3 ms·

This "research" and data access wouldn't be allowed under the DSA, because (i) the researcher didn't provide any data protection safeguards, (ii) his university

by pms 11mo ago

This "research" and data access wouldn't be allowed under the DSA, because (i) the researcher didn't provide any data protection safeguards, (ii) his university (and data protection officer) didn't assume legal liability for his research, (iii) his research isn't focused on systemic risks to society.

tguvot 11mo ago
not sure what's the point that you are making. but under "common sense comments act of 2054" unclear comments are not allowed.
- brendoelfrendo 11mo ago
  The article for this post is about the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA). Since the original comment argues against research access to data by arguing that "Cambridge Analytica was research as well," another poster chimed in to rebut that assertion by arguing that Aleksandr Kogan's research would not have been allowed access to user data under the DSA and thus, that specific legal concern is moot.
  - tguvot 11mo ago
    kogan "research" harvested data through application and he was outside of eu. so even it was happening today, whatever he did is irrelevant to EU/DSA unless they plan to chase everybody across the globe. somewhat like ofcom going after 4chan
    - shakna 11mo ago
      That's precisely what the EU is doing with Clearview AI [0]. > Max Schrems: “We even run cross-border criminal procedures for stolen bikes, so we hope that the public prosecutor also takes action when the personal data of billions of people was stolen – as has been confirmed by multiple authorities.” [0] https://noyb.eu/en/criminal-complaint-against-facial-recognition-company-clearview-ai https://noyb.eu/en/criminal-complaint-against-facial-recogni...
      - tguvot 11mo ago
        Based on your quote looks like this is what eu not doing. I like this quote more Max Schrems: “Clearview AI seems to simply ignore EU fundamental rights and just spits in the face of EU authorities.”
        shakna 11mo ago
        Hence why the upgrade to criminal charges against the company's officials. There is _not_ a lack of action on behalf of the EU, here. They are "chasing" those responsible.
        tguvot 11mo ago
        Ohh.. the upgrade will surely make them rethink the error of their ways and will come begging EU for forgiveness.

by pms 11mo ago

tguvot 11mo ago

not sure what's the point that you are making. but under "common sense comments act of 2054" unclear comments are not allowed.

brendoelfrendo 11mo ago
The article for this post is about the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA). Since the original comment argues against research access to data by arguing that "Cambridge Analytica was research as well," another poster chimed in to rebut that assertion by arguing that Aleksandr Kogan's research would not have been allowed access to user data under the DSA and thus, that specific legal concern is moot.
- tguvot 11mo ago
  kogan "research" harvested data through application and he was outside of eu. so even it was happening today, whatever he did is irrelevant to EU/DSA unless they plan to chase everybody across the globe. somewhat like ofcom going after 4chan
  - shakna 11mo ago
    That's precisely what the EU is doing with Clearview AI [0]. > Max Schrems: “We even run cross-border criminal procedures for stolen bikes, so we hope that the public prosecutor also takes action when the personal data of billions of people was stolen – as has been confirmed by multiple authorities.” [0] https://noyb.eu/en/criminal-complaint-against-facial-recognition-company-clearview-ai https://noyb.eu/en/criminal-complaint-against-facial-recogni...
    - tguvot 11mo ago
      Based on your quote looks like this is what eu not doing. I like this quote more Max Schrems: “Clearview AI seems to simply ignore EU fundamental rights and just spits in the face of EU authorities.”
      - shakna 11mo ago
        Hence why the upgrade to criminal charges against the company's officials. There is _not_ a lack of action on behalf of the EU, here. They are "chasing" those responsible.
        tguvot 11mo ago
        Ohh.. the upgrade will surely make them rethink the error of their ways and will come begging EU for forgiveness.