6 ms·
The interesting thing about warfare portrayed in fiction is that it's not only a very idealized model of warfare but it tends to be based on a zeitgeist which i
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
The interesting thing about warfare portrayed in fiction is that it's not only a very idealized model of warfare but it tends to be based on a zeitgeist which is easily decades if not centuries out of date.
For example, modern naval warfare, setting aside aircraft even, is of the sort where the combatants generally fire missiles at each other across the horizon (or would be, if there was any significant amount of naval warfare between first world powers). However, in scifi space battles you have warfare which tends to look more like naval battles in the 17th century than anything else. Inaccurate weapons. Point blank ranges. Etc. That sort of warfare was obsolete over a century ago. And even the close cousin in the form of long but still within visual range battleship battles were very rare even during WWII and terribly obsolete after that (the Falklands war being a decent example).
The idea that a laser at a range where the enemy is visible with the naked eye is going to miss is ridiculous. Similarly, the idea that any missile fired would not be guided, or that a guided missile would miss at such close ranges, is equally ridiculous.
But, SciFi isn't about predicting the future so much as it is about setting up a premise with which to tell a story, so I can forgive these shortcomings.
- Swizec 14y agoI would like to think that in the future battles will have to be fought at short range because everyone's scrambling technology will be so advanced the missile needs to get there before it can be made to miss its targets. For instance.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kibwen 14y agoWe may not even need guided missiles in future warfare. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railgun http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railgun "The United States Naval Surface Warfare Center Dahlgren Division demonstrated an 8 MJ rail gun firing 3.2 kg projectiles in October 2006 as a prototype of a 64 MJ weapon to be deployed aboard Navy warships. [ ... ] Such weapons are expected to be powerful enough to do a little more damage than a BGM-109 Tomahawk missile at a fraction of the projectile cost. [ ... ] Its expected performance is a muzzle velocity over 5,800 m/s, accurate enough to hit a 5 metre target over 200 nmi (370 km) away while firing at 10 shots per minute." I'm sure that these hypothetical railgun projectiles have some method of in-flight correction, but we haven't forgotten how to do trigonometry since WWI. :)
- Retric 14y agoThe problem with rail guns is 10,000 km is point blank range in space (1/30th of a light second). But at 6km/s that's ~ a half an hour travel time.
- bdunbar 14y agoHowever, in scifi space battles Not all scifi space battles. Just the battles in bad scifi. Movies seem prone to this. I suspect because making what we think will be realistic space combat visually appealing and easy to follow would be super hard. Fiction that gets space combat right (off the top of my head) include Stirlings 'Stone Dogs', and Vinge's 'Deepness in the Sky'.
- EdwardCoffin 14y agoVinge's Marooned in Realtime has some neat ideas for space combat too. I think that Niven and Pournelle's book The Mote in God's Eye had some interesting ideas. As I recall, space combat involved spherical vessels pouring energy into each others' shields with heavy lasers. The first one to overload the others' shield won.
- bdunbar 14y agoI should have remembered 'Mote', thank you. The first one to overload the others' shield won. Lasers, nuclear-tipped torpedos, all add to the energy budget. Pent up energy cascades _in_ when your field collapses. 'Brenda' by Larry Niven, set in the CoDo Universe, has as it's backstory the cleanup job after a really large fleet engagement.
