10 ms·
Notch: "I'd rather have minecraft not run on win 8 at all than to play along."
- sbochins 14y agoDon't quite get what his beef is with Windows 8. It doesn't really seem to be "openness" issues like he is saying. If that were the case why would he have ported his code to Xbox (another closed microsoft platform). If he doesn't like the Metro UI why is he complaining about things being closed. I guess people don't usually really think about what they say when they tweet.
- kreeger 14y agoThe Xbox never was an open platform to begin with, unlike the PC. The PC has never been the kind of platform to lock stuff down; while Microsoft may have their merits for doing so, a lot of people are up in arms about it and rightly so (as the PC is so widely distributed). Plus, while Mojang did license and partner the code with another firm for the Xbox port, they didn't create it directly themselves.
- reddit_clone 14y agoWell, XBox was a closed system to begin with. May be his beef is that Windows, up to now fairly open is now becoming a walled garden. And he is being vocal about it.
- powertower 14y agoWindows 8 app certification requirements http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/apps/hh694083.aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/apps/hh69408... > 1.2 Your app must be fully functional when the customer gets it from the Windows Store > 1.3 Your app’s trial functionality must reasonably resemble its full functionality > 1.4 Each app must display only one tile after it is installed ... Have no idea what he is complaining about. If he doesn't want to be on Metro, he can always be on the Desktop. He certainly doesn't mind it being on iPhones, iPads, and on Android devices.
- vyrotek 14y agoThese all seem like great requirements to me. FWIW, I'm actually using Windows 8 right now. I play plenty of games and don't use the market at all.
- zmmmmm 14y agoYou've listed exactly 3 points from a multipage document with dozens of requirements as if they summarize the whole document. This is not true - the requirements go way beyond the points you listed. Apart from that, these points are merely necessary, but not sufficient for getting titles published. In a closed ecosystem you hand over control of your ability to publish to someone else, and that is fundamental. The terms that really matter in the MS developer agreement are: > i. App Availability. Microsoft has no obligation to make any app available that you submit, even if that app is Certified and > j. Updates. Microsoft may update this agreement at any time in its sole discretion That leaves open any kind of anticompetitive reason MS may come up with in the future to manipulate the store.
- powertower 14y agoHere are some more random picks... > 3.9 All app logic must originate from, and reside in, your app package > 4.1.2 Your app must obtain opt-in or equivalent consent to share personal information Did you even read any of those terms? They are ALL of the same nature. > You've listed exactly 3 points from a multipage document with dozens of requirements as if they summarize the whole document. This is not true - the requirements go way beyond the points you listed. Now you're just making things up. > That leaves open any kind of anticompetitive reason MS may come up with in the future to manipulate the store. Sure, whatever you say.
- smartician 14y agoIs this new Windows "app store" the only way one can install software in the future, or is it just one additional way to deploy applications, which is more streamlined? If it's the latter, then I would think a "certification" process makes sense. It's not about closing down a platform, it's about establishing a more user friendly installation experience.
- corporalagumbo 14y agoIt's the latter. For now it seems like Microsoft is doing what Apple has never considered - building a streamlined frontend interface with a certified app store so casual users can safely and easily access a wide range of software, and maintaining a fully tinker-able backend and not closing off other software distribution channels for expert users. Unless this is all a prelude to their master plan to pull an iOS in W9, it seems like a highly prudent move. Microsoft is a company, and needs to remain competitive against Apple, and they best achieve this by simplifying the front-end. But they don't seem to be forgetting their expert-user roots. The only question for me now is how moddable the Metro interface will be. I think it would be smart if Microsoft left it relatively open for expert users to experiment with.
- ameen 14y agoI would like to point out that it isn't actually the latter. If your app is a "Metro-Style Windows 8 app", then you can't sell it on your own, you have to put it up on the Windows Store or make a desktop application if you want to sell it on your own. Metro apps will not be available from elsewhere.
- zevyoura 14y ago> It's the latter. For now it seems like Microsoft is doing what Apple has never considered - building a streamlined frontend interface with a certified app store so casual users can safely and easily access a wide range of software, and maintaining a fully tinker-able backend and not closing off other software distribution channels for expert users. Isn't that exactly what Apple has done on OS X with the Mac App Store?
- 14y ago
- Legion 14y agoThere's a reason Minecraft was created on the PC and ported to the Xbox, and not the other way around. The issue here isn't "death to all closed systems", but rather taking one of the few open ones left and making steps towards closing it.
