5 ms·
I don't think that's British vs American, that's more proper grammar vs improper grammar. You wouldn't hear anyone of any stature seriously trying to suggest th
by freehunter 14y ago
I don't think that's British vs American, that's more proper grammar vs improper grammar. You wouldn't hear anyone of any stature seriously trying to suggest that "could care less" is American English. My opinion is that it's one of those things people hear spoken more than they see written and the tendency to say "could'n care less" (without the hard stop on the 't'). Kind of like something I see on HN quite often, "kind've".
- diazamet 14y agoGranted, it's not necessarily a UK vs US -ism but I come across it most often on US websites.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoAs someone resident in the UK, I am quite sure that it is in fact a UK vs US-ism. I wouldn't know if everyone in the US uses the phrase "I could care less" but I am sure that no-one over here does. Which makes it an American turn of phrase since it is found no-where else.
- 5teev 14y agoIf you think of "I could care less" as sarcasm, it makes more sense, i.e., the speaker couldn't really care less. (If I recall, this was the typical usage when I first started hearing this phrase decades ago.)
- sarabob 14y agoAIUI the USA version is "I could care less, if I really tried hard."
- dpark 14y agoI agree this is just a question of improper grammar. However , it's fast becoming an Americanism. I think it's probably more common without the "n't" (or even just "n'") at this point. > Kind of like something I see on HN quite often, "kind've". Ew
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoWhat do you mean by "stature"? I'm convinced that British people never say "I could care less" when they mean that they don't care, but that some American people do. British people say instead "I couldn't care less", which is a more accurate statement. How does that differ from "I could care less" being a characteristically American turn of phrase?
- dpark 14y agoWhat he means is that even Americans would identify this an improper grammar. I'm not sure if that's accurate or not, though. I daresay that the more grammatically-inclined among us would call it wrong, but the typical American likely would not. (See also: literally, used as a general intensifier)
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> identify this an improper grammar. And yet those who study living languages for a living linguists of stature, if you will) insist that what they do is descriptive, not prescriptive. http://www.ling.upenn.edu/courses/ling001/prescription.html http://www.ling.upenn.edu/courses/ling001/prescription.html i.e. if a large group of people say it in a particular way, they are doing what they do, not doing something else incorrectly.
- dpark 14y agoWell, they can claim whatever they want. :) At the end of the day, calling something "right" or "wrong" comes down to a subjective call, though. If 99% of people use some construction, then even the most prescriptive of linguists will probably consider it correct. But what about 40%? 20%? Even for a descriptive linguist, the question of "do people say X" is fuzzy. Some people say "X" for almost any "X". Some people say "aks" instead of "ask", but the vast majority of people would agree that's wrong.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> At the end of the day, calling something "right" or "wrong" comes down to a subjective call But the idea is to not make that call at all. That would be prescriptive. > Some people say "aks" instead of "ask", but the vast majority of people would agree that's wrong. I'm told that's a regional variation. In other words, in some places, people speak like that. That's descriptive. so is "most people speak like that in region A and don't have a problem with it, and most don't in regions B,C,D,E".
- nollidge 14y agoIt's got nothing to do with grammar. "I could care less" is a perfectly grammatical sentence - it follows all the rules of English sentence construction. Similarly, "colorless green ideas sleep furiously" is also perfectly grammatical, it just doesn't make any semantic sense.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoBut "I could care less" is a perfectly grammatical sentence, which has a semantic meaning, which, as David Mitchell explains at comic length, is the opposite of what the speaker means to say. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=om7O0MFkmpw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=om7O0MFkmpw
- nollidge 14y agoRight. How's that different from what I said?
- dpark 14y agoAnd so we move from discussing pedantic points of language to discussing tangential points that are even more pedantic. :)
- freehunter 14y agoThus is the nature of a living language. Everyone has their own interpretation of how the language should be used, and it's up to everyone to find common ground in order to be understood. Debates, even inconsequential debates, are an integral part of understanding the words we assign arbitrary meaning to.
- nollidge 14y agoIf we're going to talk about language, then it's far from pedantic to insist on using it properly while doing so.
- dpark 14y ago