4 ms·
> then you get cases like Sandvig v. Barr Sandvig "was brought by researchers who wished to find out whether employment websites engage in discrimination on th
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> then you get cases like Sandvig v. Barr
Sandvig "was brought by researchers who wished to find out whether employment websites engage in discrimination on the basis of race, gender or other protected characteristics" [1]. It was literally the researchers asking the question you asked and then getting an answer.
"he Court interpreted CFAA’s Access Provision rather narrowly to hold that the plaintiffs’ conduct was not criminal as they were neither exceeding authorized access, nor accessing password protected sites, but public sites. Construing violation of ToS as a potential crime under CFAA, the Court observed would allow private website owners to define the scope of criminal liability – thus constituting an improper delegation of legislative authority. Since their proposed actions were not criminal, the Court concluded that the researchers were free to conduct their study and dismissed the case."
Nobody was prosecuted. Researchers asked a clarifying question and got an answer.
[1] https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/sandvig-v-barr/ https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/sandvig...
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoRight. That's what I'm saying. It's used to intimidate people, which doesn't require actually prosecuting them because nearly all of them fold before it even gets to that point or are deterred from doing something they have a right to do because of the risk. Let's remember how the process works. First they threaten you, then if you don't fold they do a more thorough investigation to try to find ways to prove their case which makes you spend significant resources, then they decide whether to actually prosecute you. They don't actually do it if they can't find a way to make you look like a criminal, but that's why it needs to be unambiguous from the outset that they won't be able to. Otherwise people will fold at the point of being threatened because you'd have to spend resources you don't have and the deal you're offered gets worse because you made them work for it.
- tptacek 1y agoPost Van Buren, the legal concern in Sandvig (that doing "audit" studies that would require signing up for a bunch of accounts in ways that violate the ToS of commercial sites) is dead anyways everywhere in the US. The idea that mere violation of ToS is per se a violation of CFAA is off the table.
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agothe problem is it's only off the table until the Trump DOJ decides that they want to charge ex FBI members who investigated Trump with felonies for using an add blocker, and the supreme Court changes their mind since apparently the new law is that Trump can do whatever he wants
- tptacek 1y agoNo? It's a Supreme Court precedent, established under Trump judges. At the point where you're saying that doesn't matter, you might as well just go the final rhetorical millimeter and say none of the law matters.
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoAnd we had to live under the ambiguity for more than three decades because the law was so poorly considered, and it's still not clear exactly what it covers. Suppose some researchers are trying to collect enough data to see if a company is doing something untoward. They need a significant sample in order to figure it out, but the company has a very aggressive rate limit per IP address before they start giving HTTP 429 to that IP address for the rest of the day. If the researchers use more than one IP address so they can collect the data in less than 20 years, is that illegal? It shouldn't require a judge to be able to know that.
- tptacek 1y agoIt doesn't. The fact pattern you've just presented is settled law: it might be a tort, it might be some other violation of state law, but it's not a CFAA violation.
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoI feel like I purposely chose a fact pattern that couldn't meaningfully be distinguished from a DDoS except by the rate, which wasn't specified. I get that there are cases where someone exceeded a rate limit by a moderate amount and that was fine -- although it's still bad that figuring that out required them to go to court to begin with -- but it seems like we're missing the thing that tells you where the line is. Unless it's really not a violation to just permanently render someone's site inaccessible because you have a lot more bandwidth than them and constantly want the latest version of whatever's on it? Which is the problem with doing it this way. You don't have anyone working things through to come up with a good rule and give people clarity from the start, so instead it all gets decided slowly over time through expensive litigation.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]