4 ms·
A one-off $10K fee per hire is chump change, compared to the alternative: if your H1-B costs 50K per year + 10K one-off, he's still much cheaper than a US-based
by toyg 14y ago
A one-off $10K fee per hire is chump change, compared to the alternative: if your H1-B costs 50K per year + 10K one-off, he's still much cheaper than a US-based developer who wants 60K per-year -- and that's not exactly the top going rate.
Corporations understand Marx much better than workers ever did.
- SeckinJohn 14y agoIt is not legal to underpay H1Bs. They literally should not be able to fill those positions with Americans if they are complaining about this.
- toyg 14y agoI'm curious to know which sort of rocket science Microsoft does that is not taught at US universities. Of course they are unable to fill positions at a given salary level. It's quite hard to find tomato-pickers at slave-like wages.
- blinkingled 14y agoHow many Comp Sci or related discipline students do the US universities graduate every year? How much is the demand? How many of those graduates are from other countries and need VISA to work? How do you know what skills Microsoft needs and why do you assume they pay slave wages?
- barrkel 14y agoI don't think you're fully informed. Sometimes it's difficult to get qualified applicants at all, at any salary level. A lot of developers are more interested in the specifics of the job, product, company etc. than the salary (once it meets a certain minimum floor); and for other jobs, the specific knowledge and experience needed is very scarce. If there are 20 people qualified for a job and 21 open positions, no salary level is going to fill all the positions. I had a H-1B visa once upon a time, but I never moved to the US. The company wanted me to, but I preferred London to Santa Cruz. Didn't stop me working for the company remotely, paid out of their UK sales office. Now I don't know what proportion of H-1Bs are like that - a global search to fill a local position - but it's definitely non-zero. (The reason I'm pushing back on this is because I don't want HN to be a happy home for the same sad sack of devs Slashdot hosted when I last frequented there some years ago; "dey took our jerbs" was a constant refrain any time H-1B came up.)
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoOh, I dunno. American software hiring is blatantly broken. I've been there, I've seen it, submitting my resume half a dozen times to the same companies to finally get an interview and, yes, eventually, a job offer. But the first five times being told that the company has no matches for me. Meanwhile, the company complains it can't find engineers.
- zpk 14y agoI could not agree with you more. It's literally part of the business model for consulting firms here.
- lrobb 14y agoIt might not be legal, but it's easy to do.
- joshz 14y agoMicrosoft doesn't pay that low. Here's[1] some data from 2 years back. Friend of mine got over 100k last year, they treat H1-B holders well. [1] http://goo.gl/P0UCj http://goo.gl/P0UCj
- toyg 14y agoAnd what's the cost of a developer leaving after 6 months for better opportunities? Periodic raises are part of overall costs, and again a locked-in visa-holder is cheaper to "maintain" in that regard.
- Nitramp 14y agoYou're neglecting the salary of the employee that you hired in that, aren't you? The 60k are on top of the salary you're paying, which would typically be comparable to the US-based developer's. Companies don't hire people on H1B to save money, but because they are starving for talent. EDIT: Sorry, didn't understand that you referred to the employee's salary with the 50K. Are you assuming that H1B employees are payed less in general?
- toyg 14y agoWhat? - US developer salary: 60k per year (cheap areas etc etc). Over three years: 180k. - Foreign visa: 50k per year + 10k one off. Over three years: 160k. And of course, the foreigner is locked into the company for X years, whereas a local can piss off after three months. Note: I say that as an Italian-born UK resident who looked into the US visa system and found it, er, suboptimal for everyone involved except corporations.
- raverbashing 14y agoOh, so you've looked into the H1-B system But do you know anyone that's actually employed like that? I know several - None of them get payed less than their colleagues - They are usually already at the "top of the chain", it's difficult for new/better job opportunities to show up. Inside the US it may be more difficult, surely, but they have no problem leaving the job and going elsewhere (and H1-B is a little less restrictive in swapping jobs than some work permits in Europe) One of the main issues today is the time it takes to apply for a Green Card, some of them are in their nth H1-B renewal now with little perspective of getting a Green Card
- blinkingled 14y agoI worked on a H1B for 9 years before getting my Green Card and I saw two types of people working on H1B - people that were adequate for their jobs for which the company did not find enough people (qualified ones not the under/overqualified) and extraordinary people with specific skills in high demand. Both class were paid reasonably well, above average salaries.
- andrewcooke 14y agomarx is not synonymous with arithmetic (or even basic bookkeeping).
- toyg 14y agoNothing to do with that; it's about harnessing the reserve army of labour, which is practically unlimited at global scale.