3 ms·
I don’t know. Pm2.5 by definition doesn’t include gasses and as I understand it the issue is that the particulate matter, whatever it happens to be, gets in the
by notmyjob 11mo ago
I don’t know. Pm2.5 by definition doesn’t include gasses and as I understand it the issue is that the particulate matter, whatever it happens to be, gets in the bloodstream. Is there any particulate matter of that size that is not neurotoxic once it enters the bloodstream? I don’t know the answer but it seems like a legitimate question.
- blueflow 11mo agoAmino acids! I'm sure now some other HN poster will come up with an explanation how Amino Acids are still neurotoxic of some sort.
- tpm 11mo agoThat's too easy, glutamate is neurotoxic in high doses.
- blueflow 11mo agoWhat about sugar?
- notmyjob 11mo agopm2.5 is a metric used in assessing air quality. Amino acid aerosols are not a source of air pollution.
- blueflow 11mo agoamino acids droplets are pm2.5. pm2.5 refers to the particle size. See what i wrote in the other thread... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45784538 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45784538
- notmyjob 11mo agoPm2.5 is a specific particle size, yes, we do agree on that. Importantly, it is also a common measurement used in assessing air quality. In that context it is typically composed of particles from a set of common sources, like wildfires, industrial sources, automobile pollution, etc…. It is, in the context of air quality monitoring, never composed of amino acids. It seems valid to make claims about pm2.5 and health, even though the claim does not distinguish wildfire pm2.5 from pm2.5 from automobile pollution or other sources. Maybe I misunderstood you to be saying otherwise.
- blueflow 11mo agoYeah but which substances/sources is not given when you just say "Pm2.5". Which is what the article did. And depending on the actual substances you get different health effects or none at all.
- amluto 11mo agoOne would imagine that salt spray from the ocean (which can easily register as PM2.5) is mostly sodium chloride, is rather water-soluble, and is entirely harmless in your bloodstream in any quantity that you could plausibly inhale.
- notmyjob 11mo agoAs I understand it you are incorrect. Salt from sea breeze is pm10 not pm2.5. My information may be inaccurate but google backs it up.