3 ms·
> A missile would probably be seen long before it reaches its destination and could be shot down. There's no way of hiding in space unless you develop some sort
by stcredzero 14y ago
> A missile would probably be seen long before it reaches its destination and could be shot down. There's no way of hiding in space unless you develop some sort of cloaking device.
Everyone says this, which should be a red flag. There's nothing in the physics that precludes this. You just need to redirect your thermal emissions in a direction it doesn't matter and spoof any detectors that could spot you by your occlusion of distant objects. Then it becomes a tactical problem, not a physics one.
If all of your enemy's assets in space are visible, then such stealth is easy. Then you can calculate directions to aim your thermal emissions and spoof the enemy occlusion detectors. So the only way to make stealth difficult in space is to have stealthed sensor platforms.
I think this gives rise to interesting tactical situations.
- wtracy 14y agoBlack-body radiation is hard to aim. If you have any active systems on board, I imagine you would have to actually refrigerate your exterior to keep it from lighting up in the infrared range. This also assumes that your enemy doesn't have observation platforms scattered throughout the solar system that can spot you from dozens of different angles.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Black-body radiation is hard to aim. If you have any active systems on board, I imagine you would have to actually refrigerate your exterior to keep it from lighting up in the infrared range. Exactly. A long, skinny, highly reflective parabola would do it. You'd have to refrigerate the exterior of that, too, of course. > This also assumes that your enemy doesn't have observation platforms scattered throughout the solar system that can spot you from dozens of different angles. No, this assumes that you have high confidence that you know where those platforms are, and that you can aim your emissions in a tight enough beam. Also, don't discount sabotage and espionage. If only one enemy sensor is in a position to see your stealth infiltrators, then there's a single point of failure which is a good target for espionage. When the US military goes in with stealth bombers, they don't just rest on their technological laurels, they also send in elite forces to knock out radar sets. This means that the enemy should maintain double or triple redundant observation platforms. Or does it? What if their observation platforms are stealthed? Then an attacker is playing a guessing game. Stealth in space won't be perfect, and it will be fraught. However, it will serve a deterrent purpose against other stealth. It will exist because the disadvantage of having no stealth at all leaves open a powerful game changing tool to be exploited by your foe.