4 ms·
> It's regulating itself like a poorly built skyscraper that is being regulated by gravity: collapsing. We have rules about how to build skyscrapers to keep peo
by anamax 18y ago
> It's regulating itself like a poorly built skyscraper that is being regulated by gravity: collapsing. We have rules about how to build skyscrapers to keep people from getting hurt. Why not the economy? Take what works, throw out what hurts.
Since much of the problem was caused by regulation ("encouraging" bogus loans, tax preferences for fannie mae investments, "mark to market" on illiquid assets, etc), faith in regulation seems misplaced.
You don't get to assume "take what works, throw out what hurts" because regulatory capture always happens.
I note that the new treasury secretary didn't bother to pay SSI despite being reimbursed for it with a separate payment and signing an acknowledgement of same, the new HUD secretary didn't bother to pay taxes on "in kind" payments, and top members of the senate committee that regulates banks and mortgages still won't talk about the sweetheart mortgages that they got.
"Regulation" gives us bailouts. It results in socialized risk. (Which, in some sense, is only fair. If govt is going to impose rules, why shouldn't govt pay for the consequences.)
- gravitycop 18y agothe new treasury secretary didn't bother to pay SSI [...] the new HUD secretary didn't bother to pay taxes on "in kind" payments What would that have to do with economic policy?
- anamax 18y agoThe point is that regulators are human and humans don't have the properties assumed by the "regulation will protect us" theory. If a system only works when some of the components are made of unobtanium, the system doesn't work. The current "stimulus" package is a great example. Well over half is just pumping up budgets for existing programs. Does anyone believe that those "enhanced" budgets will not become permanent? Govt regulation also reduces diversity. It says that everyone pretty much has to behave the same way. We know how that works out. Govt regulation is also political in the worst sense. Wells Fargo took a huge hit when it stayed out of the subprime mortgages. Regulators refused to let WF enage in unrelated activities (acquisitions, opening branches, etc.)because WF didn't "play ball", activities that said regulators let cooperative institutions do. Note that regulators don't take the hit.
- redrobot5050 18y ago>Govt regulation also reduces diversity. It says that everyone pretty much has to behave the same way. We know how that works out. Um, we get Food and Drugs that are safe? Drinking water that's actually drinkable and not full of stomach parasites and Cholera? We get stable deposit banks? Notice that regional banks like BB&T, United Bank, and PNC -- non-investment banks, didn't engage in predatory lending. Their growth was stunted during the housing boom, but their customer's deposits are safe, the banks are stable, and they're in no need of a bail out. And again, due to regulation and FDIC, your money is much safer than pre-Depression era banks. >Govt regulation is also political in the worst sense. Wells Fargo took a huge hit when it stayed out of the subprime mortgages. Regulators refused to let WF enage in unrelated activities (acquisitions, opening branches, etc.)because WF didn't "play ball", activities that said regulators let cooperative institutions do. Note that regulators don't take the hit. I'd like to see some URLs, because (no offense) you're either being too concise or babbling non-sense. I'd like to read up more on it before concluding "regulation == ultra bad" simply from your paragraph.
- gravitycop 18y agowe get [...] Drugs that are safe Not unless one overcomes the barriers to pharmaceutical access.
- anamax 18y ago> we get Food and Drugs that are safe? Nope. We get blockbuster drugs, after a long delay, and that's about it. As to their safety.... We're not seeing new antibiotics. Feel free to explain why Viagra is more profitable than a new antibiotic. (Profit = revenues - costs, so the argument should consider both revenues and costs.) > Notice that regional banks like BB&T, United Bank, and PNC -- non-investment banks, didn't engage in predatory lending. Their growth was stunted during the housing boom Their growth was stunted by govt action because they weren't meeting their "lend to folks who can't pay back" quota. > And again, due to regulation and FDIC, your money is much safer than pre-Depression era banks. Huh? Somewhere north of $2 Trillion is being pissed away because of govt regulatory failures and you think that my money is safe? >>Govt regulation is also political in the worst sense. Wells Fargo took a huge hit when it stayed out of the subprime mortgages. Regulators refused to let WF enage in unrelated activities (acquisitions, opening branches, etc.)because WF didn't "play ball", activities that said regulators let cooperative institutions do. Note that regulators don't take the hit. > I'd like to see some URLs, because (no offense) you're either being too concise or babbling non-sense. http://www.tradingmarkets.com/.site/news/Stock%20News/1921843/ http://www.tradingmarkets.com/.site/news/Stock%20News/192184... The "Community Reinvestment Act" is code for "subprime loans".