4 ms·
The big problem with CFAA isn't particular to CFAA at all; it's that it shares the 2B1.1 loss table with all the other federal criminal statutes, and computers
by tptacek 1y ago
The big problem with CFAA isn't particular to CFAA at all; it's that it shares the 2B1.1 loss table with all the other federal criminal statutes, and computers are very good and very fast at running the number on that table up. It's a real problem and I'm not pushing back on the idea that something should change about it, but I wouldn't characterize the problem the way you do, as the law singling out crimes involving computers.
Part of the history of CFAA was that it was passed because the state of the law preceding it didn't comfortably criminalize things like malicious hacking and denial of service; you can do those things without tripping over wire fraud.
- terminalshort 1y agoThere ought to just be a blanket criminal law for intentionally causing financial damages to citizens over a certain amount. Fraud is typically a civil matter, but the problem comes when someone causes $5000 of fraud to 200 people, which is made much easier by the internet. It doesn't make financial sense to sue for that amount. If we had a law that intentionally causing $1 million or more of civil damages is also a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison this would allow DAs to apply well deserved criminal penalties without having the possibility of criminalizing harmless behavior.
- tptacek 1y agoFraud is almost definitionally not a civil matter. There is civil fraud, but it bears the same relationship to fraud as the Goldman's wrongful death case did to the OJ criminal case.
- terminalshort 1y agoI'm not talking about technical definitions. The fact is that if you have a fraud case in the USA, there's a 99% chance civil court is the only place it's ever going to be filed.
- tptacek 1y agoFrom where do you draw that statistic?
- terminalshort 1y agoIt's not a statistic. It's my personal experience in business and what my lawyers have told me. The 99% is just a number I pulled out of my ass to mean "basically always." If I were going to put money on it, though, I would say it's actually an understatement. Do you have any statistics?
- tptacek 1y agoYes: the DOJ reports on things like qui tam cases and on total recoveries from all criminal fraud cases, and I think you have the ratio flipped.
- terminalshort 1y agoThe DOJ??? Are you even trying to be serious here claiming the feds are getting involved in anything more than a vanishingly small percentage of fraud claims?
- AnthonyMouse 1y ago> it's that it shares the 2B1.1 loss table with all the other federal criminal statutes, and computers are very good and very fast at running the number on that table up. That's a problem with it, but another big one is that it's inherently ambiguous. The normal way you know if you're authorized to do something with a computer is that it processes the request. They're perfectly capable of refusing; you get "forbidden" or "access denied" but in that case you're not actually accessing it, you're just being informed that you're not allowed to right now. So for there to be a violation the computer would have to let you do something it isn't supposed to. But how are you supposed to know that then? On a lot of websites -- like this one -- you go to a page like https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=<user_id> and you get the user's profile. If you put in your user there then you can see your email address and edit your profile etc. If the server was misconfigured and showing everyone's email address when it isn't supposed to, how is someone supposed to know that? Venmo publishes their users' financial transactions. If you notice that and think it's weird and write a post about it, should the company -- possibly retroactively -- be able to decide that the data you're criticizing them for making public wasn't intended to be, and therefore your accessing it was a crime? If you notice this by accident when it's obvious the data shouldn't be public -- you saw it when you made a typo in the URL -- should there be a law that can put you in jail if you admit to this in the process of making the public aware of the company's mistake, even if your access resulted in no harm to anyone? The wording is too vague and it criminalizes too much. "Malicious hacking" might not always be wire fraud but in other cases it could be misappropriation of trade secrets etc., i.e. whatever the actual act of malice is. The problem with the CFAA is that it's more or less attempting to be the federal computer law against burglary (i.e. unlawful entry with the intent to commit a crime) except that it makes the "unlawful" part too hard to pin down and failed to include the part about intent to commit a crime, which allows it to be applied against people it ought not to.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> how is someone supposed to know that? When was the last CFAA prosecution where the perpetrator literally didn't know they were doing something unauthorised?
- 1y ago