4 ms·

The correct answer is that you’re a US citizen unless proved not to be. That’s how the US has always worked, since we’ve made a long-term societal decision not

The correct answer is that you’re a US citizen unless proved not to be. That’s how the US has always worked, since we’ve made a long-term societal decision not to require papers or allow extrajudicial treatment of our people. This app and everything behind it is foundationally wrong and unamerican.

UncleEntity 1y ago
The thing I think most people forget is why society made the decision that the government requires a neutral third-party to be consulted to determine if there is probable cause to conduct a search of "persons, houses, papers, and effects". Otherwise, you have a 'king' issuing general warrants which allow federal agents to search and seize anyone they want in the course of their investigations based on 'feels'. What makes it even worse is some court said racial profiling is sufficient reason to conduct a Terry stop to determine if the person is engaged in (civil) criminal activity and lets law enforcement demand they show their papers or be scanned by some dodgy app.
dylan604 1y ago
Who cares about correct answers. While technically correct, it means nothing in the world of today. Those in power believe unless you can prove you are a citizen, you are not. It is only correct answer if that's how people are behaving.
- tremon 1y ago
  You're being too generous. Once you are targeted for whatever reason, you are not a citizen unless you manage to publicly prove that you are, and they will fight tooth and nail to deny you any such opportunity.
dboreham 1y ago
How much you believe this might depend on which regional bubble you're in. I live in Montana and around here I have an expectation that while there might be the odd rogue law enforcement person roaming the state, generally things still work like America. Meanwhile last week I was in LA for a family thing and caught some TV ads playing there. That dog-killing gnome woman was on TV saying something like "We will hunt you down and deport you, there is no hiding, leave now". Initially I thought I was watching some comedy skit, but no it was an official US government advert. Whether I'm in Montana or in LA vastly changes my perception of what's considered ok in America today.
4ndrewl 1y ago
Was unamerican. Seems to the rest of world that this is very much what America is now.
somenameforme 1y ago
See: 8 U.S.C. § 1304(e) : "Every alien, eighteen years of age and over, shall at all times carry with him and have in his personal possession any certificate of alien registration or alien registration receipt card issued to him pursuant to subsection (d)." [1] So aliens are indeed required to carry papers at all times. The balance between the rights of citizens and the obligations of aliens comes in the form of probable cause. It's similar to how a cop can't pull you over and just randomly search your car without reason, but if he has probable cause, then suddenly he can. An ICE officer can't just detain somebody for having an accent or whatever, but if they have probable cause to think the person may not be a citizen then they have a substantial amount of leverage to affirm that. Probable cause has been tested somewhat rigorously in the courts and really means probable cause and not the knee-jerk obvious abuses like 'he's brown!' [1] - https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1304 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1304
- convolvatron 1y ago
  the Supreme Court has recently determined, in Noem v. Perdomo, that racial profiling by ICE is indeed completely .. acceptable? idk what the right word for 'legal but not legal' is.
  - Izkata 1y ago
    That ruling wasn't based on race, it was based on a whole bunch of factors (including: high amount of illegal immigrants in the area in question, jobs and locations that attract illegal immigrants due to not needing paperwork, etc). It was also not final, it was temporary pending another appeal.
    - actionfromafar 1y ago
      The ruling was just ”let’s play for time, this is looking fun and interesting. Keep it up team!”
- matthewdgreen 1y ago
  You are describing rules that pertain to non-citizens. U.S. citizens are not required to carry proof of citizenship ever and they can't legally be arrested or detained for this. The most that legally ICE can do to a citizen is briefly stop them to ask questions. Anything beyond that is an illegal arrest, full stop. There is a lot of constitutional law here, not a lot of ambiguity. While mistakes happen, and ICE is clearly becoming more eager to violate the law (see TFA), that doesn't mean we should be unclear about what the law says. In particular, prioritizing the (incorrect) results from an app over any sort of claim or presentation of proof is illegal.
refurb 1y ago
You’re ignoring the cases where people produce fraudulent documentation proving they are a citizen. Do you just throw up your hands “i guess there is nothing we can do”? What I find entertaining as a non-US citizen is how border enforcement is table stakes in every other country I’ve lived in (5 so far). Even the left doesn’t question it, it’s a basic function of a government. Even the less developed countries have relatively straightforward enforcement. You produce proof you’re there legally or you’re put on the next flight home. Since I lived in the US people keep asking me why some Americans don’t want border security. I don’t have a good answer.
- habinero 1y ago
  > You’re ignoring the cases where people produce fraudulent documentation proving they are a citizen. Citation needed lol.
  - refurb 1y ago
    “In Fiscal Year 2023, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officers in the Cincinnati area alone intercepted and identified more than 6,800 fraudulent, counterfeit, or stolen documents.” https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cincinnati-cbp-intercepts-thousands-fraudulent-and-counterfeit https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cincinnati-... That ONE CBP office in the US. And it’s not even in a state with a high population of illegal aliens. There are 20 offices in the US. And sure creating fraudulent documents from scratch isn’t easy. But it’s not that hard to use someone else’s identity to get documents that support US citizenship. Hell, a paper social security card is proof as long as it doesn’t say “NOT WORK AUTHORIZED on it. So it wouldn’t even be that unusual to locate an alien that the database says (correctly) has a deportation order but for them to claim US citizenship and even produce a document that looks like they are. You can even read a nice CBP report on the problems they have with fraudulent documents. https://www.oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/assets/2025-09/OIG-25-40-Sep25.pdf https://www.oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/assets/2025-09/O...
    - matthewdgreen 1y ago
RemainsOfTheDay 1y ago
[dead]

