7 ms·
Also lots of repression in countries run by atheist ideologies.
by graemep 1y ago
Also lots of repression in countries run by atheist ideologies.
- CamperBob2 1y agoSuch countries are generally run by personality cults, which are not the least bit atheistic. Same mental bug, just a different exploit. Go to North Korea and try to sell them atheism, for instance. They'll send your remains home in a cardboard box.
- graemep 1y agoThat is the no true Scotsman fallacy. As for North Korea, it is officially atheist.
- CamperBob2 11mo agoYes, it's officially atheist because there's only room for one god figure, who happens to be a man. Christianity and Islam are "officially atheist" in the same absurd way. In NK the one permissible exception is not called Allah or Yahweh but Kim. You know, the guy whose portrait hangs in everyone's home in the exact same spot where you'd find a crucifix in a southern American home. And no, the religious nature of personality cults is not a fallacy. If anything, No True Scotsman applies to claims that a personality cult is not a "real religion." They are absolutely indistinguishable from theistic religions, except for the minor, ignorable detail that the god is alive and walking around. Of course there's also a strong component of ancestor worship in the cult of the Kims. The portrait or other object of veneration is as likely to feature il-Sung as one of the other two. Same bug, different exploit.