4 ms·
I'd personally like to say "Please keep HN civil, free from trolling, and intellectual." This site has been a great resource - and that's at least partially bec
by kaens 18y ago
I'd personally like to say "Please keep HN civil, free from trolling, and intellectual." This site has been a great resource - and that's at least partially because the tone of the vast majority of the community here is pretty serious.
I have an account on reddit as well, and my tone over there is different than my tone here. On reddit I make a decent amount of off-the-cuff remarks, occasionally troll a bit, participate in pun threads, and also have a decent amount of intelligent debate and discussion. Here I keep my mouth (fingers?) shut (stoppped?) unless I have something to say, because that's the vibe here.
Here, I'm more likely to vote people up who have a differing opinion on an issue, or even if they have an opinion that offends me, if they are able of stating and defending their position logically. On reddit, I'd probably just skim over their post.
Etc.
The tone of this site has gotten a little lighter since the first time I was here, and it seems to have gotten a lot more of a focus on the business side of things, which is fine - but if people aren't careful, the site will devolve into yet another pick-your-favorite-site-here.
So yeah. Please keep HN grown-up. It's nice to see mostly responsible discussion happening on a site like this, and I hope it continues to happen.
- TooMuchNick 18y agoAnd by "grown-up," we mean "like grown-ups who aren't from TechCrunch."
- kaens 18y agoI'm not familiar with this whole TechCrunch debacle, other than reading about that guy being spit on. By "grown-up", I mean "thinking before posting, and posting in a way that indicates that one has a generally 'mature' mental-model". This isn't something that can be measured objectively, more of an attribute that emerges from the sum of a users postings - and posters on HN have generally passed the "act-like-an-adult" test so far.
- icey 18y agoYou really should re-read the top level of this post. It's directed squarely at you.
- TooMuchNick 18y agoI just learned the very hard way to never ever comment on HN after drinking.
- ashu 18y agoSeems like HN should ask a GMail Goggles-like "Are you drunk?" question before you are allowed to post comments!