ruin your whole education because he can't stand a guy more intelligent then him. Additional Advice: Since you are about to graduate and come out soon. Let me tell you there are many people in the industry who are just like your professor. They have their pets in their projects and their own way of running things. If you fall out of favor of such guys you lose the game. >>To avenge the dishonor I had brought him, he bullied another member of my group to leave my group just an hour before the demo to an external professor (a professor from some other college who is invited for the demo and viva voce). Its more like 'Raju Rastogi' from 3 idiots, if you act like Rancho the principle is likely to advice him to join chatur. >>I was dumbfounded when I found it on my report card that I had failed getting only 10% of the total allotment for the project and the re-hashed project managed to score 90% and above. Hardly surprising. I was expecting this end in the very beginning at the start of your post. >>The sad thing is most of my colleagues didn't even try to code or come up with an idea. Even sadder is the fact that if you do, the professors make sure to take it personally and pull you down instead of motivating or giving a helping hand. More sad thing, They are likely to placed before you, and may even get a better compensation than you can.
- plinkplonk 14y agoThere are some structural problems that contribute to (but don't cause) this phenomenon. By most university rules an engineering student needs to do an 'external project' with a company or research lab to complete his degree. Technically you can do a project of your own but most professors of engineering in India are clueless about real world engineering projects and don't do any research or have projects of their own. Most students are not pigheaded enough to buck the system by formulating their own projects and risking failure. (note: I said 'most', IIT s etc are different. Here one is talking about the equivalent of a school in Hicksville in the middle of nowhere and totally disconnected from industry). There are tens of thousands of students needing such an internship/project in a given city every year. Most schools just wash their hands off the whole deal and ask their students to 'go get a project done' with no additional guidance. Most professors, with class sizes of 30 - 50, don't care about formulating or supervising projects. How is a 19 year old supposed to get a non existent company to give them an internship on a sharply defined project? In CS it is often possible to get some kind of project thanks to all the software companies in India, but in other fields like mechanical or electrical engineering, there simple are no projects available. These 'project providers' step into the void and provide 'internships' which exist only on paper and provide a complete project report to the student, who pays substantial (in local currency) fees, submits the report to his clueless profs and ticks off his 'project complete' checkbox. Now, added to this structural problem is the fact that most engineering schools in India approach the teaching of engineering as 'book learning'. Students memorize formulae and regurgitate them in exams without the faintest clue of how to actually build anything (hence the 'can't build a circuit' description in the OP). Just to complicate things, students have no training in technical writing, and even assuming they have a thesis, and know how to do confirming experiments and so on they still have trouble writing a hundred pages in English. None of this is to excuse any of the participants in this farce. This needs to be exposed, and corrected. Just identifying some underlying factors. If the professors decided to clamp down on such fraud, there is no way this will continue. But most are happy to play along. An offshoot of this is the business of creating personal essays for admissions to US schools. Professors in the US, if you see a hundred admission letters starting with "Two Roads diverged in a wood " ( I am NOT joking. I've seen 'professionally prepared' essays that start this way,) you know your prospective student has outsourced his personal essay. Some of these outsourcers get admitted to US universities, or get good jobs and so their path gets validated for younger generations as the 'smart thing to do'. And so the dance continues. somewhat tangential, personal 'external project' anecdote from a long time ago I studied Industrial Engineering in a decent but not great school and my profs were well meaning but not particularly clueful. They saw Industrial Engineering as an offshoot of Mechanical Engineering and shot down all my proposed 'build a compiler' type projects (I wanted to do a software project), because 'That is computer Science, not Mechanical or Industrial Engineering. You have to do a project in Mechanical Engineering'. So I compromised by forming a team with a couple of sharp guys, writing a small but sophisticated (given the circumstances) CAD program in Turbo C on a 486 PC ( hey it even had a scripting component - I did get to write a compiler after all), printed out all the code, added an introductory page and that was my 'project report'. The profs were a bit taken aback at the hundreds of pages of C code (which they couldn't read or grok) but the software worked, I could answer all their questions, and CAD was "mechanical engineering" so I got top grades for the project. [1] I later heard from some of my juniors that the profs used to tell them about this 'very talented bunch of guys who did a great project and you should emulate them' but I don't think anyone took that advice ;). [1]That was the only 'course' for which I had anything like a top grade. I was bored to tears and rarely attended class and spent all my time chasing girls and scraped by in some of the "write down from memory the formula for stress in a cantilever beam" type examinations by deriving enough stuff from scratch to get a passing grade. Most classes (and exams) I completely ignored. I completed my degree only because my employer(Cybercash, now defunct, but was one of the pioneers in payment processing, HQ in Virginia, with the devs in Bangalore) begged me to, so I could get a visa to go to the USA, and you couldn't get a visa without a degree. I wrote 22 exams in two weeks and got my degree. To this day I don't know anything about Mechanical Engineering. PS: In retrospect I should have just (minimally) played the game of dutifully attending classes and so on and spend half an hour or so every day memorizing the facts and formulae required to get good grades. Would have saved a lot of stress. Instead I rebelled against the insanity and quit attending class except to meet my friends. As pg said in one of his essays, (paraphrasing) when you rebel, you are still playing someone else's game,only with a logical 'not' added to the rules. You are still dancing to someone else's tune. I don't have any regrets, but then I was thoroughly confused by the way engineering was taught and learned and what behavior was lauded and what was punished. This was before the internet arrived in India. Now Coursera etc offer me a veritable cornucopia of insanely great teachers, Amazon has all the books and I am as happy as a pig in a mud pit learning new stuff well after my hair turned grey.
