4 ms·
I just tried it on several of my repos and I was rather impressed. This is another one of those bizarre situations that keeps happening in AI coding related ma
by andybak 11mo ago
I just tried it on several of my repos and I was rather impressed.
This is another one of those bizarre situations that keeps happening in AI coding related matters where people can look at the same thing and reach diametrically opposed conclusions. It's very peculiar and I've never experienced anything like it in my career until recently.
- esperent 11mo ago> people can look at the same thing and reach diametrically opposed conclusions. It's very peculiar and I've never experienced anything like it in my career until recently React vs other frameworks (or no framework). Object oriented vs functional. There's loads of examples of this that predate AI.
- alansammarone 11mo agoI dont think it's quite the same. The cases you mention are more like two alternative but roughly functionally equivalent things. People still argue and use both, but the argument is different. Even if people don't explicitly acknowledge it, at some level they understand it's a difference in taste. This feels to me more like the horses vs cars thing, computers vs... something (no computers?), crypto vs "dollar-pegged" money, etc. It's deeper. I'm not saying the AI people are the "car" people, just that...there will be one opinion that will exist in 5-20 years, and the other will be gone. Which one... we'll see.
- esperent 11mo ago> People still argue and use both, but the argument is different React vs no framework is at least in the same ballpark as AI vs no AI. Some people are determined to prove to the world that React/AI/functional programming solves everything. Some people are determined to prove the opposite. Most people just quietly use them without feeling like they need to prove anything.
- Xss3 11mo agoThis is such an apples to oranges comparison that it makes me suspicious of your motives here. Bad documentation full of obvious errors and nonsense is very different to having an opinion on OO vs Functional programming. Even that sentence sounds insane because who would ever compare the two?!
- DrewADesign 11mo ago> at the same thing But you’re not looking at the same thing — you’re looking at two completely different sets of output. Perhaps their project uses a more obscure language, has a more complex architecture, resembles another project that’s tripping up the interpretation of it. You have have excellent results without it being perfect for everything. Nothing is perfect and it’s important for people making these things to know how, right? In my career I’ve never seen such aggressive dismissal of people’s negative experiences without even knowing if their use case is significantly different.
- naveen99 11mo ago[flagged]
- statusfailed 11mo agoWhich repos worked well? I've had the same experience as op- unhelpful diagrams and bad information hierarchy. But I'm curious to see examples of where it's produced good output!
- oblio 11mo agoYou could link your docs so we can compare them to OP's docs. No need to guess.
- reconnecting 11mo agoSame here. Original: https://docs.tirreno.com/ https://docs.tirreno.com/ Deepwiki: https://deepwiki.com/tirrenotechnologies/tirreno https://deepwiki.com/tirrenotechnologies/tirreno Github: https://github.com/tirrenotechnologies/tirreno https://github.com/tirrenotechnologies/tirreno
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]