4 ms·
I used to live in France and work in technology. To be honest increasing capital gains tax to 60% is not that significant. The entire structure of taxation and
by jgrahamc 14y ago
I used to live in France and work in technology. To be honest increasing capital gains tax to 60% is not that significant. The entire structure of taxation and social charges and the rights of employees means that French entrepreneurs should simply abandon their country if they want to build a startup as might be seen in the US or UK.
Between the inability to fire people who aren't working out, to the huge amount of time off people can claim (on top of their vacation) because of all sorts of rights, to the 35 hour employee work week, to the amount of tax and social charges the employer contributes, France is unsuitable for startups. Various governments have talked about different incentives for small companies, but the on the ground situation has not really changed.
I have a good friend who runs a small company in France making medical devices. The litany of employee problems that he has to face because he cannot fire people is a nightmare and then there's the taxation. The reality is that he is working to transfer the company's IP away from France and then leave. At that point France starts getting 0 EUR in revenue from him and his firm.
Now, in case you think I 'hate France', here's the thing: I think it's a wonderful country to live in, but it is not suited to startups.
- RudeBaguette 14y agoI rebut everything you just said with one article: http://www.rudebaguette.com/2012/02/07/six-lies/ http://www.rudebaguette.com/2012/02/07/six-lies/
- draggnar 14y agocould you maybe summarize your refutations here?
- jgrahamc 14y agoNo, you didn't. My major points were: high taxation and employee laws. Your rebuttal on taxation is: "In addition, these high taxes are the same high taxes that allow entrepreneurs in France to live off of a 70% unemployment salary for 18 months after they are let go from their company. What goes around comes around." And? That's fine, but that's not what a startup cares about. Sure, it's what a person cares about, but it does nothing to address my fundamental point about the tax/social charge burden. And your other point about there being an 18 month delay in the first tax return is pointless: the taxes still have to be paid. On employee mobility, you say: "well, unless of course, you have a periode d’essai (“trial period”) written into the contract (which is the case ~100% of the time), which allows you to let go of an employee with little to no notice for the first three months. Oh, and you can also request to renew the trial period for an additional three months, legally – but you know, if you suddenly hate your employee after six months, well then, buddy, you’re S.O.L." And? After 6 months you hit all the problems of an employee who is very, very hard to fire.
- reitzensteinm 14y agoWait, your rebuttal to "France is not a country where they really promote entrepreneurship" is that the French president gave a speech admitting that the country was risk averse and needed to become more entrepreneurial? If that's the caliber of argument you're bringing to the table, I would soften your tone a bit.
- flyinRyan 14y agoHave you actually been to france? You most certainly can "fire people who aren't working out". The car companies put thousands of people on the streets when the economy tanked. France also tends to have long "probation" periods to ensure they can do exactly that: fire people who aren't working out. What you can't do in France as easily is screw people the way you can in places that aren't as interested in worker's rights (e.g. Zynga and the "google cook"). > to the 35 hour employee work week Again, if you'd actually worked in France you'd know this doesn't apply to everyone. IT workers work long hours in France just like anywhere else. But it seems you also have a misconception about how human productivity works if you think 60 hours a week (you didn't say this, I'm just guessing based on your tone) will give you a more productive year than 35 or 40 hours.
- jgrahamc 14y agoDid you actually read the first line of my comment? "But it seems you also have a misconception about how human productivity works if you think 60 hours a week (you didn't say this, I'm just guessing based on your tone) will give you a more productive year than 35 or 40 hours." No, I didn't say that and you shouldn't read that into what I was saying. I was specifically comparing the situation for startups that I've seen having worked in them in the UK, US and France. And I am specifically NOT wishing to comment on the moral or political motivations for the work environment in those countries. Each country has developed its own history and culture which I do not seek to criticize. My original point was that I do not believe France is a good place for startups. That is all.
- flyinRyan 14y ago>Did you actually read the first line of my comment? The part where you claimed to have worked in france? I don't know you, so why should I take your word at face value when the rest of your comment seems to suggest that you actually haven't worked in france?
- jalanco 14y agoIt took me about 5 seconds to find John Graham-Cumming's bio: http://blog.jgc.org/2010/03/my-bio.html http://blog.jgc.org/2010/03/my-bio.html "As a programmer he has worked in Silicon Valley and New York, the UK, Germany and France and currently works at CloudFlare."
- babarock 14y agoI live in France, I work in the IT sector. I can completely agree with what you say. From my point of view here are the biggest problems entrepreneurs have to face here: - French labor law gives much more power to the employee over the business owner. 35 hours weeks may not be applicable for IT employees, but there are high compensations. Where I work, a 50 hour week is considered "way too much". We get 35 days of paid vacation per year, my manager gets 50, I'm not even counting the myriad of public holidays. Everything from parenting leaves, to medical leaves can last weeks and cost a ton to the employwer. Did I mention that once the "trial" period (usually 3 months renewable once) is over, there are no cheap ways to fire an employee unless she screws up big time? This may all seem nice and righteous, but it's not very motivating to start your own company. - Taxes are so high it's not even funny. For every euro I earn, my employer has to pay a euro in social charges, and this isn't counting the exhorbitant taxes you pay on top of it. It's true that startups do get a grace period of 3 years, but from experience (and talking to other entrepreneurs), this is barely enough. The sickest part is that there's a market developed here where expert accountants teach young entrepreneurs how to "game" the system to minimize "tax-damage". I was shocked when I first discovered this. Until I found out how high taxes are. - Finally, and this one is the most powerful and less obvious one, there's a strong social taboo in France about being rich or even wanting to be. One thing that drives most startups I've encountered, is the drive to become insanely rich. In the US, or at least that's the impression I got there, there's no shame related to wealth. In France it is completely different. Having money, or desiring it, is bad. The rich are the "enemy" (look at recent taxation laws by our government) and the rest of us would be content with very little. Of course this is a bad generalization, but this point of view is prevalent. And this is why, I believe, the proper environment for startups is not a priority for most French people out there.
- cdavid 14y agothe "wanting to be rich" thing is frankly a cliche. Lots of people like money in France as much as everywhere else, and I don't see much difference between France and UK. It is certainly more prevalent in the US, but I would say the US are the exception. And if you want money, I am not sure startup is the likely way of doing it. Certainly, for people with the right diploma, working in the finance sector is much more rewarding financially speaking. Regarding the taxes, I will say what I always say: yes they are higher than in the UK, but you get more. So you need to compare what you're getting, otherwise the comparison is meaningless. I am working in the UK, where I paid around 35 % of taxes, so quite lower than France, where it would be closer to 50-55 % I think for my salary. But then, I get shitty health care and essentially no pension. And if I have kids, I will have to pay a lots of money to get them a decent school. I would love paying 15-20 points more taxes in exchange for that in the UK. IMO, the main issue in France is more the education system and how the incentives are highly biased toward going to a big company. The whole society is highly biased against failure, and the only path to a 'career' is through 'soft' areas. I am just over 30 and my parents don't understand why I am still doing engineering instead of 'managing' people, for example. This is the main reason why I have been leaving outside France for the last 8 years or so, not taxes.
- VSerge 14y agoWhat you say is right, but we also have advantages, like the quality of our engineers, etc. The point is, it might not be optimal but we can deal with it. This 60% exit tax, we won't be able to, and this is why I think it is significant.
- sigil 14y agoThe litany of employee problems that he has to face because he cannot fire people is a nightmare... The workaround for that in France: don't hire people. I worked for a French startup. The founder rented all his employees from a consulting agency that assumed the risks and costs of providing fulltime employment. The end result was something that resembled American at-will employment, but with a higher cost of labor.