- yuvipanda 14y agoPosting for a friend who wishes to remain anonymous: I'm a mechanical engineering by education and one thing I have noticed is there are no such options available for mechanical engineers. I remember sweating it out at the workshop fabricating a continuous variable transmission (automatic transmission) unit by hand from scratch. I went on to work with a "leading education company" in India and we rolled out an "innovative" program for engineering college students. I was fresh out of bschool and was mainly involved in preparing the presentations to be presented to the top management. The plan was supposed to connect the student community with the industry to facilitate final year projects for "free". I was happy because this entire "outsourcing of projects" was always one of my pet peeves. I later found out that the real plan was to do the above, but do it slowly and when the students were running out of time, make them pay up and "sell" them a project. The service didn't take off and boy was I secretly glad! What did I learn from the exercise? 1. There is a booming industry to sell projects. 2. There is immense demand. The moment we started advertising, we got tens of thousands of calls every day. 3. The students just want to get done with the projects. Why? They already have job offers from one of the various software companies and this is just a formality to get their degree certificate. 4. They just aren't interested. 5. We approached engineering colleges as part of marketing and most directors/principals we met were @$$holes who asked us just one question - Will this help me get more admissions for the next academic year? 6. Most HODs wanted a cut out of the entire deal. 7. Demand for projects (in decreasing order) EC>EE>CS/IT>EI>Mech/Civil I do not know the solution to this problem, but the entire ecosystem is flawed.
- realrocker 14y agoRelevant experience of mine. http://honestmusings.wordpress.com/2012/05/13/sales-before-engineering-lessons-i-learnt-from-my-first-business/ http://honestmusings.wordpress.com/2012/05/13/sales-before-e... .
- sathish316 14y agoI despised this trend when I was in college and did not know the value of internships either. Most people I knew were outsourcing or buying projects or internship certificates to have more time for what they wanted to do after college - MBA, MS etc. Me and my friend knew 8051 assembly language before project frenzy started. We wanted to stay away from outsourcing project sellers and build something on our own. There was a senior who'd built a Robotic arm to show it was possible. Our major was in Electronics and communications engineering. We built a GPS vehicle locator by making two GSM phones talk to each other using SMS. It even had a maps front-end in VB. Nothing I had learnt in College prepared us for what we did in those 3 months. We took printouts of 8051 microcontroller, GPS module, Nokia, Siemens modem datasheets. We spent lot of time researching GPS modules which we could get in Bangalore and after numerous visits to circuit shops, setup a lab at home for soldering and burning microcontroller ROM. We burned code in 8051 ROM like 200+ times and spent the whole time learning soldering, writing modular code in Embedded C, talking to Siemens AT modems. When we finally got SMS response of GPS coordinates, we had 600 lines of Embedded C code. We started writing the client side in VB which was a breeze except for soldering a Nokia phone to COM port. We got the same grades as those who bought their projects, but we had the satisfaction of building something. College in India is pretty much useless unless you have great peers. I was fortunate to have a liberal education in school where the focus was on learning and not rote memorization. I learnt assembly, gwbasic, C, VB while in school. My friend got a job in Embedded systems industry. I applied for GPS and fleet mgmt software companies but ended up working for a big IT company. I got out of that soon and joined a place where developers are not treated like commodities.
- GabrielF00 14y agoWikipedia did a project where students at Indian universities were assigned to expand and write Wikipedia articles in lieu of their normal coursework. Two universities were selected - College of Engineering, Pune and Symbiosis School of Economics. It was a complete disaster - students plagiarized so much material that Wikipedia blocked one of the universities and then shut down the project prematurely. For the engineering school, just 13% of the content students submitted survived cleanup efforts. For the economics school it was a bit better, but just 29% survived. Students simply did not have the experience of someone looking at their work carefully and checking that they were following the rules. The students also didn't have the skills to understand how to work with sources and how to paraphrase. Some students were willing and able to change their behavior in order to contribute good content, but that was only 24% for the economics school and 2% for the engineering school. Many students just did not have the English language skills to complete the assignment. You can read an independent report here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:India_Education_Program/Analysis/Independent_Report_from_Tory_Read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:India_Education_Progr...