- chuppo 14y agoSecureBoot, UEFI and such, the PC is forced to stop being a general purpose computing device, and more like an xbox, ps3 or smartphone - a computing device where the manufacturer and/or os-maker controls what can and will run on the device. Its about your freedom. Freedom to run whatever computations you please on general purpose computers that you own. With SecureBoot and win8 so is not the case.
- stephengillie 14y agoThe article lists many tech celebrities whose dire predictions have made other articles. I'm still waiting to see the technical problems each has with Win8.
- dpark 14y agoWait, so he's refusing to put Minecraft in the Windows Store because it's "less open" than Windows 7? Didn't his company rewrite Minecraft so that he could sell it on iOS?
- zmmmmm 14y agoHe's not refusing to put on the store. He's refusing to go through a charade of "certification" to assist MS to put it on the store - essentially to assist them in closing down their open platform by getting all the popular titles into the closed ecosystem. If MS will open up the store put it there without certification then I suspect he's fine with it. While it would certainly have been more consistent to withhold the iOS port, there was no equally good open alternative on that platform, so it would have been a fairly futile gesture. On Win8, having independent games continue to thrive and ignore the Metro store will make a tangible difference to Microsoft's ability to shut down legacy apps in the future. So I can sympathise with why he would treat these situations differently.
- recoiledsnake 14y agoI find your argument specious at best. If we're talking the Metro store, Windows RT tablet users(eg. the Surface RT users) will be unable to run the game simply because they're ARM machines like the iPad on which the game runs on. It's funny that he has no problem going through the certification for the "Post-PC" iOS app store which is supposedly killing the PC and going to sell more than PCs in the near future. But suddenly he has a problem with Windows 8 and Windows RT. There is a disconnect here. > If MS will open up the store put it there without certification then I suspect he's fine with it. Sorry, but is this a joke? Every malware, spyware, virus, grayware, toolbar, Bonzi Buddy clones will end up in the store. Look at what Steam had to do with Greenlight. http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-08-31-valve-bans-steam-users-creating-fake-greenlight-projects http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-08-31-valve-bans-stea... http://www.shacknews.com/article/75603/steam-greenlight-adds-100-submission-fee http://www.shacknews.com/article/75603/steam-greenlight-adds...
- saulrh 14y ago
- thetabyte 14y agoWhat people here aren't getting with the references to XBox and iOS is that Notch's objections aren't to closed platforms. He objects to PCs as closed platforms. Minecraft was originally an indie game developed for PCs due to their open ecosystem. It was only able to reach closed markets like iOS and XBox because of its success as a side project on an open platform. Notch strongly believes that the computer should stay a bastion of openness in order to sustain a indie game community--indeed, the majority of my own games I play today are small, independent games that provide a unique experience that I would hate to lose due to higher barriers to entry.
- kenjackson 14y agoHow would the existence of Windows 8 stopped the creation of Minecraft? He still could have developed with it (there's the desktop). He could have deployed his app, had it certified, etc... There doesn't seem to be anything that openness would have provided him. Open platforms are good for a few classes of devs: 1) Devs at competing companies. Closed platforms make it easier for one company to shut out a competitor. 2) Malware creators. 3) HW tinkerers. This is probably the class I have the most empathy for. With that said Win8 has a complete desktop mode fully available for tinkering.
- Retric 14y agoThere is no way to do a truly large scale beta on iOS. Your options are to release it to a select group, or go though the review process are release to everyone. That's not to say all Closed platforms would have caused issues with Mincraft just some of them.
- thetabyte 14y ago"had it certified" Bam. I have no idea quite how intensive the review process is (I'm no Windows programmer, so the requirements don't mean much to me) but any additional barrier is something that holds back the finnicky and decentralized indie crowd. Not only will it present another technical barrier that they will have no interest in surpassing, but there will likely be a cultural and psychological backlash of having to certify their version 0 project with Microsoft. Not to mention how certification requirements would impact beta releases and feedback.
- hetman 14y agoYes, I can see how making an application more consistent and predictable would be terrible for the end users.
- corporalagumbo 14y agoYeah, and I bet they're gunna really loathe buying certified apps from a unified marketplace with extremely streamlined install and uninstall processes.
- kenjackson 14y agoWith all due respect, I'm going to Windows 8. I'd like Minecraft to be there, but if it's not, I'm sure some other indie developer will put together a compelling game on the platform.
