5 ms·
USA gives South Korea green light to build nuclear submarines
- rayiner 1y agoBrilliant move. Giving South Korea the U.S. approval required to provide for its own defense, while using that to incentivize investment into American shipbuilding.
- echelon 1y agoThat's a genius move! We should get every country to do this. Build your nuclear subs here, in the US shipyards. We'll help you! We can massively expand our capacity, which will be important for self defense in the coming decades.
- tyre 1y agoAn interesting example of this is the US modernizations of its military industrial capacity by supply pre- and during WWI. There was intense debate in the international community as to whether non-warring countries could supply nations at war without being considered combatants. If they aren’t, you can’t neutralize the enemies supplies. If they are, those third countries are effectively part of the conflict. The US had to take the latter stance because it didn’t have a strong industry to product its own weapons. If it supported nations from buying from non-warring parties, it would be shit out of luck if it had its own wars. So it received a lot of investment from European powers, generating jobs, economic growth, and the funding to expand its domestic production without having to take on debt or wait for a war to break out. Come its entry into WWI and then WWII, the US had a strong home base of industrial capacity for arms manufacturing.
- Waterluvian 1y agoI imagine countries would only do this begrudgingly out of necessity. The U.S. has positioned itself as unworthy of trust and respect and is basically taking the mafia protection approach to getting other nations to work with it.
- kakacik 1y agoI would be very worried about any form of built in kill switch / degrade effectiveness based on recent F-16 fiasco that sobered entire Europe into massive military spending. Trust lost is trust that either never comes back or it takes tremendous, long term continuous effort. Not holding my breath.
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agothe good news here is that embedding a kill switch into a nuclear sub won't work very well since they don't communicate with the outside world for months at a time
- mindslight 1y ago"Military functionality license expired. Surfacing required to renew license. Surface Now? [Yes] / [Okay]."
- Waterluvian 1y ago“Dive dive dive” “We can’t. The updates are still updating”
- delfinom 1y agoWell, yes but no. Hence the doomsday planes specifically made to communicate with deep sea subs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_E-6_Mercury https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_E-6_Mercury Tl;dr attenuation of signals in water is frequency dependent, just like in air or walls, etc. So the plane has a 5 mile long antenna
- echelon 1y agoRecent F-16 fiasco? I didn't see this. What happened?
- c420 1y agoI believe op is referencing the halting of EW support and software updates to Ukrainian f-16's. https://bulgarianmilitary.com/amp/2025/03/09/russian-media-claim-u-s-halts-the-f-16s-ew-aid-to-ukraine/ https://bulgarianmilitary.com/amp/2025/03/09/russian-media-c...
- cjs_ac 1y agoPart of AUKUS is this.
- nobodyandproud 1y agoI wouldn’t call it a genius move. Just long overdue: South Korea is one of the last, staunch US allies that can build large ships at scale. But will bringing manufacturing to Philadelphia be a mistake? Will they run into the generations-steeped shipyard workers and steelworkers? Will American steelworkers try put one over to make themselves an expense, or a legit partnership to help each other? I can see this going either way; and I hope this partnership transcends the usual, petty partisanship.
- jltsiren 1y agoIt's more that South Korea and Japan are the last developed countries, where it's still economically viable to build cargo ships. Several European countries have robust shipbuilding industry, but they focus on higher-value ships such as cruise ships.
- nobodyandproud 1y agoHow do they achieve it? The cost of living and social services can’t be that much different from at least mid-tier EU members.
- OneMorePerson 1y agoNot an expert but I think it has a lot to do with what gets prioritized by the government and other groups. Tax breaks and other support aren't infinite and where they (any given government) chooses to use them makes a big impact.
- jltsiren 1y agoBy becoming wealthy later than European countries. Shipyards are long-term investments. It makes sense to build them when you have the expertise and labor costs are in your favor. But once you have built them, they are a sunk cost. You can remain competitive against countries with cheaper labor for decades. Globalization and the growth of international trade also helped. China built new shipyards, but the demand for new ships also grew, keeping Korean and Japanese shipyards in business. Meanwhile, the wage gap is gradually getting narrower.
- beefnugs 1y agoBut doesnt it also give russia incentive for walking distance sabotage
- farseer 1y agoSouth Korea is capable enough to build nuclear submarines even if the US had denied them the said facilities. This saves them money, not having to modify their shipyards.
- echelon 1y agoIt's really great for the US to have customers. We can expand our shipyards again. We should go and find more customers.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> South Korea is capable enough to build nuclear submarines even if the US had denied them the said facilities Technically, yes. Politically, no. “To produce fuel for the submarines’ naval propulsion, the ability to enrich uranium was required. However, this plan probably served two goals, since a country with enrichment capability can also enrich uranium to weapons-grade levels without significant difficulty. The fact that [former President Roh Moo-hyun] launched this plan less than five months after North Korea’s [2003] withdrawal from the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) supports the possibility that his ulterior motive was to acquire uranium enrichment capability in part to enable the future development of nuclear weapons. Ultimately, Roh had to abandon this plan in 2004 amid rising suspicion of South Korea’s nuclear ambitions after the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) discovered that South Korean scientists had previously conducted an unauthorized enrichment experiment” [1]. [1] https://www.csis.org/analysis/will-south-koreas-nuclear-ambitions-subside-next-five-years https://www.csis.org/analysis/will-south-koreas-nuclear-ambi...
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoWhat am I missing about how hard it is to enrich uranium? We did it in the 40s, having a significantly less solid understanding of all of the physics involved. Material science on containers, motors, energy generation, etc have all been significantly improved in the intervening decades. Wikipedia says U235 is ~0.7% of earth deposits, and as little as 7kg may be required for a minimal nuclear device. Processing, 700kg of uranium does not sound insurmountable, even with a terribly slow and inefficient process. Just grinding it up and using some kind of mass spectrometer could trivially separate a 3Dalton mass difference.
