5 ms·
> At one time, the philosophy was that the country was more secure when we could all be assured that the privacy of our communications was intact. That's never
by dpark 14y ago
> At one time, the philosophy was that the country was more secure when we could all be assured that the privacy of our communications was intact.
That's never really been the view of the U.S. government. It's always been the view that you should be able to have communications with your neighbor that are secure from everyone except the US government, who obviously need to snoop in order to protect us all.
The security agencies and the police agencies have always pushed for more comprehensive and more invasive surveillance. We've had wiretapping for as long as we've had wires to tap. We crippled Internet security for years. I remember the days of separate US and international Netscape releases, due to crypto export restrictions. It wasn't until 2000 that the restrictions were truly relaxed.
- pgeorgi 14y agoUS and international Netscape releases (as well as Windows and various other tools) rather indicate that the US govt was interested in secure communication for US citizens and corporations, while being able to snoop on the rest of the world. If you need an example, pick the Clipper chip - and even that doesn't _quite_ work out, given how publically that proposal was shot down.
- nnnnnnnn 14y agoActually it is a reflection of the law. The US government had the authority to prohibit export of crypto (at the time), but did not have the authority to limit it domestically. If they had been given that authority things may have been different.
- CWuestefeld 14y agoThat's kind of circular. If the government has the authority to create a law to do X, then the government has the authority to do X, full stop.
- dfc 14y agoI always thought that the clipper chip died in the court of public opinion and not in a court of law. However, I do not understand your interpretation of circular reasoning. Lets look at the case where X is regulate the sale of switchblades. The federal government has the authority to regulate the sale (commerce) of switchblade knives between states, the federal government does not have the authority to regulate the sale of a switchblade within a state.
- anamax 14y ago> The federal government has the authority to regulate the sale (commerce) of switchblade knives between states, the federal government does not have the authority to regulate the sale of a switchblade within a state. Let's look at the case of guns. Do you really think that Montana could say "you can sell Montana-made machineguns in Montan without satisfying federal law"? (The feds don't much care about switchblades. They care about guns.) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn . In that case, the feds got to regulate even though the wheat in question wasn't sold and never left the farm.
- dfc 14y agoWell the feds did care about switchblades, that is why they passed a law banning the interstate sale of switchblades, "the Switchblade Knife Act, (Pub.L. 85-623, 72 Stat. 562, enacted on August 12, 1958, and codified in 15 U.S.C. §§ 1241–1245), prohibits the manufacture, importation, distribution, transportation, and sale of switchblade knives in commercial transactions substantially affecting interstate commerce[56] between any state."[1] Evidence for a continued interest in switchblades can be found in the recent exemption carved out for assisted opening knives in 5 USC § 1244.[2] (I think the exemptions in 1244 were passed within the last 5 years as part of a Homeland Security appropriations bill, but I'm fuzzy on the exact date.) Wickard was 70 years ago, interstate commerce doctrine has evolved a lot in the intervening years. In fact I'm a little surprised that you used it as an example. It has been a while since ConLaw I, but I think Wickard is often used as an example of the height of the broad interpretation of the commerce clause. Are you arguing that there is no limit on the power of the the commerce clause? Or that Wickard is the controlling case? Lopez is one of many cases since Wickard where the Supremes walked back such a broad interpretation of the commerce clause. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchblade#Federal_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchblade#Federal_law [2] http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1244 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1244
- dpark 14y agoI think it's rather an example of how the Judicial branch keeps the other branches in check. If the NSA had its way, they'd be able to listen in on every conversation you ever have, track every site you visit, record every communication you ever make. They would do the same for everyone internationally as well. The difference is that we have the Supreme Court protecting US citizens to some extent, so the NSA cannot legally wiretap your phone just for kicks, but the Supreme Court doesn't extend the same protection to citizens of other countries.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoAnd you believe the NSA when you can't see the warrants, know who issued them, what they contain, etc.? How would we know they weren't tapping domestic communication? You wouldn't. Any whistleblowers would be roughed-up or locked-up... much like Thomas Drake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Andrews_Drake#2007_FBI_raids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Andrews_Drake#2007_FBI_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSA_warrantless_surveillance_controversy#Trailblazer_and_whistleblowing_prosecution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSA_warrantless_surveillance_c...
- dpark 14y agoI said that the judicial branch keeps the other branches is check. I didn't say that are completely effective or that their checks are sufficient. And I certainly didn't say that the NSA wasn't engaging in any domestic wiretapping.
- jacobrobbins 14y agoYes, I think the key word in that sentence is "legally". The following article describes the situation re: warrantless monitoring of u.s. citizens by the NSA: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/05/23/110523fa_fact_mayer?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/05/23/110523fa_fact_... The thing is that they can not bring the result of this warrantless wiretapping into court. But they probably don't want to. From what I've seen the FBI is a lot more vocal in complaining about the impact of encryption because their mandate involves bringing cases to court so they want a formalized, legitimate way of breaking encryption when they have warrants. They would also love to have the dragnet that the NSA has to know who to watch, and I don't know to what extent they do, but the bigger difference that I see is that the NSA is not interested in launching court battles (any more) whereas that is the primary endgame for the FBI. The problem of course is that an encryption system which can be broken in a formalized way is open to the possibility of being broken by the wrong people. You can't have your cake and eat it too by having strong encryption that can be broken by the "right" people because there is no way to theoretically describe who the "right" people are. The encryption has to work the same for everyone. Like all big issues in society there are competing rights; the need for law enforcement bumps up against the freedom of the individual. I believe that we are comfortable enough pushing this balance more heavily towards the freedom of the individual in America that a policy of embracing strong encryption is in the best interests of everyone, but I am aware that I don't have as much knowledge about this issue as some others.
- napillo 14y agoWell, that was the philosophy that they were promoting. I know for a fact that your re-stating of it seems to be more accurate. My father was doing business in the late 80's, early 90's with Russia, and he was transferring large files across a modem link. The CIA contacted him and asked him not to encrypt his files, so they could see what was going on.