4 ms·
It's not an unmitigated positive, instead it's a transparent move to paper over the high cost of housing by getting both parents to work. Of course housing pric
by HarryHirsch 1y ago
It's not an unmitigated positive, instead it's a transparent move to paper over the high cost of housing by getting both parents to work. Of course housing prices will adjust accordingly, the supply remains the same, and the demand side has more money to spend.
- kiba 1y agoLand price will adjust accordingly in response to any positive economic news. If you want an unalloy good to come out of these programs, tax lands. Otherwise, any welfare program will just get some of its value captured by landlords.
- blfr 1y agoLand value tax is interesting because it encourages/forces more efficient use but you can do a lot more by cutting demand through limiting immigration and financialization opportunities.
- Avicebron 1y agoI'm not sure why people don't immediately get serfdom vibes whenever they mention a land tax.
- balamatom 1y agoProbably because most of us are already unlanded serfs, except we also get vibes now. Yay, 1000 years of progress!
- Aarostotle 1y agoIt’s the same reason people don’t get serfdom vibes when a government proposes to take over childcare. Governments buying goods for people with tax money turns them into dependents, sometimes permanently. It’s easy to overlook that.
- SoftTalker 1y agoLand value tax won't help unless you greatly reduce the zoning and regulation over what can be built on the land. Putting the land to its most efficient use isn't possible if all you're allowed to build is a two-story detached single family house.
- ecshafer 1y agoGeorgism is the way to prosperity.
- Tanoc 1y agoYou don't reduce the regulation, you increase it's flexibility. Such as allowing dynamic zoning where an area that is zoned as medium density residential automatically becomes hybrid high density residential/low commercial once the districts zoned around it as low density residential are filled. The issue is we zone something and it stays that way until it's manually reviewed and rezoned. The district has no ability to change itself according to the circumstances. It has to rely on a third party that acts without due haste and with great reluctance.
- storf45 1y agoOur property taxes are already crazy high and continue to go up every year. How does this help?
- ransom1538 1y agoExactly. Now landlords will charge more. The owner of assets get all the money.
- ryandrake 1y agoBy your and OP's logic, nothing should be done to subsidize anything or make people's lives more affordable because the excess will be sucked up by landlords. On the flip side, if we did things to make people's lives less affordable, would that translate into landlords giving back by lowering rents? I don't think so.
- OGEnthusiast 1y ago> By your and OP's logic, nothing should be done to subsidize anything or make people's lives more affordable because the excess will be sucked up by landlords. That seems pretty reasonable to me actually? When housing is so supply-constrained, any subsidies/incentives/bonuses/etc. will be captured by the owner of the scarcest asset (real estate). Building more housing at this point seems like it should be a P0 priority before anything else.
- Eextra953 1y agoAcross the US, the majority (2/3-ish) of children already live in families where both parents are employed. I don't see free childcare moving that statistic more than a few percentage points at best. I'm skeptical that this policy would encourage more parents to work and further raise housing costs, especially since this would mostly affect families with children who are pre-K. It is a big policy change but the number of families it will affect is quite small I think. If it does have any effect on housing cost I would expect to see it at the very low-end since it would help low-earners the most.
- usaar333 1y agoIn Quebec it was a 20% jump in mother employment: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-31/affordable-daycare-and-working-moms-the-quebec-model https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-31/affordabl... And had all sorts of negative outcomes for the kids: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/long-term-study-of-universal-preschool-in-quebec-yields-sobering-outcomes/2018/12 https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/long-term-study-of-...