7 ms·
Largest-Triangle-Three-Buckets and the Fourier Transform (2024)
- kohlerm 11mo agoIt is definitely a real problem to be solved. We used something similar in an IOT application some time ago
- sevensor 11mo ago> sine waves and provides the amplitude and frequency of each sine wave. And phase! Good luck trying to reconstruct your signal after you discard the phase. Lest you object that nobody would do this: I’ve seen people actually try to do this, and they couldn’t make sense of the garbage that resulted.
- srean 11mo agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramer%E2%80%93Douglas%E2%80%93Peucker_algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramer%E2%80%93Douglas%E2%80%93... is an alternative if visuals are all that matters. It can and will rain havoc in the Fourier space.
- toddwprice 11mo agoIf stuck on a desert island with only one algorithm in my bag, I’d wish for the Fourier. At least I would die happy.
- r--w 11mo agoFortunately, if you’re a ClickHouse user, you can use the built-in function `largestTriangleThreeBuckets(n)(x, y)`.
- tonyarkles 11mo agoWith respect to the frequency changing as the signal's downsampled, I'm pretty sure the author isn't correctly keeping track of the fact that by having fewer samples they're effectively changing the sample rate. It looks like the FFT every time is using 2048 bins, which is somewhat unexpected. They're not documenting how they're taking a 2048-point FFT with fewer than 2048 samples. Otherwise, fantastic article!
- gblargg 11mo agoTypically you want the peaks preserved when zooming out.
- jiggawatts 11mo agoThe paper describes the LTTB algorithm on page #21: https://skemman.is/bitstream/1946/15343/3/SS_MSthesis.pdf https://skemman.is/bitstream/1946/15343/3/SS_MSthesis.pdf
- woggy 11mo agoThere is no way the frequency doubled with that first down sampling. Author made a mistake applying the FFT.