3 ms·
Qing Dynasty annexed Xinjiang, Taiwan, Tibet, Mongolia, as well as large chunks of Central Asia, and fought with Sikhs over Kashmir. Looks like a good case of i
by macleginn 11mo ago
Qing Dynasty annexed Xinjiang, Taiwan, Tibet, Mongolia, as well as large chunks of Central Asia, and fought with Sikhs over Kashmir. Looks like a good case of imperial expansion to me.
- yanhangyhy 11mo agobasiclly every big country...
- _t9ow 11mo agoThe person you replied to wrote: none of them were products of “Han Chinese imperialism.” This is correct, since the Qing Dynasty was led by the Manchus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qing_dynasty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qing_dynasty), not by the Han Chinese.
- macleginn 11mo agoIt was not the Manchus who reconquered Tibet in the 1950s, after it had been an independent country for several decades. And the general argument is not about whether there is something inherently imperialistc in the Han -- it is about whether the Han are so isolationist that this should somehow prevent China as a political entity from expanding. Well it has not prevented this before (cf. also the Tang period expansion, if we want to talk about more distant history), so I see no reason why it should prevent it now. Unless, say, the CCP cedes control to an openly Han-nationalist party, but then the last one was imperialist alright (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Terror_(Taiwan) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Terror_(Taiwan)).
- thaumasiotes 11mo agoThey also annexed China. That's your idea of "Chinese expansionism"?