3 ms·
Yes, it's a pretty biased article, but I don't mind. You know why? Because he's been pretty spot on. Anyone who's been watching Intel knows how misleading Intel
by mtgx 14y ago
Yes, it's a pretty biased article, but I don't mind. You know why? Because he's been pretty spot on. Anyone who's been watching Intel knows how misleading Intel can be (before anyone accuses me of being an AMD fanboi or something, I own a quad core i7 SNB laptop), and it's obvious ultrabooks will not get to the magical $700 price-point anytime soon (I'm thinking 3-4 years here).
Why not? Well, because while Intel keeps promising that, they have no intention of being themselves part of that price reduction. They have no intention of reducing their prices. So they want to put the whole responsibility on manufacturers. Unfortunately for them, manufacturers have to worry about more than just CPU's to be competitive with ultrabooks. They have to worry about having a quality and high-resolution display. They have to worry about having a fast and large amount SSD, and so on.
Why is it that the laptop/PC market has been considered non-innovative in the past compared to the smartphone/tablet market? Because all the focus has been on CPU's and that has helped Intel. But now people are starting to prioritize more than the CPU in their laptops. In fact the CPU may not even be their #1 or #2 priority anymore. A good display or a good SSD or high quality materials might be.
This sucks for Intel, as the their processors are becoming more than "good enough". ARM devices are "good enough" for most people in terms of performance (iPad's success is proof of that), and an Intel chip that is 10x more expensive will soon become irrelevant for most people. That price gap will just not be worth it to them.
- ajross 14y agoIntel's CPU prices (like all semiconductor products) have been going steadily downward for... basically forever. I don't have a clue what you're talking about. I guess you're saying that Intel gets a higher margin for its parts per-die-area than fabless SoC vendors do, which is undeniably true. But generally that's considered a good thing for the company, not a bad one. Intel has competing parts in the market for almost everything they sell, and still manages to make a product that people are willing to pay significantly more money for. It won't last forever, obviously. Eventually the desktop market will dissolve and servers and mobile SoCs will be all that's left. And Intel certainly seems to be aware of this, c.f. all the marketing effort being pushed into the various low-margin Atom lines.
- mtgx 14y agoI'm not talking about old CPU's going down in price. I'm talking about the "new" CPU's, which is what Intel will be pushing. Not like anyone still wants a cheap $20 Intel Pentium M in their laptops anymore. My point is they are overshooting in performance, and that means they are overshooting in price, too. And most consumers simply won't care. People pay $1000 or more for Macbooks because they are from Apple. They are buying the brand. It doesn't really have anything to do with pricing there. I mean, it's not like you can just say "Hey, if Apple can sell 20 million $1000+ Macbooks per year, then so can HP, or Dell!". Far from it.
- ajross 14y agoI understand that you think Intel CPUs are overpriced. I'm just saying that the market is paying those prices. So you're wrong, simply by definition. Compared to essentially everyone else in the industry, Intel is printing money with their silicon. The only product area that comes close in price per die area that I can think of off-hand are high end FPGAs. And it's not as simple as saying they should just drop the price to sell more -- last I remember reading Intel's 22nm fabs are at capacity. They can only sell more Ultrabooks by cannibalizing sales of other parts. Now, that will change in the future, but it hasn't happened yet.