- ks 14y agoA missile would probably be seen long before it reaches its destination and could be shot down. There's no way of hiding in space unless you develop some sort of cloaking device. "Aircraft carriers in space" makes sense to me. I assume that warping space requires a lot of energy that requires huge reactors that don't fit in small fighters. They would depend on a "mothership" for long range travel.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoHere's an example of how generalizing space-combat is difficult. The nature will depend on technological capability, extremely so. For example, if you can shoot missiles at, say, 10km/s that leads to a different type of combat than if you can do so at 100km/s, or 1000km/s, etc. Highly relativistic missiles, at say 0.98c or more, are effectively impossible to defend against, and massively potent. At that speed a kinetic "warhead" massing only 10 milligrams (perhaps a millimeter in diameter or less) would have an explosive yield of nearly a kiloton. More so, when the missile is 15 million kilometers away (40 times the distance from the Earth to the Moon) the time between when the target detects the missile and impact is only one second. Even at technology levels far below that level missiles can still remain extremely effective. At long distances (thousands of kilometers away) the missiles would engage in evasive maneuvers to avoid being shot down by speed-of-light weapons. And then at some point they would release a huge number of evenly spatially arranged fragments. At a missile speed of about 40km/s (which is a reasonable estimate for speeds achievable by cutting edge and next generation propulsion technologies today) you get a ratio of warhead mass to TNT equivalent explosive yield of about 190:1 (meaning that a 1 kg impactor yields 190 kg of TNT equivalent in kinetic energy). Which means that a single 500 kg missile could break up into a thousand fragments, each of which is only 3 cm in diameter (if made out of depleted Uranium) and has the kinetic energy punch of nearly 100 kg of explosives. If, for example, we imagine a crewed ship capable of accelerating at, say, 5 gees (~50 m/s^2) and we imagine a fairly small ship that is only about 100 m^2 in cross-section then an attacker could fire a barrage of only 8 such missiles and fragment at a distance of 400 km and have an effective 100% chance of at least one fragment hitting the target. Even with high powered lasers it is no small feat to destroy a 3 meter target at 400 km distance. As the speeds of the missiles go up they become more and more effective and difficult to shoot down.
- molmalo 14y agoYes, in the [Falklands/Malvinas] war, it was demostrated that direct combat between battleships is obsolete. But in Millennium Challenge 2002, it was demonstrated that a large attack with small boats and smart tactics, can still be deadly. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002)
- Athas 14y agoThe jury's still out on that one. Van Ripers strategies involved such things as using motorcycle messengers (without accounting for the added latency to information exchange) that were invulnerable, and his proposed ship-to-ship missiles were way too large to fit on the vessels he used. It's too complex a case for me to understand fully, but it's clear that Van Riper totally underrepresented the disadvantages of his low-tech methods.
- jamieb 14y agoEvacuate? In our moment of triumph? I think you overestimate their chances.
- fafner 14y agoNot only zeitgeist. But portrayal in fiction requires heroism, action, and suspense. You don't get that with real warfare. Being shot at by an enemy you can't even see and then calling in an air strike at the location where you expect the enemy to be is not the "romantic vision" people have about war. They want close combat with sweaty men fighting each other in heroic ways. What would be a more realistic portrayal? A bunch of automated drones fighting each other. Space even removes a lot of tactical elements. So the one who has the right number of good enough drones wins. That's boring. No heroism, no action, no drama, no suspense. The sweat and suspense is left in non heroic and to outsiders a bit boring fashion at the engineer's drawing board.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoAh yes. If you allow canonical, stereotypical battles then there's a high risk they could be boring. So you have to either figure out a way to portray them that aren't boring or you pick situations that are unusual to portray. As a case in point, consider the way submarine combat is portrayed.
- fafner 14y agoSubmarines are a good point. But with submarines you have the whole hide&seek thing going. That's a lot of suspense right there. However in space there is no hide&seek. The problem is that space is so huge that unless you assume really fast spaceships there is no way of hiding. Planets and moons are too far apart to be really used as cover or tactical element.
- Lexarius 14y agoHide and Seek can work in space, even without magical cloaking technology. Space is very big, so if you're far enough away it may be difficult to tell a (properly designed) ship from random rocks or man-made debris unless you're looking dead at it already. Especially if you're flying in an area where lots of debris is already present, like an asteroid belt or a planet's ring. Doing it in near-earth orbit might be tricky, though, since people watch the sky a lot. Information from ground-based tracking stations could be used to identify large unknown orbiting objects.
- gaius 14y agoMany of my friends believe a) submarines still have deck guns and b) warships at sea still fight by drawing alongside and attempting to board. And these are the military enthusiasts!
- InclinedPlane 14y agoa) This is funny because even surface ships don't tend to use large guns as weapons except under specific circumstances. Other than torpedoes, modern submarines use guided missiles for attacking land targets or other ships that are out of range of their torpedoes. b) Interestingly enough, this is probably the most dominant form of naval warfare in the last decade or so, due to the increase in piracy off the horn of Africa. Of course, this isn't the way things go down when warships are on both sides.
- incision 14y ago>But, SciFi isn't about predicting the future so much as it is about setting up a premise with which to tell a story, so I can forgive these shortcomings. So true. It pains me how often I see SciFi, particularly older works, judged on the in/accuracy of "predictions".