I don't think the argument is whether Apple pushed the industry forward. They absolutely did. The question is, if they knew no patents would get awarded for so

I don't think the argument is whether Apple pushed the industry forward. They absolutely did. The question is, if they knew no patents would get awarded for software features like slide-to-lock or gesture control, would they still have introduced the iPhone? I believe they would have, but it would be great to hear your thoughts if you disagree.