3 ms·
Objective-C isn't owned by Apple? Who else is using it? Of the few other people who are using it, how many are using it without Apple's extensions? Apple does i
by dpark 14y ago
Objective-C isn't owned by Apple? Who else is using it? Of the few other people who are using it, how many are using it without Apple's extensions? Apple does indeed de facto own Objective-C. They control it. They have embraced it, extended it, and extinguished anyone else who might have had a claim on it.
It's strange too that you have a problem with C# being proprietary, but you don't have a problem with Java being proprietary. Oracle owns both the language and the implementations that everyone uses. That it's part of their business plan to maintain it for Linux does not change its fundamental nature.
And just so you know, Microsoft did open the source for C# under admittedly restrictive terms. Look up Rotor. And they have issued a Community Promise that protects projects like Mono. And yes, Mono counts, just as surely as GCC counts, unless Microsoft also owns C++.
- melling 14y agoObjective-C is an open source project, like the webkit browser. Google adopted webkit for Chrome, for example. There is nothing prevent anyone else from adopting Objective C. Your logic is pretty flawed. Just because Objective C has not gained wide adoption doesn't mean that it's not open to be adopted. Google uses "Java" for Android. Java is open source. You can download the source and build it. Mono is fine but it's not nearly as good as Microsoft's compiler. C# is a great language. It would be great if Microsoft simply open sourced it.
- dpark 14y ago>There is nothing prevent anyone else from adopting Objective C. There's nothing preventing anyone else from adopting C# via Mono, is there? Also nothing stopping other companies from improving Mono. >Google uses "Java" for Android. Got them sued, too. I think they were within their rights, but this shows that "openness" is not synonymous with safety. >It would be great if Microsoft simply open sourced it. No arguments from me. I'd love that as well, though I don't see it happening any time soon.
- melling 14y agoThe quality of Mono isn't nearly as good as the alternatives. Why bother using it? Just to say that you aren't locked into Windows with C#?