4 ms·
Where's your sense of history? People wrote this sort of thing back 10 years ago, when Ruby was becoming popular. People wrote posts saying that Ruby would take
by dalke 14y ago
Where's your sense of history? People wrote this sort of thing back 10 years ago, when Ruby was becoming popular. People wrote posts saying that Ruby would take over from Python, and others replied saying that no, it wouldn't. The 'fact that the author wrote this post' is nothing new - it's more of the same.
And "2-3 years back"? Paul Graham's "The Python Paradox" was in 2004 and Peter Norvig's "How to Write a Spelling Corrector" was 2007. Neither of those were turning points. Python was, long ago, chosen as one of the three main languages at Google. Can you identify what it was 2-3 years ago which indicated that it was the hip language de jour?
Congratulations about Perl6 advances. It was the cumbersomeness of Perl5 objects and dealing with complex data types which helped me switch to Python, back in the late 1990s.
- cygx 14y agoIt's hard to predict the long-term popularity of languages from history. For example, look at the P*-languages (Perl, Python, PHP, Ruby) If I'm not mistaken, peak popularity went something like this: Perl->PHP->Python->Ruby->? Now, look at the release dates of these languages (according to Wikipedia's 'appeared in'): 1987 Perl 1991 Python 1995 PHP 1995 Ruby While Perl and PHP got popular pretty fast, it took years for Python and Ruby to gain traction. All of these language still have reasonably vibrant communities, even though Javascript appears to be 'hot' right now.
- dalke 14y agoI've been trying to get a sense of popularity. All I can find is the "TIOBE Programming Community Index." I looked at the chart for the last 10 years of numbers. Perl started declining in 2005. PHP's popularity seems to have been 2004-2010. Ruby's was 2007-2010, though it seems to be making a comeback. Python's was 2004-2011, and it again seems to be on the rise again. Those are relative numbers. In absolute numbers, PHP is ranked higher than VB, then Python, Perl, Ruby, and Javascript. It doesn't seem reasonable to really talk of peak usage over the last 10 years. It might be possible to talk about "most mentioned by the popular bloggers", but that's also a different metric.
- chromatic 14y agoAll I can find is the "TIOBE Programming Community Index." You might as well not bother. TIOBE is excessively vague about what it measures to the point that no one's been able to reproduce its results. Worse, it's never demonstrated that the number of searches it measures has a strong correlation with usage. Worst, it confused the Google Chrome browser with an implementation of Pascal for quite a while.
- dalke 14y agoAgreed. The thing is, I can't find anything better, so such questions as "when did the popularity of language X peak?" seem unanswerable.[1] We are left with anecdotal impressions, and my own experience ;) says that those are even more suspect than TIOBE's numbers. Also, I was looking for popularity, not usage, although these two numbers are intertwined and hard to disentangle. [1] That's not quite true. http://langpop.com/ http://langpop.com/ for example has what appears to be a more well-defined method of accumulating that data. However, "Last data update: Wed Apr 13 14:57:11 +0200 2011", the operator is no longer interested in the project, and would like to sell the site. I cannot find trend data, and my guess is that that's reserved for whomever will buy the site. So it might be answerable if I want to spend money on it.
- nacker 14y agoWhere is the sense of history of someone whose entire experience of programming probably extends no further than 2-3 years into the past? This is a systemic problem in software. The average age of a "cutting-edge" programmer is always going to be under 30. People in their 20's are at a peak of performance, but merely in the foothills of judgement and knowledge of history, even software history. Those who are successful in their careers in software become managers in their 30's and cease to take part in debates about languages, which accounts for their puerile tenor. I'm nevertheless glad to see that you are still keeping an eye on things, Mr Dalke!
- dalke 14y agoDo you have any evidence which helps confirm that "people in their 20's are at a peak of performance"? I know in my case that in my 20s I implemented an algorithm for finding the maximum common subgraph between a set of N graphs. While in my 40s I created a new algorithm for finding the same, which is faster and more flexible. But in my 20s I worked a lot harder, which means I produced more code. And got burned out a couple of times. If you measure performance by LOC, then I might agree with you. But did Linus Torvalds and John Carmack become worse once they got into their 30s? What of Don Knuth? And Guido van Rossum was born in 1956 making him over 30 when he started Python. I think Guido has long since learned not to care about language debates on HN. ;)