4 ms·
As much as I love Bret Victor's ideas, I feel this is a bit harsh on Khan Academy. There's nothing wrong with criticism, but it shouldn't be your only kind of f
by modeless 14y ago
As much as I love Bret Victor's ideas, I feel this is a bit harsh on Khan Academy. There's nothing wrong with criticism, but it shouldn't be your only kind of feedback. Even if Khan Academy did nothing right (which I think is clearly false) they should at least deserve praise for attacking the problem at all, when so many people are content to ignore it.
If you're trying to lead a revolution in programming, witholding praise from your strongest supporters isn't the way to go about it.
- DigitalJack 14y agoI can see how it can be read as harsh. What I see is someone who cares very deeply about the message he is trying to get out. He cares so much that when someone falls short while citing his work as inspiration, he feels it's doing the world a disservice not to address the short comings.
- phleet 14y agoSpeaking as one of the interns that worked on the project, I don't really feel that this was too harsh. Had he focused on all the things that were wrong with it and torn it to pieces, I would be inclined to agree, but he's provided a number of very specific ways in which the environment could be improved. Some of these ideas were considered and not implemented for practical reasons, others were left out due to time constraints, and some we honestly just didn't think of. On the particular note of practicality, we were trying to make the best thing we could make exist now. I hope that Khan Academy Computer Science in its current state looks laughable in a few years - both compared to what it becomes and compared to what other people have built.
- zethraeus 14y agoI'm curious, were you guys ever in contact with Bret during the project?