3 ms·
The supreme court interprets the laws, including the constitution, and they've decided that being brown is sufficient reasonability.
by fragmede 1y ago
The supreme court interprets the laws, including the constitution, and they've decided that being brown is sufficient reasonability.
- estearum 1y agoNope they didn't decide that. It's actually even worse! A lot of Americans have the impression that SCOTUS keeps deciding in the administration's favor, but this is not true. SCOTUS is saying: "We're not going to hear this case right now, but we likely will in the future. In the meantime, we are going to overturn the lower court who did actually hear the case and allow the administration to continue its actions. No, we will not explain we think the lower court got wrong." Increasingly these SCOTUS orders totally unexplained which is a blatant violation of their judicial obligations, and they are frequently unsigned by the majority (conservative) Justices. Presumably because they don't want their names written on papers that they know will be understood by future generations to be totally indefensible. SCOTUS has proven itself functionally incapable of fulfilling its Constitutional duties and has proven that we need a lot more Justices. If you don't have the time to hear the cases we need you to hear, then the court needs to be scaled up and we can pick random panels to hear different cases. Nothing to do with policy disagreements (how would any American even know if they had a policy disagreement with an unexplained, unsigned SCOTUS order?) – we just need courts that can decide on things that are important to our country.
- potato3732842 1y agoFrankly it's a miracle it took this long to be a problem IMO. The supreme court over the years has watered down constitutional protections against government enforcement upon individuals massively because doing so was necessary to empower the government to enforce speeding tickets, financial regulation, environmental regulation, chase bootleggers, etc, etc, with it's power only constrained in practice by political optics. So now here we are, in a situation where the government is doing what it always does, levying what's essentially a criminal punishment (incarceration in this case, typically fines historically) in a case where allegedly no crime has been committed, and then give the accused only kangaroo court administrative process because it's not a crime, but now it's doing it at scale, flagrantly, loudly and against the political will of some of the locations it's doing it in. There are a lot of bricks in this road to hell and someone somewhere was issuing a warning as each one was laid. Should have listened.
- estearum 1y agoWhat are you talking about? This was a problem in 2012 and SCOTUS ruled unambiguously in Arizona vs United States that we cannot stop people based solely on their outward "apparent" immigration status. In SCOTUS's own words, "the usual predicate for an arrest is absent" and being merely "suspected of being removable... does not authorize an arrest." "As a general rule, it is not a crime for a removable alien to remain present in the United States. See INS v. Lopez-Mendoza, 468 U.S. 1032, 1038 (1984). If the police stop someone based on nothing more than possible removability, the usual predicate for an arrest is absent. When an alien is suspected of being removable, a federal official issues an administrative document called a Notice to Appear. See 8 U. S. C. §1229(a); 8 CFR §239.1(a) (2012). The form does not authorize an arrest." This is a MAGA and Heritage Foundation-driven reversal of VERY recently settled law. Absolutely not business as usual. https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/567/387/#tab-opinion-1970515 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/567/387/#tab-opi...
- potato3732842 1y agoI'm not even debating the legality of the stop. It doesn't matter. Whether or not the stop is legit the whole system from there on is a kangaroo court rife with rights violations as well. That's the real problem here. Hair splitting over the specific reason for a stop is a distraction. Even if you fix it it won't change much. Whether or not they can make the stop doesn't really matter. They'll find other ways to force people to produce their papers.
- estearum 1y agoIt literally changes whether brown-ish Americans can go about their day without being thrown on the ground in zipties or not. > They'll find other ways to force people to produce their papers Okay, so make them find other, increasingly illegal ways so they can be held accountable at a future date. Not quasi-blessed by SCOTUS's delay tactics.
- potato3732842 1y ago