- xradionut 14y agoProblems like this are vexing, even to us non-Indians in the US. I've had the privilege of working with some awesome engineers from around the world, but issues of this ilk taint the opinions of many folks in IT and CS. It's bad enough that these assumptions hurt the careers of truly talented and dedicated engineers and programmers.
- TokenAccount 14y agoJust to balance out all the negative commentary about Indian education (which I'm not discounting by any means), I would like to offer my experience as a college student in one of India's premier engineering colleges (hint, y'all know it's name). I was a chemistry student in a mostly technical (engineering) college. Nobody in this college would dream of the kinds of blatant cheating I hear about at other places. Yes, people helping each other in their projects... imbalanced project teams with one brilliant student putting in most of the effort etc, that level of dubious behaviour was not uncommon (but not _too_ common either). I got to play around with computers as my final year project. It was computational chemistry. I built a simulation model of a large number of molecules floating around under each other's forces and watch their emergent behaviour over simulated time. I'm rather proud of that project to this day. And I was not alone by any means. A few of my batchmates' project work ended up in published papers (yes, our professors were expected to carry out international level research along with teaching). I interacted a bit with the computer science people too (since I was working on high performance compute clusters etc.). Some of the software I saw them build was impressive but I didn't know _how_ impressive at that stage in my life. Later I switched fields and ended up doing a masters in computer science in a US university (picked up the under-graduate material through self-study and audited classes over a few years of pretending to do science research and TA'ing :-) ) Then I realized that the computer science students I came across back in my Indian college were doing some very impressive work for undergraduates. So there. I hope it provides a reasonable counter-point to all the negative stuff about Indian students/colleges. My school is definitely not the common case... but it and many others like it do exist. (I'm posting from a throw-away account for reasons best left unstated.)
- vanderghast 14y agoI don't think the issue is an Indian issue. More likely its just because a very small number of people should actually be taking engineering, but because of how lucrative it is, so many people take it who shouldn't be there. I went to Stanford in the early 2000s for undergrad and majored in EE. EE classes would normally have up to 50-60 students in lectures. Lectures would be taken by professors, many of whom were leading experts in their field, and some would be visibly bored or annoyed at having to teach ridiculously simple undergrad classes. You can imagine Nobel prize winners trying to teach basic physics. Students did not learn much from these professors, some of whom would just recite from the textbook (which they had written). So students stopped coming to class. And Stanford even then recorded and streamed most engineering lectures, so by middle of the term only 5-6 students would show up to class. Then you go for the final exam and there are like 100 students who show up, everyone surprised the class was so big! They had problem sets every week, and tutorial sessions where you could get one on one attention with graduate students. These were the most personalized attention you could get during the course. You had a choice at Stanford. You could either choose to learn, or you could choose to have good grades. Only the top 5% of the class, the real geniuses could learn and get good grades at the same time. I was not that smart. So I spent the first two years taking classes I was interested in. Mostly skipped the lectures, and took as many classes as possible. I was a solid B student. Then I got tired, and decided EE was not for me. Thought about switching majors but it was too late. So decided to get through on the bare minimum of effort. As soon as I flipped that switch, I met the other group of people, the ones focused on good grades and enjoying life. In order to get good grades, you have to do well in problem sets, midterm, final exam and project for each class. Problem sets - It's ok to copy answers. We used to have a basket in the EE office where people turned in answers. Just go one day early and grab someone else's paper. Copy, return. If the guy turned it in a day or two early, he must have known what he was doing. Project - Even easier. Stanford had so many socially inept engineers. Guys who don't even speak in class and usually very quiet or weird. These guys need friends too. Be their friend. Be in their project group. You don't even have to do anything. The smart guy will do all the work, won't even complain or tell the prof. Why? Because most of the really smart guys are really arrogant that their smart, and they believe they don't need anyone else. They're annoyed they have to have project partners. As long as they have to have a partner, then one who is friendly but doesn't interfere with their ideas or vision for the project is the best. Mid-term and finals - The last week before the mid term or final, show up for the tutorials. Most of the grad students teaching them will focus on the problems most likely to come out in the exam. Voila. I was an A student the last two years. And graduated without knowing anything. I told my faculty advisor I just wanted to get my degree and get out! And the funny thing is, I have friends who have made a career out of "getting grades" this way. Think about all those venture capitalists in Silicon Valley. Those were the kids who were friends of smart engineers. Think of Sheryl Sandberg, Eric Schmidt etc. The managers without significant technical knowledge.
- arunprabu 14y agoI did all 2 of my academic projects in my college itself, while many others did outside.