4 ms·
This is missing the forest from the trees. Yes you can attach a keyboard. But carrying a keyboard along with your tablet is more expensive than carrying around
by bad_user 14y ago
This is missing the forest from the trees.
Yes you can attach a keyboard. But carrying a keyboard along with your tablet is more expensive than carrying around a light notebook, like a Macbook Air, which is just as portable, more efficient at certain tasks, less efficient at others.
Also, comparing a PC with a tablet by comparing the hardware and the input interface is totally missing the point. When the PC evolved from DOS to Windows, from single tasking to multi-tasking, from big desktops to laptops and then to thinner notebooks with touch-pads, nobody talked about "post PC", as the evolution was not including regressions of functionality which made it totally obvious that the new devices were just like traditional PCs, only better.
That this happens now only means that these new devices are more limited than PCs, so a hard distinction needs to be made. And going forward, while lines continue to be blurred, the distinction will be extremely simple and effective, by answering just one question ... is software installation from third-party sources easy?
The ramifications by answering Yes to this will be: (1) piracy is easy + (2) mallware is possible + (3) Firefox is available for that device + (4) yes, that's a PC.
- eloisant 14y agoWell, on any Android device software installation from third-party is easy. 1, 2 and 3 are definitely true, but not 4.
- bad_user 14y agoActually that was my point. Until further developments, most Android devices are PCs and any distinction being made to the contrary are arbitrary and short-term.
- vidarh 14y ago> But carrying a keyboard along with your tablet is more expensive than carrying around a light notebook My tablet was <$130. My keyboard with carrying case was <$10. But your comparison with a Macbook Air also misses a substantial other distinction: I can, and often do, leave the keyboard at home. The keyboard lives in my bag. The tablet is small enough to fit in my coat pocket, and so I often take it with me in cases where I don't want to drag more stuff with me, but still want something bigger than my phone. It is significantly more mobile. > is software installation from third-party sources easy? > The ramifications by answering Yes to this will be: (1) piracy is easy + (2) mallware is possible + (3) Firefox is available for that device + (4) yes, that's a PC. By your argument, any Android device is a PC. Fair enough. But it's quite clear that is not the context of the article being discussed.
- bad_user 14y agoI wasn't talking about price, I was talking about how much you need to carry. Having 2 pieces (tablet + keyboard) is worse than having a single notebook (also, don't you need a tablet stand too?). And yes you can leave the keyboard at home, but if you know you'll need a keyboard, carrying your notebook instead is more efficient. I view them as complementary devices, being designed for different use-cases. And by my argument Androids are indeed PCs, at least for now, because excluding the availability of third-party sources, all other distinctions will get blurred within the next 2-3 years.
- vidarh 14y ago> Having 2 pieces (tablet + keyboard) is worse than having a single notebook It is lighter and takes up less space in my bag, and the tablet attaches to the carrying case, so no, it is not "more expensive" on that measure either. > And yes you can leave the keyboard at home, but if you know you'll need a keyboard, carrying your notebook instead is more efficient. Even if I agreed with this - and I don't - having to keep data in sync across multiple devices is a major pain, and reason enough for me to avoid this. I do have a laptop, but it is just that: A computer I use on my lap in my living room. It is too big for me to want to drag around, because it is a replacement for a desktop - which I haven't owned for 10 years or so - rather than something I see as a mobile computer. But I increasingly treat my laptop as a dumb terminal. More of my personal data has my phone as its primary source than my laptop, and I do the vast majority of my work on servers, and so most of the local storage I use on my laptop is stuff that is synced to it from my phone and tablets for convenient local access when I do use it. I'd rather see a situation where my phone or tablet is my primary computing device and the rest just provide convenient screens and input devices as needed. > And by my argument Androids are indeed PCs, at least for now, because excluding the availability of third-party sources, all other distinctions will get blurred within the next 2-3 years. When you start picking your own definitions instead of relying on those the article are based on, the discussion becomes meaningless.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]