4 ms·
Yawn. Yet another "I don't like suburbs and/or people who do like them therefore suburbs are evil and/or said people are cretins." screed. If a puritan is som
by anamax 18y ago
Yawn.
Yet another "I don't like suburbs and/or people who do like them therefore suburbs are evil and/or said people are cretins." screed.
If a puritan is someone who is mad because someone, somewhere is having fun, what is the word for such people?
Note that he's pining for a past that (1) didn't really exist and (2) to the extent that it existed, people (mostly) abandoned it for suburbia.
There are still some instances and he's welcome to live in one. He's even welcome to build more, with his money. (If he's right, folks will flock to them. If he's wrong, well, shouldn't he take the hit?) The folks in suburbia won't mind.
And that's what makes them better than he is. They don't get pushed out of shape when someone has different preferences.
- gravitycop 18y agoYet another "I don't like suburbs [...]" screed. Speaking of suburbs, or exurbs, have you seen the latest ones? This one is 51 miles northeast of San Jose: http://www.mountainhouse.net/town/technology.php http://www.mountainhouse.net/town/technology.php Mountain House is truly ready to be the town of tomorrow with its comprehensive technology plan. All homes and businesses will be wired with: · A cutting-edge, expandable fiber-optic broadband telecommunications infrastructure · Virtually unlimited high-speed internet access to online and electronic information · Video conferencing capabilities in both commercial and residential structures and the ability to order goods and services online · A state-of-the-art, community-wide intranet, MyMountainHouse.com, that allows residents special local connectivity, including the ability to access children's schools or in-town businesses without picking up the phone
- ardit33 18y ago1) That past did really exist. There was towns/cities, and rural land (with houses miles apart). Suburbia tried to be a hybrid, something between country living and city living, but failed at doing both miserably. There are other social factors. At least, here in CA, there is a huge adversity against building more density, (the NIMBY effect). A vocal group of people are opposed to tall building/building anything close to their backyard, creating a lack of density, and artificially limiting the free market and real town-higher-density formation, at a reasonable price.
- anamax 18y ago> 1) That past did really exist. I'm referring to the delusions that he has about the "grand doings" of folks in town squares. (I do like the town squares that have an artillery piece set up by the local VFW chapter but I don't think that that's what he has in mind.) > Suburbia tried to be a hybrid, something between country living and city living, but failed at doing both miserably. Failed according to whom? Not the folks who pick suburbia over towns/cities and rural, which are still available for those who want to live in them. > At least, here in CA, there is a huge adversity against building more density, (the NIMBY effect). It's not NIMBY to point out that high density is often a disaster. Besides - CA is a big and mostly empty state. There are plenty of places where you can build high density that is no where near someone's back yard. And, it's fair to point out that CA also has govt restrictions that significantly reduce rural living.
- bokonist 18y agoMany people did not choose the suburbs freely. They were driven out of the cities by incredibly high levels of violence. The typical American city now has a homicide rate 10X to 100X that of a Victorian era European city. That's not a typo, 1990's DC had a homicide rate 100X that of London in 1900.
- pg 18y agoI believe that statistic, but the truth is that people were driven out of cities in cars. The violence is probably effect as much as cause.
- bokonist 18y agoIf suburban living had been a mere preference, it would show up in real estate prices, not in population loss. To get massive population loss, people have to be unwilling to buy at any price. When the crime rate increased in the 70's, people sold their houses at fire sale prices, or just abandoned them altogether. Great swaths of American cities ended up looking like this: http://www.jim-frizzell.com/Philadelphia2001/04-18-01/04-19-01jefferson_and_darien_north_philadelphia.jpg http://www.jim-frizzell.com/Philadelphia2001/04-18-01/04-19-... Meanwhile, dense city neighborhoods that have suburban levels of violence tend to have much higher real estate prices than the suburbs. This indicates that people really do prefer cities, but it's the violence that keeps them out.
- queensnake 18y agoJamais Cascio has termed it 'Aspirational Apocophilia': http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/cascio20090103 http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/cascio20090103