- genbattle 14y agoI think he's not so much against having Minecraft run on Windows 8 at all (i'm sure if Java support it, it'll run), I think he's just more averse to serving it via Microsoft's store. I think Notch is overreacting in this case because he's already supported Microsoft's platform monopoly with Minecraft on the Xbox 360 (which is completely closed), so this stance seems kind of contrary. Possibly there's some sort of clause in Microsoft's contracts that says an Application on the Windows Store can't be sold outside the store or something which he's actually getting up in arms about. I'm not particularly crazy about Windows 8 either, but Notch probably needs to be a little more specific with his protests (then again, it is just a twitter post).
- trafficlight 14y agoI can't remember where I read it, but he has the same attitude about Steam. Notch feels that he has a large enough userbase that Steam (or Windows 8 App store) doesn't offer enough advantages over Mojang's homegrown distribution system.
- jeffool 14y agoLikely his Twitter. I think he's said as much.
- trafficlight 14y agoI can't edit now, but here's where I saw it. http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/07/25/notch-on-why-minecraft-still-isnt-on-steam/ http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/07/25/notch-on-why-minecraft-sti...
- thebigshane 14y agoI think it was this interview (it was on HN a while back): http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/09/15/future-talk-notch-on-steam-windows-8-whats-next/ http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/09/15/future-talk-notch...
- recoiledsnake 14y agoWhat is Windows 8 "certification" that he's complaining about? Is it about adding it to the Windows Store distributed by Microsoft? In that case, doesn't it need to rebuilt with WinRT/DirectX? Or to add it as a link to the developer's website like desktop apps can have in the Store? The requirements are here: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/hh749939.aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/hh74... Can't see anything really bad there, if anything those rules finally herd the Windows application cats.
- stinos 14y agoexactly. If those really are the requirements it is all about, there's not that much to complain about as most of them are rather 'good practice'. And if you do not follow them your application cannot be in the store? Well boohoo.
- throwaway64 14y agonot everyone shares your, or apples ideas, about what constitutes a "good practice"
- Goronmon 14y ago>It must be code and feature complete At what point in the timeline of Minecraft did it meet this criteria, because when I started playing, this wasn't true, and yet he was still making sales and people were still enjoying the game. And what happens when Microsoft starts "enhancing" the rules?
- dmansen 14y agoTo all you people saying that this is just "best practices" requirements, etc: do you not realize this is MICROSOFT? The evil empire? He's taking a stand! A completely meaningless stand, but really, this is important!
- jebblue 14y agoWell stated, perhaps a quick review will help: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=885975 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=885975
- aristidb 14y agoWhy the hostility towards Notch? Minecraft will keep working on Windows 8 (just not in the Store), nothing to fear, move on.[1] It's equally unreasonable to love Microsoft as it is to hate it. [1] Well, it probably won't work on Windows RT because only Windows Store things work there, but then that would likely require a total rewrite of the Java&OpenGL game to C++&DirectX (or another Microsoft-approved solution) anyways, and Minecraft (as opposed to Minecraft Pocket Edition[2]) is not suitable for tablet touch control anyways. [2] Which is developed by another firm.
- watty 14y agoI think any hostility you see is due to his comment of "I'd rather have minecraft not run on win 8 at all than to play along.". He'd never be dumb enough to do this so why say it, and why stir the pot with everyone who thinks Minecraft really really might not run on Windows 8?
- BCM43 14y agoWhy would he never be dumb enough to do this? It seems that he does not see it as a moral decision, and I'm guessing he's betting that windows 8 adoption will never be that large.
- jack57 14y agoDISCLAIMER: I use Windows 8 as my main operating system. The notion that normal desktop applications will not run on Windows 8 is incredible. I could download Minecraft right now, and it would run without a hitch. People need to use Windows 8 and realize that it is an iteration of Windows 7. It feels like Windows 7 with an interesting tablet overlay that I never use. P.S. Every single game I own on Steam works
- ameen 14y agoI have it on dual boot. Normal desktop applications will work on Windows 8, but if I want to make a Metro version of that app, it has to go through the MS certification and can only be sold on the Windows store. Metro is where major Win 8 innovations are (AppBar, Charms, App Dashboard, App Lifecycle, etc.)
- ameen 14y agoI'd been wanting to build Windows apps and had been working on one for the past 6 months. I happened to be invited to a MS event for Windows 8 and as excited as I was to be there, I was disappointed to learning that "Metro-style" apps can't be published elsewhere, it has to be from the Windows Store(sic), and with MS handling sales, updates, etc. What then, is the benefit of an entirely new OS, with a new feature - Metro(the AppBar, charms, dashboard, etc), if you're going to force developers to use your own AppStore? I wouldn't mind giving a cut of my profits to MS, but I wouldn't want to be on their mercy for updates, sales, etc. And if anyone didn't notice, this is the desktop PC we're talking about. I'm not interested in Tablets or other stuff for which my application is clearly not aimed at(neither designed for). I think Microsoft is aiming to get more applications for its Tablet devices, and in doing so it'll destroy the only remaining MS product that has a huge market share - the desktop PC. Nokia was once at the same enviable position where MS was, and we all know how that ended. Viva la Linux!
