3 ms·
The business model is that it'll have users install software that replaces 15% of third party ads on web pages with their own ads. This sort of ad replacement h
by jimrandomh 14y ago
The business model is that it'll have users install software that replaces 15% of third party ads on web pages with their own ads. This sort of ad replacement has actually been done plenty of times before: by malware and by shady toolbars. Pretty much no one is going to be okay with this. The music industry and the US government hate the guy's guts; it's directly stealing money from Google; it wants to directly compete with iTunes; it's directly stealing money from every random blogger and press outlet that might cover it; and other companies doing exactly this was responsible for destroying Microsoft Windows' reputation in the eyes of consumers. Oh, and it's a backdoor held by someone considered wildly untrustworthy. So on the list of parties that have a vested interest in seeing it fail, we have:
- The music industry
- The US government
- All ad-supported press outlets and blogs
- Microsoft, Apple, and Google
- The computer security industry
Oh, and it's also probably illegal (under copyright and tortious interference grounds). I think this is really just a signaling ploy; Dotcom wants to be able to say that he tried to come up with a monetization model for the music industry. But to say that this is doomed a fairly significant understatement.
- bduerst 14y agoIt will add another layer to the internet tug of war on advertising. Hulu and other ad-dependent sites already detect ad-block and won't give you content unless you disable it. I see media providers doing the same to protect their interests. The question is - will enough sites quash this ad-replacement service from the get go to prevent a large userbase from forming?
- veb 14y agoNobody will be okay with that? You're joking right? Every person out there who aren't technical, won't give a shit. Free music? They'll do anything. I bet these people will think, "It replaces advertisements that I don't even see anymore because I'm so used to them? Well okay!"
- moe 14y agoIs "free music" really a selling point anymore? Between grooveshark, youtube, a dozen "youtube frontends" and a dozen streaming services that will fill you up for $10/month it seems very much like a strawman.