3 ms·
This statement from the last paragraph of the very interesting Economist magazine article submitted here is thought-provoking: "Bitcoins tend not to be very sec
by tokenadult 14y ago
This statement from the last paragraph of the very interesting Economist magazine article submitted here is thought-provoking: "Bitcoins tend not to be very secure, says Richard Booth, a consultant at RSA, a cyber-security firm. As some users have found to their cost, hackers can sometimes steal Bitcoins from users’ online vaults. In the latest raid, on September 5th, hackers stole $250,000 in Bitcoins from Bitfloor, a large American exchange, causing it to shut down its operation." What does that say about the overall reliability of Bitcoins as a new form of currency?
A while ago I wrote that perhaps the greatest contribution the Bitcoin experiment will make to humankind is to teach you and me and our neighbors more about the realities of economics. And later I added that the Bitcoin experiment will also contribute to greater understanding of attack surfaces and online crime. Many of the ideas about how to mine Bitcoins, store Bitcoins, and trade with Bitcoins as a medium of exchange illustrate both the strengths and weaknesses of any other medium of exchange in a world full of human beings. Seeing the discussion of Bitcoins here on Hacker News reminds me of early online discussions in the 1990s of online payment systems such as PayPal, and the arguments beforehand that PayPal wouldn't have to invest a lot of time and effort (as it eventually did) building defenses against theft and fraud. If a weakness in a system is attached to a lot of money, the way to bet is to bet that someone will go looking for that weakness, even if you haven't thought of it.
AFTER EDIT: Here is a question for all the security-knowledgeable persons who participate here on Hacker News, a question once asked of the inventor of Pretty Good Privacy (PGP). How expensive do you think it would be for the United States National Security Agency (or a comparable organization from another national government) to crack a Bitcoin store, given that we know that some Bitcoin caches have already been cracked?
- scott_s 14y agoI'm a bitcoin skeptic, but I think that the problems you mentioned in the first paragraph have more to do with the poor security of those individual vaults, not bitcoin itself. But, it does bring up an interesting point: as far as how I know bitcoin works, once you steal the bitcoins, they're stolen. This is different from fiat currency, at least online. If someone breaks into Bank of America's servers and figures out how to transfer a bunch of money from other people's accounts to their own, Bank of American can undo it. As long as the person does not get a cash or cash-equivalent, then it should be reversible. I invite the people who are more familiar with bitcoin to correct me, but as I understand the protocol behind it, once a bitcoin transfer from one owner to another owner is made, it's not (forcibly) reversible.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoExactly. Bitcoin transfers are irreversible. Which means, effectively, they are closer to physical money than electronic balances in this respect.
- xtracto 14y ago"In the latest raid, on September 5th, hackers stole $250,000 in Bitcoins from Bitfloor, a large American exchange, causing it to shut down its operation." What does that say about the overall reliability of Bitcoins as a new form of currency? This can be compared to the Wild West times when gangs used to break into banks and steal lots of money. It is not that the money was weak, but that those storing it did not have proper security. As bitcoins become more popular, you will have more and more competent individuals start offering storage services for these.
- king_jester 14y agoBanks of today have not become competent, only they have fixed those flaws that occurred the most in the past. Given that banks continue to have high visibility breaches and leaks of user information, it is not clear that time is what's needed for Bitcoin to get better security.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> What does that say about the overall reliability of Bitcoins as a new form of currency? As xtracto said, there isn't something inherently insecure about Bitcoin. In fact, AFAIK, there have been no exploits to date of the actual math behind Bitcoin itself. The issue has been breaches of the various institutions dealing in Bitcoins. When a bank is broken into and cash is stolen, you wouldn't say that dollars are insecure ― you'd say that the bank is insecure. This is no different, except it's occurring online.