- finnw 14y agoMore likely they expect to get a large market share for free, from name recognition alone. Try convincing a 50-year-old who has owned nothing but Windows PCs for 25 years that a new Windows 8 (or 9) PC is not what they need.
- kleiba 14y agoI so wish Notch would stream another coding session to twitch.tv again.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI don't know what qualifies as a "PC" any more these days. I will say that I don't see much future in Windows as the free for all it once was. We can argue the pros and cons of that until the cows come home, my guess is that this is just an inevitable reaction to this horrible Windows software experience of today. Just about every Windows app I've tried to install in the last couple of years has also tried to fool me into installing some bundled 3rd party crapware. If you want an open platform , use one that is open by design in other words a Linux distribution.
- nivla 14y ago>Just about every Windows app I've tried to install in the last couple of years has also tried to fool me into installing some bundled 3rd party crapware. If you want an open platform , use one that is open by design in other words a Linux distribution. and yet the latest Ubuntu comes with Amazon Shopping bundled. I think its becoming a trend to monetize on everything, both open and closed. No necessarily a bad thing but everything seem to merge that way. Think the future might redefine the words "open" and "free".
- djhworld 14y agoThere are numerous distributions of Linux out there, if you don't like the advertising in Ubuntu, there's nothing stopping you from uninstalling the advertising features or moving to a different distribution That's the whole point of Linux.
- nivla 14y agoThe point was not about avoiding or getting rid of the "bloat/crapware". The poster above me claimed that you won't find "bloat/crapware" in an open-source os and I was just pointing out that with Ubuntu's recent changes, it is not the case anymore.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThat wasn't exactly my point. My point was that the bloatware/crapware problem in Windows has gotten so out of hand that MS had to do something and that something was to start tightening up who can ship software for the platform. Of course there is nothing stopping people shipping crapware for Ubuntu or any Linux distro. The advantage of open source OSs is that you will always have a choice about how much "nannying" you want from the OS.
- sturd 14y agoSurely, having Micro$oft muscle in on 30% (or whatever they charge) of all Windows based Minecraft sales is enough to complain about.
- Zenst 14y agoOne interface to piss them all off - Metro. Reason I say that is if you take Metro away what are the issues. I know anybody who knows how to use a mouse is pretty much of the WTF metro GTFO and that is understandable, but removing that aspect there is nothing realy upsetting that wasn't there before hand. Yes I know developing on microsoft API's (exspecialy anything associated with IE) has been a complete nightmare for many in the past including myself with many a fix being lamented as fixed in the next release only to find the next release entails you having to change other aspects as they are nolonger supported. Thats true with anything were you touch a API outside your control, at least potentualy in one way or another. If anything by not officialy certifying minecraft for win8 is doing no harm at all for microsoft as it probably runs fine as is and with the processing power nowadays HTML5 becomes more and more appealing to many as apposed to going native. Is he right to make a stand, yes, it is his right and has to be respected, especialy as he is able to. But personaly the more I look into win8 and metro aside I'm liking it for what it is, there again I'm the sick puppy who preferes vista over win7 and i'm sure no metro fan, but having explorer or an alternative desktop option is not going to be too hard. Also worth noting that it will be hard to garner true win8 sales once its released as Microsoft have done alot of write off's last quarter (pulling some early like write off of the cost of pressing windows 8 and other gems) so the win8 release quarter can only look better however it does. This with the cheap upgrade and less messing with versions (mini, lite, almost, profesional and ultra or whatever they were). So for many it will be a fiscal no brainer, especialy all those XP installs becoming less supported (unless your a new intel chipset that support XP over Vista, bless). Maybe Microsft will install a desktop chosser akin to the browser selection, at least that would plicate alot if they had a clear cut choice. But anything that runs on a closed source OS in any form is gong to be limited, its if those limitations actualy matter that to what your doing is what realy counts and whilst I applaud Notch's stand I do wonder if later on he find some toys missing that needn't of fallen. Especialy when the certification process for a xbox is alot more stringant than any flavour of desktop OS.
