5 ms·
I have a strong suspicion this guy is just pontificating without actually having spent any time with people in big content. > Video-content owners aren't looki
by dasil003 14y ago
I have a strong suspicion this guy is just pontificating without actually having spent any time with people in big content.
> Video-content owners aren't looking for a savior and ultimately won't be satisfied with anything less than an open ecosystem accessible by any device.
Big content doesn't give a fuck about open ecosystems. They care about cash money and to a lesser extent they care about control. What they don't want is a Netflix decimating and dominating the market. They may be wary of Apple because of their dominance in iTunes, but if they can grow the market (which their app store model seems like it has a shot) then big content is happy to play ball with them.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThe problem here is that there is a fundamental conflict of interests. Apple wants to sell expensive devices with a big markup which by definition not everybody will be able to afford (TV is popular with low income demographics). Big content doesn't care about "open" in the free software sense but they want to be able to sell content to everyone which is why they still sell DVDs. Since TV is an almost completely passive experience the only way for apple to get ahead would be either turn it into a more "active" experience or get exclusive content which would not be in the content industry's interest.
- dasil003 14y agoI'm not making any argument about whether Apple can be successful or not, merely on the incompetency of the author.
- kabdib 14y agoI've worked in the TV (set top box) business. Oh, god. The cable companies (a) despise their customers, (b) hate to innovate, and (c) their /short term vision/ is on the order of five years. Cable Labs? A firewall against companies that think they can intrude on the space. Want to do something new and whizzy? No problem, just pass some compliance tests . . . which takes months or years. Also: TV is harder than you think. Think "legacy network with some interesting regulation thrown in" (e.g., handling emergency broadcast signals, batshit insane limits on use of bandwidth) and that's for starters. Comcast's back ends are running horrible software stacks, and interoperability with that stuff is really hard; you get to build your own back-end for testing, probably millions of dollars . . . and then you get to integrate with Time Warner's stuff, which is all different, and Rogers, and so on. TV is all about smiling people circling each other with knives. It's full of entrenched players who are happy to screw anyone, including big companies who think they can do end-runs around carefully erected defenses. TV is war.
- dasil003 14y agoAgain... I am not commenting on Apple's ability to succeed in TV.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> Also: TV is harder than you think. Think "legacy network with some interesting regulation thrown in" (e.g., handling emergency broadcast signals, batshit insane limits on use of bandwidth) and that's for starters. Well fuck that. Just do it all over the internet. The ideal system would be one where you don't purchase channel subscriptions, but individual shows. Then you can watch the shows you've purchased as many times as you want, on any devices you own. Of course, you will get "live" broadcasts in the form of being able to play it live when it normally airs for the first time on TV. This is exactly what Apple's vision is, and I hope they find a way to make it happen, but I'm not very optimistic.
- kabdib 14y agoAgain, it's harder than you think. - You have to get content. Those people want to be paid. You are in competition for this. - The cable companies control your air supply -- the bandwidth to your customers -- and unless you make them happy, your customers are screwed if they watch your stuff. Bandwidth caps on the order of 25GB / month are just crazy small for any amount of TV watching. Apple could probably afford to buy Comcast (and Warner). That would suddenly be interesting.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> Again, it's harder than you think. That's why I said I'm not optimistic. I have the confidence that Apple can do an excellent job of creating a solid and intuitive UI and service. I have very little confidence that they will be able to make the sort of content deals necessary to make it have practical value. I don't think the bandwidth caps are a big issue, because 720p video is probably 1 GB/hour. You would have to watch 8 hours/day to hit a 250 GB limit.
- josephlord 14y ago> Big content doesn't give a fuck about open ecosystems. They care about cash money and to a lesser extent they care about control. What they don't want is a Netflix decimating and dominating the market. They may be wary of Apple because of their dominance in iTunes, but if they can grow the market (which their app store model seems like it has a shot) then big content is happy to play ball with them. From my experience the MSO's put the priority on control and know that with the control they will make money. They would probably feel at least as threatened by Apple as Netflix. The content producers care about cash money but with the best content the best money is to be made from exclusive regional deals. This is a bidding war the MSO's are in position to win (and still make a profit) and new entrants don't have the scale to make a profit if they bid enough to win. Apple could win the bidding but until they get the scale it won't pay them back.
- dasil003 14y agoWell yeah, I was just talking about content owners. The interesting thing about Apple is they are the first ones with a credible shot to outbid MSOs. Not that it will be easy, but no one parts customers from their cash like Apple.
- josephlord 14y agoApple can afford to outbid them but not profitably in the short term. It may still be worth a short term loss for long term gain but that hasn't been Apple's strategy up to this point; they have always aimed at profitability from launch so far.
- dasil003 14y agoOf course, no one is anywhere near making the kind of content money that MSOs are making, that's a given. The reason Apple is interesting is not even because of their cash pile, it's their proven ability to command a premium price. This is what Netflix and every other streaming company has failed to do. That's why Apple is interesting, but like I said, that doesn't make it easy.
- jonnathanson 14y agoFor the time being, yes, you are 100% right. But let's look at it on a more basic level. Content creators are looking for rents (recurrent economic gain) on intellectual property. In their eyes, they've manufactured a property, and now they're looking to make a return by way of charging people (not always customers directly, but somebody) to use it. At its simplest, this is no different from how a real estate developer builds a property, then seeks ROI by leasing the office space or apartment buildings. Putting aside the age-old debate about whether IP is actually something tangible, or whether the system is worthwhile, we can certainly agree that studios and networks are clinging violently to their current ways of earning those economic rents on IP. What would it take to get them to overturn the current model? What would it take to get them to see the value in an "open ecosystem"? Well, we'd need to convince TV studios and production companies that there's more money to be made in open distribution than there is in direct distribution to TV networks. TV networks are relatively safe, cash-rich (sometimes cash-stupid, even) places to "lay off" a property. They're willing, one-stop buyers for the IP the studios have been investing in and developing. Apple, Microsoft, Netflix, Amazon, Google, et al., will need, collectively or individually, to represent a distributed market for content that is at least as economically attractive as the TV networks, if not moreso, before we'll see a lot of movement. I am fairly confident that that will happen. And relatively soon. I work in the entertainment business, on the creative and production side. I can't tell you how many big names in talent, writing, producing, etc., are f-ing sick of the network system. Or how many big and small production companies are sick of it, and realize how much richer the open ecosystem could be. But nobody's doing anything major about it -- not yet, at any rate -- because the current cash cow (sale to networks) is still the best and easiest in town. I don't necessarily believe that Apple will, or should, get into the content development game. It's a crapshoot, and it's not suited to Apple's business model. But I do believe that production companies will, increasingly, start selling their content to everyone, and not just the networks. Conversely, I don't think the networks will change their tune. Not willingly. They will not be the first to change, at any rate. They'll resist, kicking and screaming, because their business models are inherently predicated on maintaining very tight control over distribution of the properties they've acquired. Unfortunately for them, they're stuck holding a piece of the overall content value chain that is increasingly outdated.
- 14y ago