UncleEntity 1y ago

The thing I think most people forget is why society made the decision that the government requires a neutral third-party to be consulted to determine if there is probable cause to conduct a search of "persons, houses, papers, and effects". Otherwise, you have a 'king' issuing general warrants which allow federal agents to search and seize anyone they want in the course of their investigations based on 'feels'. What makes it even worse is some court said racial profiling is sufficient reason to conduct a Terry stop to determine if the person is engaged in (civil) criminal activity and lets law enforcement demand they show their papers or be scanned by some dodgy app.

dylan604 1y ago

Who cares about correct answers. While technically correct, it means nothing in the world of today. Those in power believe unless you can prove you are a citizen, you are not. It is only correct answer if that's how people are behaving.

tremon 1y ago
You're being too generous. Once you are targeted for whatever reason, you are not a citizen unless you manage to publicly prove that you are, and they will fight tooth and nail to deny you any such opportunity.

dboreham 1y ago

How much you believe this might depend on which regional bubble you're in. I live in Montana and around here I have an expectation that while there might be the odd rogue law enforcement person roaming the state, generally things still work like America. Meanwhile last week I was in LA for a family thing and caught some TV ads playing there. That dog-killing gnome woman was on TV saying something like "We will hunt you down and deport you, there is no hiding, leave now". Initially I thought I was watching some comedy skit, but no it was an official US government advert. Whether I'm in Montana or in LA vastly changes my perception of what's considered ok in America today.

4ndrewl 1y ago

Was unamerican. Seems to the rest of world that this is very much what America is now.

somenameforme 1y ago

See: 8 U.S.C. § 1304(e) : "Every alien, eighteen years of age and over, shall at all times carry with him and have in his personal possession any certificate of alien registration or alien registration receipt card issued to him pursuant to subsection (d)." [1] So aliens are indeed required to carry papers at all times. The balance between the rights of citizens and the obligations of aliens comes in the form of probable cause. It's similar to how a cop can't pull you over and just randomly search your car without reason, but if he has probable cause, then suddenly he can. An ICE officer can't just detain somebody for having an accent or whatever, but if they have probable cause to think the person may not be a citizen then they have a substantial amount of leverage to affirm that. Probable cause has been tested somewhat rigorously in the courts and really means probable cause and not the knee-jerk obvious abuses like 'he's brown!' [1] - https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1304 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1304

convolvatron 1y ago
the Supreme Court has recently determined, in Noem v. Perdomo, that racial profiling by ICE is indeed completely .. acceptable? idk what the right word for 'legal but not legal' is.
- Izkata 1y ago
  That ruling wasn't based on race, it was based on a whole bunch of factors (including: high amount of illegal immigrants in the area in question, jobs and locations that attract illegal immigrants due to not needing paperwork, etc). It was also not final, it was temporary pending another appeal.
  - actionfromafar 1y ago
    The ruling was just ”let’s play for time, this is looking fun and interesting. Keep it up team!”
matthewdgreen 1y ago
You are describing rules that pertain to non-citizens. U.S. citizens are not required to carry proof of citizenship ever and they can't legally be arrested or detained for this. The most that legally ICE can do to a citizen is briefly stop them to ask questions. Anything beyond that is an illegal arrest, full stop. There is a lot of constitutional law here, not a lot of ambiguity. While mistakes happen, and ICE is clearly becoming more eager to violate the law (see TFA), that doesn't mean we should be unclear about what the law says. In particular, prioritizing the (incorrect) results from an app over any sort of claim or presentation of proof is illegal.

refurb 1y ago

You’re ignoring the cases where people produce fraudulent documentation proving they are a citizen. Do you just throw up your hands “i guess there is nothing we can do”? What I find entertaining as a non-US citizen is how border enforcement is table stakes in every other country I’ve lived in (5 so far). Even the left doesn’t question it, it’s a basic function of a government. Even the less developed countries have relatively straightforward enforcement. You produce proof you’re there legally or you’re put on the next flight home. Since I lived in the US people keep asking me why some Americans don’t want border security. I don’t have a good answer.

habinero 1y ago
> You’re ignoring the cases where people produce fraudulent documentation proving they are a citizen. Citation needed lol.
- refurb 1y ago
  “In Fiscal Year 2023, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officers in the Cincinnati area alone intercepted and identified more than 6,800 fraudulent, counterfeit, or stolen documents.” https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cincinnati-cbp-intercepts-thousands-fraudulent-and-counterfeit https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cincinnati-... That ONE CBP office in the US. And it’s not even in a state with a high population of illegal aliens. There are 20 offices in the US. And sure creating fraudulent documents from scratch isn’t easy. But it’s not that hard to use someone else’s identity to get documents that support US citizenship. Hell, a paper social security card is proof as long as it doesn’t say “NOT WORK AUTHORIZED on it. So it wouldn’t even be that unusual to locate an alien that the database says (correctly) has a deportation order but for them to claim US citizenship and even produce a document that looks like they are. You can even read a nice CBP report on the problems they have with fraudulent documents. https://www.oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/assets/2025-09/OIG-25-40-Sep25.pdf https://www.oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/assets/2025-09/O...
  - matthewdgreen 1y ago

RemainsOfTheDay 1y ago

[dead]