3 ms·
Guideline has an FSA/HSA product which is a walking CMMS and IRS violation. I never bothered escalating my disputes, but simply said, their customer service ag
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Guideline has an FSA/HSA product which is a walking CMMS and IRS violation.
I never bothered escalating my disputes, but simply said, their customer service agents have multiple times admitted in writing to their systems being designed to break federal and state law.
I never thought it was worth pursuing. But Gusto has deep pockets…
- huerne 1y agoWhat specifically is violating policies?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> What specifically is violating policies? Guideline materially and repeatedly breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA. Their definition of when an expense is “incurred” varies materially from case to case and diverged substantially in almost all of them from IRS guidance. Multiple times, a customer service agent said—in writing—the last person I interacted with misrepresented something material that I had subsequently acted on. Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. I am describing my personal experiences. Don’t cite this comment if you decide to pursue these fuckwits.
- ihattendorf 1y agoDo you have a concrete example of when their definition was different from IRS guidance?
- fragmede 1y ago(Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services)
- deadbabe 1y agoCould you elaborate
- lotsofpulp 1y agoNot using Fidelity for HSA and Vanguard/Fidelity for 401k is a sign of bad leadership. I have to assume management is getting paid off some way to subject themselves to an inferior and more expensive custodian.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> have to assume management is getting paid off some way to subject themselves to an inferior and more expensive custodian I’ve done a startup that tried to run ADP for payroll. It was a mess. Lots of startups avoid that problem by using Gusto. And until recently, Gusto integrated better with Guideline than other providers. So that’s what one got. No kickback needed. (Like, constellation of shitty products users are locked into helped make Larry Ellison the world’s richest man.)
- xp84 1y agoADP seems to have a half dozen or more discrete variations on their payroll product, each with their own weird quirks. I’ve experienced some that were perfectly adequate. Some of them being trash also seems plausible.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> some of them being trash also seems plausible I wouldn't call them trash. They're just absurdly powerful tools for moving boatloads of money in infintessimal increments. It's incredibly low-level financial tooling that simply outclasses any organisation without full-time finance and payroll departments.
- peterbonney 1y agoHaving selected a 401k provider for a small (<15 person) company and also for a larger (>100 person) one, I can say that the big names make it prohibitively expensive for small companies to use them. And that expense ultimately comes out of peoples’ retirement funds in the form of fees. They frankly don’t want the business - too much compliance overhead for a small asset pool. Believe me, I would prefer to have my own 401k at Fidelity too. I have no dog in this fight, I just know from experience that setting up a 401k for your company is vastly different from setting up a brokerage account, and the reason a lot of small companies end up with off-the-run vendors is because those are the ones that will take the business.
- micromacrofoot 1y agoGusto has their own, so I can't imagine they'd keep Guideline's?
- cj 1y agoGusto bought Guideline, migrated Guideline customers who also use Gusto directly to Gusto, and everyone leftover from the acquisition is now being served by Guideline under the name Accrue401k. The Accrue401k (formerly Guideline) dashboard is exactly the same, just a different name. And former Guideline customers who use Gusto for payroll now use Gusto 401k. That’s my understanding at least. Gusto basically acquired their mutual customers, seemingly.