3 ms·
First party DLLs have copyright.
by pjmlp 1y ago
First party DLLs have copyright.
- fooker 1y agoNo, these are specifically ‘redistributables’. In the rare case they aren’t, you just require the user to obtain it, wink and nod.
- zorked 1y agoTypically in Microsoft redistributables there are terms in the license that says they can only be licensed for use with a Windows license.
- geocar 1y agoHere's the Visual Studio redistributable licensing requirements: https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/license-terms/vs2026-ga-visualcpp-v14-redist-runtime/ https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/license-terms/vs2026-ga-v... There's nothing about Windows licenses in there. There is a specious claim that I can't modify the DLL in some circumstances, but I doubt that's enforceable in any jurisdiction Microsoft could reach me, and to the careful reader the license almost admits as such. If I'm NVidia in this case, these would be pretty easy to follow. Now I redistribute the DLL: My user downloads the DLL and uses my software (with the DLL) in Wine. Good for them. I have a happy customer. _Maybe_ Microsoft is unhappy, but I'm not sure what they can do besides pound sand: _I_ haven't violated those terms, and my user doesn't have any relationship with Microsoft. If I've made a mistake and the Visual Studio redistributable isn't typical, what exactly do you think _is_ a typical license from Microsoft that has the force you suggest?
- pjmlp 1y agoYou are missing all the OS DLLs, COM and WinRT components, .NET libraries, that are covered by Windows EULA. Also the ones downloaded directly via Windows Update from Microsoft servers.
- geocar 1y agoThat's not how copyright law works in the slightest. You can absolutely download a file from Microsoft's website and run that file on Wine and Microsoft cannot get a judge to hold you to any "license terms" elsewhere on that website. I am not your lawyer and this is not legal advice, you are just a moron if you think otherwise. Furthermore, I also don't think Microsoft would claim otherwise! But you are still welcome to prove me wrong by providing just _one_ example on their website of a license that you think could force me to do anything at all, because of a DLL _you_ can give to me (aka "a redistributable")
- Dwedit 1y agoMicrosoft redistributables are just the standard library. Most of the rest of the new DLLs are not backed by any system calls, just by API calls. Except of course for the D3DKMT stuff, that stuff is the real system calls used by Direct3D.