3 ms·
Thanks, that's less hyperbolic than the title, but I don't think you've quite captured what he's saying either. I think he's saying if you invent a new tech, Y
by tedunangst 14y ago
Thanks, that's less hyperbolic than the title, but I don't think you've quite captured what he's saying either. I think he's saying if you invent a new tech, YouHolodeck, you're not magically exempt from copyright law and you can't just post existing copyrighted material ("but it's different, it's holographic"). Existing laws should apply, without needing constant updating ("on the internet", "in the holodeck", "in the singularity").
If you want an exception you have to ask for it, you don't get one by default. That does not mean the new technology is illegal. If Disney says no Mickey Mouse in holospace, then no Mickey Mouse in holospace, but you're still going to be free to post holos of your local street corner mime doing his thing.
- icebraining 14y agoSo he's saying that we should have exactly what we always had? New technologies were never exempt from following copyright law. What he's really saying is that he doesn't like that some technologies are actually legal (like Aereo), not because they're new, but because they fall under fair use conditions. And so he wants to kill them by making them "illegal until proven legal".
- tedunangst 14y agoThat is what I think he's saying. I know, it's disappointing when it's not rage worthy. (And if I'm wrong and it is rage worthy, is there any point to reading about it besides getting all ragey?) As for Aereo, I like what they're doing (and wish it were available in more places), but even so, I think they're navigating a fine line between the letter and the spirit of the law.
- tptacek 14y agoYou don't want to lose sight of the fact that he's using this argument to support an injunction; what he's doing isn't quite as benign as saying "all existing laws should apply", because the existing laws don't promise preliminary injunctions in every case where technology butts up against copyright. On the other than, this is a case involving a product that has no purpose other than the one that the content producers say directly infringe their rights; in other words, it is at first blush a better than average candidate for an injunction. But then back on the other hand, he's making general points, not points narrowly tailored to cases like Aereo.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>I think he's saying if you invent a new tech, YouHolodeck, you're not magically exempt from copyright law and you can't just post existing copyrighted material ("but it's different, it's holographic"). Existing laws should apply, without needing constant updating ("on the internet", "in the holodeck", "in the singularity"). I don't agree that he's saying that. The issue is that (leaving DRM circumvention tools aside) standard copyright law doesn't prohibit distribution technologies at all, just infringement. Hollywood doesn't like that -- they want to be in charge of what distribution technologies people are allowed to create, regardless of what they're used for. So their end run around it has two parts: 1) They refuse to sanction the use of the new technology for their own content, and then 2) they argue that because it isn't sanctioned by the major players, substantially all use must be infringing and dissemination of the technology itself (regardless of use) therefore induces that infringement and has no substantial non-infringing use. It isn't about Mickey Mouse and the local mime. Aereo doesn't pick which channels its users watch. Its users can use the technology to watch PBS broadcasts (e.g. of your local mime) that are distributed under Creative Commons or other permissive licenses, or Presidential speeches that as U.S. government works fall immediately into the public domain, or use the technology to record video that the users have negotiated a separate license for with the copyright holders, or make a variety of legal fair uses of the plaintiffs' copyrighted material. Or the users can use it for blatant infringement, e.g. to record sitcoms and burn them to DVDs to sell in the street. But that's all between the copyright holders and the individual users. Aereo is just providing the technology -- and Hollywood is trying to stop the technology, not the infringement.
- tptacek 14y agoDid you read the amicus that Techdirt is (poorly) summarizing? Because I read your comment and I can't find anything in it that refers to what Oman actually said. You instead seem to be arguing about what "the content industry" "wants". The content industry obviously wants a lot of silly things, but we're discussing a specific court filing --- more importantly, that's what 'tedunangst is talking about, and so if you're not talking about Oman's filing it's very weird to say he's wrong.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago