7 ms·
Not really - there's a really simple solution for hiring more women without dropping the bar for them. Make your company the most desirable place for anyone to
by nostrademons 14y ago
Not really - there's a really simple solution for hiring more women without dropping the bar for them. Make your company the most desirable place for anyone to work, so that you have vastly more applicants than positions, and then you can pick whoever you want as the incoming cohort. Math:
Say that your goal is to hire from the top 1% of the field, and the top 1% is indistinguishable from each other. There are 1 million people in the field, and you will be hiring 1,000 this year. Also say that women make up 10% of the field. In this scenario, there are 10,000 people that you would be happy to work for you, and 1,000 of them are women.
If only 10% of prospective employees would even consider working for you (which is the case for many startups, and probably for present-day Microsoft), then you're trying to fill a class of 1000 from a universe of 1,000 candidates, and only 100 of the women both apply and meet your hiring threshold. The best you can do is 10% female interns.
If, however, everyone in the field wants to work for your company, you have a universe of 10,000 candidates, 1,000 are women, and you're trying to fill a class of 1,000. You can have a female proportion anywhere from 0-100% with no loss of quality.
- codex 14y agoThe strategy you describe drops the bar for all employees in order to achieve a gender target. This is not how companies operate, for the most part. If a company wants to hire 1,000 people and 10,000 applicants are in the top 1%, they will move the bar up to hire the top 0.1% instead. Given a normal distirbution of applicants, there is a huge difference in talent (10x?) between top 1% and top 0.1%. The bar always automatically adjusts higher; otherwise, a competitor will hire the fraction of the 0.1% that you've passed over. Now the competitor has a 1,000 workers, and you have 1,000 workers, but the competitors are 10x more talented for the same pay (most of the 0.1% didn't get an offer from you, so there's no bidding war for their talents). Actually, if a company spends more money recruiting each equivalent female employee than male employee, they do effectively drop their total hiring bar if spending more money lets the company climb the bell curve, because it's effectively a reduction in spending efficency, but that effect is small, and skill parity is still achieved.
- nostrademons 14y agoYou're assuming you can continuously & linearly rank every single applicant. The labor market doesn't work that way. Typically, it's organized into tiers - you have your superstars, and then you have a pool of developers that are good enough, and then you have a bunch of clueless n00bs. Within a tier, it's rare to find significant, measurable performance differences. The studies showed a 10x difference in productivity between the best teams and the worst teams - that does not mean it applies to individuals, or that it means the best developer is 2x as good as the second best developer, at least on an industry-wide level. (How would you stack-rank John Resig against Rob Pike? The two of them against Zed Shaw? The three of them against Guido van Rossum? Note also that even if you can stack rank their accomplishments, that won't necessarily reflect in their day-to-day performance. Guido van Rossum wrote Python, but he also wrote a bunch of AppEngine code that isn't all that much beloved.)
- codex 14y agoEven if the population is divided into discrete tiers, the process is still rife with unfairness no matter how you dice it. If you have 1,000 slots, 10,000 candidates in your tier, and 1,000 of them are women, you can hire any ratio of women to men that you like and all will be equally talented. Great, right? It's great for those that are hired; not so much for everyone else. Say you make the gender ratio 50%. You hire 500 women and 500 men from the top tier. Every first-class company like Google or Facebook adopts this strategy. This means that the odds of being hired at a first-class company is 50% for women in the top tier, and only 5% for men in the top tier. For every interview a woman does, a man must do ten. Eventually all the slots in all first-class companies are filled up, leaving some top-tier men working for second class companies--but no top tier women are working for second class companies.
- nostrademons 14y agoRight, but you're going to get this unfairness no matter what criteria you use, gender or otherwise. Say you leave the gender ratio unspecified and instead decide based upon the interviewer's gut feeling. Then you'll bias the hiring process toward schmoozers with good social skills. Or you decide based on which college the applicant went to. Then you bias it towards people who were willing to shell out for a prestigious piece of paper. Or you decide based on whoever responds to your offer first. Then you bias it against people who have lives and better things to do with their time than refreshing their e-mail waiting for a callback. Really, the only solution is to acknowledge that life's not fair, and people sometimes get things for completely arbitrary reasons. Which is really hard for a lot of people to do - it was hard for me - but you end up being a lot more successful when you don't think too hard about all the folks who get undeserved job offers and promotions and think more about how you can tilt the odds toward being one of the lucky ones instead.
- bradleyjg 14y agoIf you have way more indistinguishable applicants than positions you are paying too much.
- nostrademons 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficiency_wage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficiency_wage
- azakai 14y ago> Say that your goal is to hire from the top 1% of the field, and the top 1% is indistinguishable from each other. That's not how the world is.
- nostrademons 14y agoIt largely is in an employment situation. There are a number of people that are all well-qualified for the job, and any one of them can do it as well as any other. It's not necessarily true when you compare between organizations, where different groups may make subtly different decisions with wildly different outcomes (although even then, a lot of the difference comes from different circumstances and not innate talent of the people involved). But in an organization, the need for teamwork and to "row in a common direction" tends to flatten out individual differences, and there're generally two possible classes: "valued contributor" and "holding back the group". (This is also why large organizations like Google tweak their hiring processes to avoid false positives more than false negatives. One bad hire forces the team down to his level, as they always have to stop and explain things to him, or he'll block them from implementing a cleverer solution that he wouldn't understand. One good hire, however, very rarely raises the level of the team - he needs a lot of patience and very good empathetic & people skills to do so.)
- azakai 14y ago> It largely is in an employment situation. There are a number of people that are all well-qualified for the job, and any one of them can do it as well as any other. No, that is simply not true. There might be a cutoff over which everyone is "reasonably competent", and perform "acceptably", but there are still huge differences between people. You immediately say "no" to people that don't reach the "acceptable" bar. But above that, you have hiring quotas, and you try to maximize the value of the people you hire. Hiring someone just above the bar now means you get one less hire later. Someone much better might show up, and often does. And on the other hand if the current candidate is much, much above the bar - you fight to get that person hired, you work on convincing your peers in the hiring process. Because they are worth it. Such people have a much higher chance to be hired. I've been on both sides of the hiring process many times and worked for many years in tech. To say that above some skill level everyone is the same, "can do it as well as any other" - not in all of my experience.