4 ms·
I like Mike Masnick, but this seems like a real miss. He should have gotten a second source before running it.
by eli 14y ago
I like Mike Masnick, but this seems like a real miss. He should have gotten a second source before running it.
- rayiner 14y agoThe purpose of the compulsory licensing scheme is the public good, to keep copyright holders from preventing certain socially-beneficial uses. The "disruption" provision a concession to copyright holders, basically promising them that the compulsory licensing scheme won't be used to gut their copyright protections. I think Masnick's argument is that the Royalty Board should use its rate-setting powers to make online radio companies like Pandora more competitive. But Pandora is a for-profit business. Why should the Board give them rates lower than what they can get by freely negotiating with the copyright holders? There are a lot of problems with copyright, but they're on the enforcement side. The streaming radio debate is just about money. Pandora can't make money selling Indie music. They want to sell Britney Spears, because that's what consumers want. But they don't like how much money Sony, etc, are charging for Britney Spears. So they want to force the government to force Sony, etc, to sell Britney Spears for less money.
- 001sky 14y agoHistory> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996 Regulatory capture at its finest.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm not sure how it's an example of regulatory capture, and even so how it's relevant to a discussion about copyright law.
- 001sky 14y agoMany CLECs formed in the post-Telecom Act "bubble" operated using the unbundled Network Element Platform (UNE-P), in which they resold the ILECs' service by leasing the underlying [assets]. This greater dependency on the ILECs made these "UNE-P CLECs" extremely vulnerable to changes in the UNE-P rules. In the meantime, the largest facilities-based CLECs, MFS and TCG, had IPOs and then were acquired by Worldcom and AT&T, respectively, in 1996 and 1998 as those long distance companies prepared to defend their business customers from the Regional Bell Operating Companies' (RBOC) incipient entry into the long distance business. Important FCC Rulings With the Triennial Review in August 2003, the FCC began to rewrite a large portion of the rules implemented by the Telecommunications Act of 1996... And that was that. The cable and telco's own washington. The mechanisms and the game are the same. There will never be a viable business that leases another businesses core assets. Copyright and Fiber are interchangeble, one is just fact/history. These special interests are legalized, entrenched monoloply/cartels. The entire copyright industry is. (elsevier, edu publishers at all levels, et al).
- rayiner 14y agoI'm not sure how this is an example of cable and telcos "owning Washington." The cable companies and the telcos built that infrastructure, and Congress forced them to lease it out to CLECs. It's even less applicable in this context. At least the telco infrastructure was publicly subsidized. Nobody subsidized Britney Spears, etc.
- 001sky 14y agoThe 1996 act was completely undermined by telco lobbying. Its public policy purpose --legislated disruption-- was never successfully implemented. They won the war you never knew was fought, the greatest type of victory. The subtlety of the argument is precisely the point. =] There is a reason the most $$$ paid man in washington is the head of RIAA, the hollywood/old media lobbying group. The Cable and the RLECs (now VZ, T, etc) are all-pro and in the same leaugue.
- javajosh 14y agoI think you are giving Masnick too much credit in his argument. It looks like he confused general copyright enforcement guidelines with specific compulsory rate setting guidelines. Sloppy at best, muckraking at worst. I would be curious to know, though, how often compulsory rates are set and in what specific circumstances, if you know.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ta12121 14y agoWhy should the Board give them rates lower than what they can get by freely negotiating with the copyright holders? The answer is in your own post: The purpose of the compulsory licensing scheme is the public good, to keep copyright holders from preventing certain socially-beneficial uses. If traditional radio compensates rights-holders as a form of advertising, why doesn't internet radio (which has restrictions on how often and how predictably it can play music)?