- mariusmg 14y agoThe friggin Windows Store is optional. Nobody is forcing you to use it if you don't want to. The "platform" is just as open as it was before.
- RobAley 14y agoAh, thats good. If his users want to use the default Metro platform to launch and play the game, then they can right?. Oh wait...
- mariusmg 14y agoYes, you actually can. A start screen tile in Windows 8 can launch a both Metro and desktop apps.
- RobAley 14y agoWhen we looked earlier in the year, the only way to get non-signed desktop apps to run from metro was to either have a signed metro app call them or create a fudgy work-around by creating a dummy file/protocol type, assigning your desktop app as the default handler for that dummy type, and adding a file of the dummy type to metro. They also stated in january, with regards to the first solution, "we're moving away from allowing an application to start any other application". Not exactly free and open (or ideal), and not one for most users to do themselves. Has this changed since then?
- brazzy 14y agoThe problem is: what if it becomes non-optional in the future? That would be very much in Microsoft's interest, and they have a myriad ways to help it become reality without outright making it mandatory and risking another antitrust case.
- lhnz 14y agoI am behind Notch on this. A strategic move for Microsoft might be: (1) Build an eco-system around their app store by providing benefits to users through it (some natural and others artificial). (2) Impose an increasing level of control over what developers on their system can do. And then once this power-relationship is established, you do this to maximize profit: (3) Lock out non app-store members from developing. (4) Take rightful dictatorial control over the developers in their market. What they can sell, how they promote themselves, what prices they can sell at, whether the money goes directly to them, etc. (5) Ensure the stable dominance of the big app development studios by negotiating them preferential agreements. Control over the means of distribution is power. This is the natural progression of people optimising for wealth.
- iy56 14y agoThat's a horrible strategic move for microsoft. Do you have any idea how many shitty homegrown apps their huge business customers use?
- lhnz 14y agoActually the existence of shitty business apps is one of my points. They improve the quality of those 'shitty' homegrown apps for their huge business customers (the cheese is that if you want to be seen in Metro you have to play ball) and then over time they get a cut of sales of all of these apps. There is an economic impetus for creating a walled garden. Businesses aren't investing money here just for intrinsic benefits. Owning the market is powerful as you can control how other people get their money.
- iy56 14y agoWhy would a company want all its employees to have to buy their outlook calendar-based time logger doohickey? They just distribute it on new hires' computers and be done with it. And that's not even getting into the ones that actually have proprietary data/trade secrets. Forcing all windows 8 programs to go through a Microsoft-curated app store is just not going to happen unless it's for some very limited "starter edition".
- mariusmg 14y agoHypocrisy. My least favorite sin.....
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Ensorceled 14y agoOkay, here's the real problem that Notch is worried about. Every game and app that has "Microsoft Certified Safe(TM)" is one more reason the average user will be reluctant to run apps or games that are not "Microsoft Certified Safe(TM)". They are worried that the next batch of indie games will, instead of running, pop up a window "Microsoft has not certified this app as safe. You can be infected with viruses, or key loggers can steal your bank accounts. Do you still want to run this uncertified application?" It's not about the big assed buttons.
- talmand 14y agoI totally agree. In the PC gaming community, I'm in that group by the way, that sort of thing will be met with anger and derision because it's already a common thought that Microsoft does nothing but crap on the PC gaming community. Look into Games for Windows Live, or whatever that call that crap now, to see what I mean. Microsoft's presence in the PC gaming space is a joke and they have a long, hard road to go down to get past that. Labeling games that have yet to be certified, at a cost I'm sure, as unsafe and vectors for malware installations will do nothing to alleviate that attitude. Notch is right, anything that Microsoft does relating to PC games is of concern because it appears they go out of their way to ruin the experience to get you to switch to the "superior gaming experience" of the 360. Where of course they control everything and make money off of other people's work.
- SparrowOS 14y agoGod says... one draweth near for to deliver her husband out of the hand of him that smiteth him, and putteth forth her hand, and taketh him by the secrets: 25:12 Then thou shalt cut off her hand, thine eye shall not pity her. 25:13 Thou shalt not have in thy bag divers weights, a great and a small. 25:14 Thou shalt not have in thine house divers measures, a great and a small. 25:15 But thou shalt have a perfect and just weight, a perfect and just measure shalt thou have: that thy days may be lengthened in the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee. 25:16 For all that do such things, and all that do unrighteously, are an abomination unto the LORD thy God. ---- In addition to a general statement on fairness, this might be about different versions, perhaps for platforms? I'm not at all worried -- God is just.