3 ms·
I would argue that immigration as a solution to economic growth is a zero sum game, and we need to look at different answers. Gifted, driven, talented entrepre
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I would argue that immigration as a solution to economic growth is a zero sum game, and we need to look at different answers.
Gifted, driven, talented entrepreneurs tend to succeed wherever they end up, but there is a finite natural supply.
What Western nations should concentrate on is growing and exploiting their not-quite-natural-born entrepreneurs. yC seems to be quite good at this but a wider government policy is the most likely way to see sustained growth - not inviting the cream of Indias crop to nip over and pay taxes for twenty years. Delhi is not stupid, and there will be a race to the bottom.
- pash 14y agoI agree with your broader point, but if the United States has a comparative advantage in entrepreneurship, it's not actually zero-sum. That is, if the American legal system, venture funding, etc., combine to offer a foreign entrepreneur a better likelihood of building a successful company there than in her home country—and there's some evidence that that's often the case—then letting her emigrate to the United States should be a net gain for the global economy.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoTrue, but for every non-us company that creates broad democratic institutions and enforceable contracts, then that countries comparative disadvantage shrinks, probably towards a meaningless point. Look at India - democratic, enforceable contracts, and vast internal Market. Sound familiar? Go to New Mexico, or southern California you will find tired, poor huddled masses.