5 ms·
For those that do not understand the subtext, the reason Napolitano does not use email is that there is no persistent, written record with her name on it that c
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
For those that do not understand the subtext, the reason Napolitano does not use email is that there is no persistent, written record with her name on it that can be used as evidence against her. This is a common strategy/policy used by many people, particularly among the political class. It is an excellent way to inject ambiguity into any potential culpability.
It is a common practice for people that wish to minimize evidence trails should things come to that. Don't conflate "don't use" with "ignorant of". It is a voluntary choice.
- BklynJay 14y agoWhy does she go on to say that some might call her a "Luddite"? This would imply that she doesn't believe in technology, which could logically be extended to perhaps include "understand" technology.
- reitzensteinm 14y agoThe implication in that sentence is that people may assume she is a luddite, but they would be wrong in doing so.
- starpilot 14y agoBecause she's throwing around the term casually, like people do? "I'm really OCD about this" ≠ actual self-diagnosis of OCD
- ams6110 14y agoI'd feel pretty comfortable saying that no cabinet-level official really "understands" technology enough to make decisions on cybersecurity. They rely on subordinates who (hopefully) do.
- jeffchuber 14y agoThis is also exactly why she should be forced to use email. Any appointed government position should come under extra public scrutiny.
- msh 14y agoShould all her face2face conversations be recorded too?
- fleitz 14y agoIn a public capacity, certainly. The DHS should work with other branches of government to ensure that the conversations of all public employees are recorded and sent to the public at large for review. By having her conversations recorded and played back in Wal-Marts average citizens could report any suspicious activity she makes to a Wal-Mart manager. What if a Wal-Mart customer recognized someone she was meeting with as a terrorist in disguise. Or that someone had brought more than 2 oz of water to a meeting and that it might be a bomb. These are important measures that she should be taking to ensure her freedom. Just like the government monitors our conversations at 655 Folsom to protect our freedom, we should monitor theirs to ensure their freedom. Government officials usually enjoy the most amount of freedom in a society, we know that terrorists hate us for our freedom and we know that they've attempted to destroy government buildings during 9/11, therefore the public should be on high alert to help government officials maintain their freedom by monitoring all their communications. It's really the least we can do to protect them from freedom hating terrorists. Unless she's a terrorist herself, or doesn't love freedom I'm not sure why she would be trying to hide her conversations from us.
- Uchikoma 14y agoBest HN comment ever.
- officemonkey 14y agoNo, it's really not. Anything which makes HN more like reddit is not a good thing.
- revelation 14y agoOf course, some government officials aren't quite so smart and seek to just circumvent any recordkeeping system by using private email accounts hosted by 3rd parties [0]. [0]: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20070551-503544.html http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20070551-503544.html
- sliverstorm 14y agoHey, that strategy is just fine if nobody knows about the account. That can be difficult to maintain though.
- randomfool 14y agoThat's only a reason to avoid government email- personal email remains personal (which is why Sarah Palin allegedly conducted so much 'state' business via personal email). It concerns me that the one in charge of protecting so much is so isolated from what they are protecting. I often worry that the proposals to protect the Internet do more harm than good, and I wish those in charge had more vested interests.
- systemtrigger 14y ago> personal email remains personal If you believe that, why cite Palin's Yahoo! account as an example? > [Napolitano is] isolated from what [she is] protecting Her choice is congruent with the limitations of the protocol, and for that I respect her.
- Vivtek 14y agoI believe by "personal remains personal", grandparent meant that the legal requirements for official email do not apply to an official's "personal" email - even when that personal email is used solely to circumvent the legal requirements.
- fluteflute 14y agoInterestingly, the UK has just clarified that personal email/texts can be made public - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19775763 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19775763
- taw9 14y agoPerhaps it could also be argued that she doesn't use it because she understands it too well... Come on, you think that new NSA station in Utah is limited to foreign surveillance?!
- fpp 14y agoVery right - it's called accountability. At the same time (at least in Germany) they want to force citizens to use email (accounts) where they have complete control of the servers / infrastructure it is provided from. In the US they are e.g. strangling GAO that has at least in the past created some level of accountability for government dealing. Other means of oversight are also step-by-step turned into false fronts. If you go from email (for which regulations for record keeping exist) to other means of electronic communications (e.g. rt-messaging, encrypted messaging with personal / keys linked to your gov. position) you at best increase the efforts for recovery to a level that it becomes infeasible in most cases or make it impossible when [due to strange coincidence] the crypto-keys have been lost. Guess it more-and-more becomes clear where this is leading to in the long run - zero accountability and arbitrary state power where you have to prove that something is not right (which you then of course can't).