3 ms·
Which is easier to sell folks on? "You'll be able to lie about in the terraformed Martian soil/space station garden/ship farm and gaze at the stars!" or "We'
by angersock 14y ago
Which is easier to sell folks on?
"You'll be able to lie about in the terraformed Martian soil/space station garden/ship farm and gaze at the stars!"
or
"We'll flay the skin from you and replace it with a polymer and wiring. In fact, we may just decide to crack open your skull and yank your brain, and shove it into a box, where electrodes will provide stimulus and try to present a mapping of sensory inputs you aren't evolved to process."
Honestly, I think the former is an easier sell. Also, the technology for the former is here--it just isn't distributed yet.
This singularity transhuman nonsense lacks both wonder and reason. It lacks reason because it depends on a lot of technology that hasn't been invented yet and presupposes that people will want to mutilate themselves on a whim.
Worse, it lacks wonder, because instead of attempting to change the world to suit us--perhaps the most fundamental of human drives--it instead seeks to alter what we are in attempts to make things "easier" and "more efficient".
- efnx 14y agoI think it was William Gibson who said, "the future is here, it just isn't evenly distributed...".
- reso 14y agoI understand your sentiment, but I think you're choosing your examples too carefully. Other singularity-era technology could let us breathe underwater, or increase our muscle and bone-density ten-fold, giving us superhero like strength. I think that's pretty wondrous.
- angersock 14y agoMy reading suggests that we assume this technology is developed and ready to go. I too could see, once we pull out the singularity dust, a future where extensive body modification is possible, where my vision is trivially fixed to have larger spectral response and my skin is a flashing display of whimsy. But, that still supposes quite a bit. Moreover, I'll take your breathing underwater example to point something else out, as well as the muscle/bone-density one. We have that technology--some sort of Self-Contained Underwater Breathing Apparatus; a SCUBA, if you will. Similarly, we have ways of increasing muscle mass using steroids and other additives. And you know what? This is largely the domain of the rich, or of those who have money and time to spend on frivolities. So much of the singularity tech that I see bandied about seems to fall very much in that camp (see also: http://archive.picturesforsadchildren.com/93/ http://archive.picturesforsadchildren.com/93/ ). I'd much rather see better distribution and use of existing technology than wait for The Future--especially when it's presented as Everything's Possible With Science! (Speculative fiction has done a decent job of picking apart some of threads of these sorts of futures...I'd suggest reading some of the Dangerous Visions anthology or more recently Paolo Bacigalupi if you'd like a properly melancholy commentary on the future with Science! There's this annoying problem of the many billions in poverty that somehow always gets waved away.)