3 ms·
> Obama was hated by San Franciscan progressives because Because San Francisco progressivism doesn’t win on a national stage.
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Obama was hated by San Franciscan progressives because
Because San Francisco progressivism doesn’t win on a national stage.
- Eisenstein 1y agoTimes are changing. The pendulum swing back from MAGA is going to be interesting.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Times are changing. The pendulum swing back from MAGA is going to be interesting The pendelum swings in multiple dimensions. MAGA went mainstream in a way the Tea Party and conservativism did not by abandoning policy purity in favour of, first, messaging, and later, idolatry. The preserved component between MAGA's messaging and Mamdani's rise is populism and, to a lesser degree, divisive politics. Where MAGA failed and Mamdani may deliver is in pragmatism (and not being corrupt). There is an opportunity to unify "abundance" policies with inclusive progressivism or villanisation of wealth. (I'm not convinced you can do both. If you want to pursue growth and cost of living, you need to turn the capital spigots. Accumulated capital facilitates that. If you want to tackle inequality and billionaires, you'll need to temporarily destabilise those capital structures. You'll also, presumably, be increasing the lower and middle classes' purchasing power, which limits how much public spending you can do without spiking inflation.) San Francisco progressives can influence national politics. But anyone insisting on copy-paste purism is a godsend to MAGA.
- mamonster 1y agoMain reason why MAGA will fail even harder is that you now see that there is basically nothing holding this movement together apart from Trump. Next step in MAGA is the open inheritance war between the original 2016 spirit and the 2024 donor class.
- ithkuil 1y agoHopefully we don't add too much energy to the pendulum because eventually it will swing back again
- AbstractH24 1y ago> Because San Francisco progressivism doesn’t win on a national stage. If the message that Democrats take from this is NY progressivism wins on a national stage, we'll certainly lose the next presidential election, and maybe even fail to gain a majority in either the House or Senate during the midterms. That's my biggest fear.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> That's my biggest fear Mamdani is a disciplined New York progressive. He’s left of the median voter. But the Mamdani that won the D primary was also left of the median NYC voter. One can take a shallow policy lesson from this election. Or a deeper political lesson in the value of pragmatism and respect for the voter (versus the holier than thou crap that has polluted the far left).
- AbstractH24 1y ago> Mamdani is a disciplined New York progressive. He’s left of the median voter. But the Mamdani that won the D primary was also left of the median NYC voter. I hope you are right, that he is more like Obama than Trump. Time will tell. Personally, I haven't seen any evidence to support that hypothesis. If you have, I'd love to feel more assured you are right so please share.
- AbstractH24 1y ago>Mamdani is a disciplined New York progressive. Also, who are these current or former elected officials that fit the description "disciplined New York progressive" you refer to? I'm truly not sure.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> who are these current or former elected officials that fit the description "disciplined New York progressive" you refer to? The guy named in the comment.
- 1y ago