6 ms·
"Apps that display Apps other than your own for purchase or promotion in a manner similar to or confusing with the App Store will be rejected." <- So, sounds li
by saurik 14y ago
"Apps that display Apps other than your own for purchase or promotion in a manner similar to or confusing with the App Store will be rejected." <- So, sounds like the rather benign goal of keeping developers from impersonating Apple's own payment channel and thereby confusing users into believing they are transacting with Apple and then to send Apple support issues.
- MaxGabriel 14y agoApple just released the SKStoreProductViewController in iOS 6, which allows a user to access the app store from within an app (like a modal view that slides up from the bottom). In fact, the WWDC video presenting it uses cross-promotion of apps as its first example use of the view controller. If you're right about Apple's motivation, I would think using the SKStoreProductViewController would be an easy compromise for developers to take. Edit: If you haven't seen it before, this https://www.dropbox.com/s/eytnivsz5ft43mh/iOS%20Simulator%20Screen%20shot%20Oct%201%2C%202012%2012.42.47%20PM.png https://www.dropbox.com/s/eytnivsz5ft43mh/iOS%20Simulator%20...
- jsatok 14y agoAgreed, SKStoreProductViewController is a great addition in iOS 6. Very powerful tool for developers.
- Codhisattva 14y agoAgreed. The headline here is a bit hyperbolic.
- eps 14y agoI actually wish they banned all cross-app promotion, which is the second most annoying thing after the in-app purchase promotions.
- rooster117 14y agoI have personally experimented with TapJoy and even though it worked as a way of bumping my ranking for a small period of time I choose to never use it again and now that I understand those networks I would be pretty happy if they didn't exist anymore. I wouldn't want to get rid of all cross promotion though since if I really liked an app I may want to know more about other apps the developer made.
- mmanfrin 14y agoSo you'd ban all the free demo versions of paid apps?
- tehwebguy 14y agoNo, I think the idea is that there are some full blown apps that seem to serve only to push sales of other apps. Not a big deal for demo + full version apps, but when you pay full price for an app (or download a free, non-demo app) and keep getting pushed to buy other apps it gets pretty annoying. Some apps have done it tastefully, like Temple Run. Others like Scramble (and my assumption is all Zynga apps) just make it a drag.
- jrajav 14y agoArguably, the existence of a full and demo version - along with limits on features or usage period of the demo - will be all the "promotion" you need.
- Karunamon 14y agoNo need for having two apps clogging up the store - have just the app, and have the paid version unlocked via IAP.
- potatolicious 14y agoThis is actually really painful for both devs and users - the main thing being that recovery of the paid upgrade will be finicky and unreliable. The UI for recovering an in-app purchase is the same as the buying UI, which leads many users to mistakenly believe they are being double-charged. Who can blame them, the UI blows. Since devs themselves also do not get any user-specific information when an in-app purchase is sold, it becomes pretty much impossible for your support channels to verify someone actually owns what they say they own. Until the API improves (not holding my breath, it's been like this for, what, 3 years now?) IAP-driven upgrades will hurt both users and developers.
- rhizome 14y agoThen maybe people should be putting more effort into this setup than in goosing popularity juice and user-hostile co-promo bs.
- ghshephard 14y agoCompletely agree as a user. I know this would annoy developers to no end, as their scammy "Load this App and will give you 5 jewels" promotions are a pretty common way to get App store "Popularity" juice, but first, it's annoying within the context of an app, and second, it artificially boosts the popularity of a secondary app that might be complete crap. Still waiting for the authoritative metacritic/rotten tomatoes of the app store to develop. I'm happy to spend upwards of a thousands dollars a year on the App Store - but, other than trusting podcasts/trusted bloggers, it's pretty damn hard to find anything useful on it without wasting a lot of time and money.
- jobu 14y agoThe practice of giving incentives to download apps has been officially banned (by Apple) for over a year, but I don't think the apple reviewers have been enforcing it uniformly.
- __abc 14y agoWhat I wouldn't give for a X day trial period on all apps. Hell, let categorization drive the length of trial period, I don't care. Please just give me a way to "try before I buy".
- crikli 14y agoAgreed. I hate "free" apps that are completely hamstrung until you buy some dumb in-app purchase.
- inthewoods 14y agoYes, and very annoying for my children. And for me.
- rustynails77 14y agoExcellent point. On the iPad, my young kids can do most things easily, except deal with these advertisements. It usually exits the app, brings up Safari and they wonder what's going on. The second most annoying thing is OpenFeint - Can't this be globally turned off?
- saurik 14y agoThe way Apple's restrictions work, you can't build global opt outs like that. Services, for the record, would love to be able to do it; in fact, I was once begged by some companies in the analytics space (think Flurry) to build a global opt out for their products on jailbroken devices, and after contacting other companies I found out they all wanted to do it but couldn't (so I built it).
- aiham 14y agoYou can block kids from using in app purchases by going to Settings > General > Restrictions > In-App Purchases
- evilduck 14y agoThat doesn't stop the app from prompting for the in-app purchases, it just prevents unwanted transactions. Go download Talking Tom (it's "free") and see what parents complain about. Turning off purchasing doesn't stop my 2 year old from hitting one of three or four "upgrade" buttons available on screen at any given moment, bringing up a popup or opening a browser or the app store for cross promotions. I would have actually bought the damn thing because of the entertainment it provides if it weren't for refusing to support the total sleaziness of that monetization method.
- arn 14y agoNah. All app promotion apps that are affected are ultimately sending sales to the official App Store anyway, so there's no impersonation of the payment channel. It does affect a class of apps, including AppShopper (mine).
- saurik 14y agoWhile that's a fair comment, the services being described here really shouldn't be affected: there is no excuse for, say, TapJoy, to mimic the App Store (and I doubt they are doing it, although I haven't seen their UI in a while)... it wouldn't even be optimal for their mission and if they or someone in a similar position is doing so they should probably look at their layout again. However, I will then point out that the distinction you are drawing can get somewhat vague: just because you aren't accepting money, doesn't mean users aren't now confused because they think they are using the App Store's interface; as an example, they might have expectations such as trusting the validity of the reviews and ratings being shown.
- arn 14y agoSure you can argue that. But any App Promotion App is ultimately downloaded from the App Store originally, so I'd assume it's reasonably obvious. But even so, I don't think that Apple's adding a specific clause to their App guidelines due to the very small percentage of people who are downloaded App Discovery apps and then get confused. If I had to guess at their motivation, it would be their attempt at blocking paid-for-promotion schemes that try to game the App Store ranking systems. I think that's more likely.
- jsatok 14y agoTotally agreed. I tried to get that across in the interview for the article. It's pretty hard to say that the pay-for-ranking firms help users, and I think Apple's just taking a first stab at combatting them. I think there's a lot more they can do to improve the ranking algorithm in helping to combat these firms. As a user and as a developer, I really hope these changes help move some of the blatant junk off the Top Lists.