4 ms·

Is this related to internal monologue? I don't see mentioned in my view.

Sharlin 1y ago
Yeah, aphantasia is talked about a lot but similarly whether people have an internal monologue, and to what degree, varies a lot. But they're not necessarily highly correlated, if at all.
ourguile 1y ago
I've seen some sections discussing memory, but not necessarily internal monologue.
drdec 1y ago
I don't think so. Anecdotally I know someone with aphantasia and they report having an internal monologue.
- khazhoux 1y ago
  I’m aphantasic and can hear internal monologue just fine.
- racingmars 1y ago
  From everything I've read about aphantasia, I'm certain it described me -- I have absolutely no ability to consciously "visualize" things in my head (I was also surprised to learn that some/most people sometimes experience a smell sensation if they recall smells, or "hear" music when they think about music or have a song stuck in their head, etc.) Really the only thing in my head is my internal monologue. If I'm thinking about something I've seen, it's my internal monologue "saying," with words, physical attributes I remember about it. If a song is stuck in my head, it's my internal monologue (in my own voice) signing the lyrics or my own voice humming the tune in my head. No sensation of it being the original artist or the actual instruments, it's 100% my own voice in my own head. I have a friend who says she does not have any inner monologue at all, and thinks entirely visually. I can't imagine! We're on the pretty extreme opposite ends of the spectrum of how we think, apparently.
  - kbrkbr 1y ago
    Yes, that. Same here. I still remember (semantically) that my parents laughed at me, when they told me to count sheep to fall asleep and I told them all I can see is darkness and white dots when I close my eyes. They probably thought I was joking.
YcYc10 1y ago
I think it might be. I'm pretty sure I don't have an internal monologue the way people describe it, and I definitely can't conjure up actual images in my mind. I can however imagine sounds or music.
aurumque 1y ago
There is a related set of experiences that articles like this tend to conflate. * presence of internal monologue * ability for visualization * ability for audiation * affective memory (remembering feelings) * SDAM (weak autobiographical memory) It speaks to the larger questions around the human experience, and that we are only now discovering the many ways it differs for each individual.

Yeah, aphantasia is talked about a lot but similarly whether people have an internal monologue, and to what degree, varies a lot. But they're not necessarily highly correlated, if at all.

ourguile 1y ago

I've seen some sections discussing memory, but not necessarily internal monologue.

drdec 1y ago

I don't think so. Anecdotally I know someone with aphantasia and they report having an internal monologue.

khazhoux 1y ago
I’m aphantasic and can hear internal monologue just fine.
racingmars 1y ago
From everything I've read about aphantasia, I'm certain it described me -- I have absolutely no ability to consciously "visualize" things in my head (I was also surprised to learn that some/most people sometimes experience a smell sensation if they recall smells, or "hear" music when they think about music or have a song stuck in their head, etc.) Really the only thing in my head is my internal monologue. If I'm thinking about something I've seen, it's my internal monologue "saying," with words, physical attributes I remember about it. If a song is stuck in my head, it's my internal monologue (in my own voice) signing the lyrics or my own voice humming the tune in my head. No sensation of it being the original artist or the actual instruments, it's 100% my own voice in my own head. I have a friend who says she does not have any inner monologue at all, and thinks entirely visually. I can't imagine! We're on the pretty extreme opposite ends of the spectrum of how we think, apparently.
- kbrkbr 1y ago
  Yes, that. Same here. I still remember (semantically) that my parents laughed at me, when they told me to count sheep to fall asleep and I told them all I can see is darkness and white dots when I close my eyes. They probably thought I was joking.

YcYc10 1y ago

I think it might be. I'm pretty sure I don't have an internal monologue the way people describe it, and I definitely can't conjure up actual images in my mind. I can however imagine sounds or music.

aurumque 1y ago

There is a related set of experiences that articles like this tend to conflate. * presence of internal monologue * ability for visualization * ability for audiation * affective memory (remembering feelings) * SDAM (weak autobiographical memory) It speaks to the larger questions around the human experience, and that we are only now discovering the many ways it differs for each individual.