- wrsh07 1y agoThe US has an incredibly strange relationship with shipbuilding. Zvi and the Cato institute both have lengthy pieces about why the Jones act is bad [1] [2], and whether or not you believe that has entrenched our shipbuilders, the US essentially manufactures no ships compared to South Korea and China. This naval news post says there are $5 billion in modernization costs for the shipyard needed for this project so it seems like we're still years away from a started (much less completed) project. [1] Nov 2024 https://thezvi.substack.com/p/repeal-the-jones-act-of-1920 https://thezvi.substack.com/p/repeal-the-jones-act-of-1920 [2] June 2018 https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/jones-act-burden-america-can-no-longer-bear https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/jones-act-...
- jauntywundrkind 1y agoIt is worth noting that the US and Korea have already been very engaged in trying to work together on ship building, mostly for the US, which we seem to have gotten quite slow and costly at. From the same source as this article, American HHI working with Korean HD HHI. No real action yet but both companies want to be working together. https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2025/10/hii-hosts-hd-hhi-leaders-at-ingalls-shipbuilding-reinforcing-strategic-partnership/ https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2025/10/hii-hosts-hd-hh...
- rurp 1y agoSeems like a typical trump Big Announcement. No details, doesn't really fit with the actual state of the world, and no clear path to even getting these things built. I'll be surprised if >0 get built in Philadelphia in the next decade.
- nickff 1y ago>"Zvi and the Cato institute both have lengthy pieces about why the Jones act is bad [1] [2], and whether or not you believe that has entrenched our shipbuilders, the US essentially manufactures no ships compared to South Korea and China." One issue is that Naval ships are very different from commercial vessels, and at least in the USA, almost no shipyards have shared facilities and staff between the two products since WWII. Interestingly, most other countries do not build most of their naval tonnage (destroyers and frigates) to the same standards that the USA does (European countries are notable for using commercial hulls standards for these ships). On a related note, the Odd Lots podcast had a (relatively) recent Jones Act debate episode, which is worth a listen if you're interested in the subject.
- phendrenad2 1y agoMaybe we can buy some of these South Korean nuclear submarines, park them off the coast of the US, and use them for energy. If we do it quick, we might be able to get nuclear power going before the environmentalists notice. Edit: Your downvotes only make me more powerful.
- nemomarx 1y agoWhy would we buy south korean subs for this, especially ones south korea is building with us navy help? we have nuclear subs and the us is actually pretty good at building more of them. It's the cheapest kind of reactor we have and doesn't get protested by environmentalists. The transmission from sub / ship to shore is not great I think, though. They're used for power during disaster recovery?
- inejge 1y agoYour post is flippant, or you forgot the /s (Poe's law strikes again), but in case anyone took this seriously: using the subs to provide energy would be grossly uneconomical even by current nuclear power standards. Naval reactors are comparatively puny and optimized for compactness and long periods between refueling, which means using highly enriched fuels: very expensive and a proliferation concern.
- credit_guy 1y agoYour post raises an interesting question. Will the US let South Korea use its naval reactors? The US naval reactors use highly enriched uranium, which can be easily converted into bombs. France used to use highly enriched uranium, but their latest nuclear subs use low enriched uranium (LEU). Now, part of what made the US naval reactors so reliable is that they kept the same design over so many decades. If they change to LEU, that probably requires quite a major design change. If they do that, they might as well allow the civilian industry to use that design for non-military purposes.
- hearsathought 1y agoImagine if south korea needed china's permission to build nuclear submarines. We'd called them china's vassals and attack china for being bullies who deprived nations of their sovereignty. Imagine if the title was : "China Gives South Korea Green Light to Build Nuclear Submarines". What would the comments here be like. No doubt a lot of nonsense about "the ccp" this and "the ccp" that.
- Glyptodon 1y agoI will say that the "in/on US territory" piece is a very key detail. Like obviously no matter the country, if you want to build weapons offshore in their territory you probably need permission.
- hearsathought 1y ago> I will say that the "in/on US territory" piece is a very key detail. That's the point. South korea is not allowed to build nuclear submarines in their own territory. They lack the sovereignty to do it. The US won't give them permission to build one on their own. But you probably knew this and your comment is meant to distract.
- cookingmyserver 1y agoCitation needed. I am unable to find any treaty that prevents the RoK from building nuclear submarines on their own territory.
- hearsathought 1y ago> Citation needed. I am unable to find any treaty that prevents the RoK from building nuclear submarines on their own territory. Are you being intentionally dense? Why wouldn't they be building it in their own territory if nobody was stopping them? Besides, I already replied to your other comment that South korea is not allowed to enrich uranium by the US.
- koakuma-chan 1y agoIs it nuclear in the sense that it has nuclear bombs or it is just nuclear powered?
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 1y agoNuclear powered. i.e. No need to resurface for air (as all oxygen can be recycled or separated from water) and no need to refuel for the entire lifespan of the submarine.
- embedding-shape 1y agoHow long can they actually stay below the surface in practice though? I'm guessing water is filtered on the vessel, but food must be re-supplied constantly I'm again guessing? Maybe they do it like airplanes refuel in the air, rendevouz with another submarine and somehow transfer the resources for food making between then? Probably read too much Tom Clancy...
- echoangle 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Warspite_(S103) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Warspite_(S103) Seems like the record is 111 days submerged. Nuclear Subs are typically pretty big so they can probably bring enough food to last for the entire time without resupply.
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 1y agoYeah that's the official record and it's pretty close to that on average. The main limit is morale. People want their swim calls and sunlight.
- trueismywork 1y ago3 months. There's an episode by smarter everyday about it
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 1y ago