3 ms·

I got one of the Newegg circulars in my email advertising a sweet little uATX AMD server board and got to thinking that my home FreeBSD server could use a CPU b

I got one of the Newegg circulars in my email advertising a sweet little uATX AMD server board and got to thinking that my home FreeBSD server could use a CPU bump and more memory. As soon as I saw how much 128GB of DDR5 ECC would cost my jaw dropped and noped the fuck out. The cheapest 32GB modules are around $300 and upwards of $500. Thought I was going to gift myself early this Christmas. Depressing indeed.

buildbot 11mo ago
Indeed, it makes mini computers with soldered ram actually end up being quite cheap by comparison. HP will currently sell you 128GB AMD or Nvidia boxes for 1.7-2.8k depending on your flavor of choice. Not ECC though.
- PunchyHamster 11mo ago
  ...till supplies last. Which won't be long when people do exactly that (hey, that mini PC is now cheaper than building similar setup)
  - buildbot 11mo ago
    Indeed…
- JonChesterfield 11mo ago
  The strix halo mini workstation is 128gb of ecc. Good machine. Source https://h20195.www2.hp.com/v2/GetPDF.aspx/c09086887 https://h20195.www2.hp.com/v2/GetPDF.aspx/c09086887
  - buildbot 11mo ago
    Necro reply - I don't think they actually shipped it with ECC... If you lookup a Z1 mina G1a repair video: https://youtu.be/1i_PfH05ekw?si=MpQ0Uc9QVwhgsFzi&t=267 https://youtu.be/1i_PfH05ekw?si=MpQ0Uc9QVwhgsFzi&t=267 It has 8 chips, not 10. It needs 10 from true ECC.
    - JonChesterfield 11mo ago
      I should check this next time I take it apart, thanks for the heads up :)
      - buildbot 11mo ago
        I’d be really curious to see - that would possibly sell me on one! Linux should also report edac being up in dmesg if it has ecc.
alias_neo 11mo ago
Exactly this. I'd been planning to upgrade my desktop as a christmas present for myself. Now I have the cash and was looking at buying my PCPartPicker list, the cost of the 64GB DDR5-6000 RAM I planned to buy has gone from £300-400 to £700-800+, a difference of almost the price of the 9070 XT I just bought to go in the computer. I guess I'll stick with my outdated AM4/X370 setup and make the best of the GPU upgrade until RAM prices stop being a complete joke.

buildbot 11mo ago

Indeed, it makes mini computers with soldered ram actually end up being quite cheap by comparison. HP will currently sell you 128GB AMD or Nvidia boxes for 1.7-2.8k depending on your flavor of choice. Not ECC though.

PunchyHamster 11mo ago
...till supplies last. Which won't be long when people do exactly that (hey, that mini PC is now cheaper than building similar setup)
- buildbot 11mo ago
  Indeed…
JonChesterfield 11mo ago
The strix halo mini workstation is 128gb of ecc. Good machine. Source https://h20195.www2.hp.com/v2/GetPDF.aspx/c09086887 https://h20195.www2.hp.com/v2/GetPDF.aspx/c09086887
- buildbot 11mo ago
  Necro reply - I don't think they actually shipped it with ECC... If you lookup a Z1 mina G1a repair video: https://youtu.be/1i_PfH05ekw?si=MpQ0Uc9QVwhgsFzi&t=267 https://youtu.be/1i_PfH05ekw?si=MpQ0Uc9QVwhgsFzi&t=267 It has 8 chips, not 10. It needs 10 from true ECC.
  - JonChesterfield 11mo ago
    I should check this next time I take it apart, thanks for the heads up :)
    - buildbot 11mo ago
      I’d be really curious to see - that would possibly sell me on one! Linux should also report edac being up in dmesg if it has ecc.

alias_neo 11mo ago

Exactly this. I'd been planning to upgrade my desktop as a christmas present for myself. Now I have the cash and was looking at buying my PCPartPicker list, the cost of the 64GB DDR5-6000 RAM I planned to buy has gone from £300-400 to £700-800+, a difference of almost the price of the 9070 XT I just bought to go in the computer. I guess I'll stick with my outdated AM4/X370 setup and make the best of the GPU upgrade until RAM prices stop being a complete joke.